4 ms·
>Is there anything to prevent the pay for our most important and meaningful jobs from approaching zero? If people are willing to do something for free, why sho
by gruez 4y ago
>Is there anything to prevent the pay for our most important and meaningful jobs from approaching zero?
If people are willing to do something for free, why should we pay above that? If there aren't enough people willing to do it for free, we can raise the prices we offer until we get enough takers. This is microeconomics 101. The implied problem of "if the pay for our most important and meaningful jobs approach zero, wouldn't there be no one to do it?" doesn't exist, and makes as much sense as "Nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded!"
- Waterluvian 4y agoYeah. It’s the wrong argument, really. Economics isn’t a charity. You can’t really argue “I deserve to be paid more!” (Unless you’re not into capitalism, which is valid) I think the more valid foundational argument is whether or not the government is incorruptly ensuring the system is functioning equitably. That is: the solution to this perceived problem isn’t to tip the scale. It’s to ensure the scale isn’t being tipped.
- anothernewdude 4y agoEconomic concerns are bigger than that. Quality of education is core to a well functioning society. A dollar spend now on education is worth the investment.
- pauldenton 4y agoYes, but there's no evidence that throwing more money at the problem results in better outcomes https://youtu.be/f0JorXgqxiU https://youtu.be/f0JorXgqxiU Camden can be the highest funded and lowest performing school in the state. Inner city schools often have the highest amount of money available and lowest performance
- ipaddr 4y agoBecause parents and social expectations play a greater role than money
- coredog64 4y agoThere's a danger in classifying education as an investment. If I look at how my investments are performing, and I see a broad group that isn't doing well, I don't shrug and say "thems the breaks", I move my money where it will do better. To bring this back to the topic, if we look at the outcomes from "investing" in majority-minority school districts, are we going to decide that it's yielding appropriate returns? If not, what happens next?
- nemo44x 4y agoIt’s not really a capitalism thing (private ownership) as much as a free market/market economy thing. Although intertwined they aren’t necessarily the same thing. IMO a lot of gripes about “capitalism” are really grievances with competing in the market economy.
- thfuran 4y ago>The implied problem of "if the pay for our most important and meaningful jobs approach zero, wouldn't there be no one to do it?" That is not the implied problem.
- gruez 4y agoWhat's the implied problem then? If there's no problem of pay going to zero, why fret about it going to zero?
- rocketbop 4y agoTeachers aren’t robots, it’s not just an important to have a bum in the seat. The quality of the teacher has a large impact on student outcomes, and if reasonable wages aren’t available many potentially excellent teachers will do something else while only the most incompetent will go into the profession.
- smugma 4y agoBy this argument, teachers should be paid more. There are teacher shortages across the US and the article touches on shortages in Oz. https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/05/12/free-training-teacher-shortage-apprenticeship/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/05/12/free-tra...
- renewiltord 4y agoInteresting phenomenon, actually. I wonder if market pricing for teachers would result in higher pay or more teachers: I.e. if lowering pay were easy, or if firing were easy. Certainly some aspect of compensation must pay for the hiring risk. And the other thing is that government organizations are slow to react to market forces, so as the majority employer in the space, they're frequently likely to just be behind. Some sort of incentive mechanism for cost cutting may work but it's hard to build that without it misfiring. If I were in charge of an education system, I'd definitely hard bargain to keep teacher costs low because in downturns it's the cost I have least control over managing. There'd be a delta in the fair market price as a result. In addition, my boss would likely also try to keep my budget low since if any extra would go into the piece that has most market power - unionized labour.
- mjhay 4y agoPeople thinking they understand economics because they took a 101 class is a major problem. Case in point: this post.