3 ms·
> Property rights exist because when you steal someone’s car, you’re depriving them of the usage of that car. No, property rights exist because of a social val
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Property rights exist because when you steal someone’s car, you’re depriving them of the usage of that car.
No, property rights exist because of a social value judgement that their existence is a net benefit. The particular structure of some aspects enforcing property rights in one class of property (tangible personal property) reflect that. (Mostly, in the Anglo-American system, this is addressed by the theft and conversion crimes and torts.) But the other main class of tangible property (real property) doesn’t really have the same nature, nor do most other elements of the broad class of intangible personal property, and the primary means of enforcing them against encroachment tend to be oriented around trespass (in common law terms, though there are special terms for it for some specific subtypes of property, such as as “infringement” for most IP rights) rather than theft/conversion, which also applies to tangible personal property (trespass to chattels).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Ferret7446 4y agoProperty rights exist due to the laws of physics allowing them to be enforced. If you physically possess a car, you can use it, and if someone steals it, the police can go physically take it away from them and return it to you. You can't meaningfully enforce intellectual property rights in the general case. If someone learns the secret KFC recipe, you can't take it away from them.