3 ms·
Argument for discussion: with the advent of large language models, copyright is not only untenable, it's a literal threat to the progress of civilization.
by CamperBob2 4y ago
Argument for discussion: with the advent of large language models, copyright is not only untenable, it's a literal threat to the progress of civilization.
- wilg 4y agoI agree. Perhaps there's a productive way to leverage this to publicly (or privately) support and fund artists, authors, and others who are critical to properly training our finest computer programs.
- permo-w 4y agois making bigger and better neural networks really the same as progressing civilisation? I think Hacker News is one of the few places where the majority would say yes I would say stripping artists of their rights is the opposite of progress
- wilg 4y agoIf AI powered tools are able to provide a lot of value (they probably will), and they require lots of data (they probably will), then it's a conversation worth having. Though artists are often very leftist and/or liberal they tend to be extremely conservative about intellectual property rights because their livelihood depends on it. This is fair enough, but unfortunately even outside of AI, intellectual property law is already overzealous. We probably need alternate funding models or something.
- tpxl 3y agoTheft providing value doesn't excuse theft. These giant companies can absolutely afford to properly license their datasets, and if they don't want to license them, they can create them. Mozilla has been creating an open dataset for text-to-speech/speech-to-text for years now with thousands of contributors, why can't Google do the same?
- zelphirkalt 3y agoProbably, because they did not attain actual consent by the people whose data they use.
- CaptainFever 3y agoIf you disallow “theft” (copying is not theft, let alone training), then as you said, only giant companies can afford to train datasets by licensing or creating data (e.g. Adobe, Getty, Disney). These statements always ignore that libre AI models exist, and rely on the weakening of copyright laws to let small creators use AI and compete against corporations that will use AI regardless, because once again, they have the resources to license giant datasets and we don’t.
- aftbit 3y ago>Theft providing value doesn't excuse theft. I don't know about that. One of the biggest problems IMO with most theft is that is is net value negative. Someone steals my $500 cell phone and fences it for $100. The fence resells it for $250 to some poor sap who can't use it because it is IMSI banned. Value is destroyed. This is why many consider it okay for a starving man to steal bread to eat. His value (not starving) is greater than the cost to the baker (1 loaf of bread).
- zelphirkalt 3y agoIf you take that point of view, I hope you also apply it to everything and not just some segment that is convenient. It means for example, that no music creator, no software company, no movie maker, etc. has any copyright. I would be OK with that, but only if that was universally applying, and not just for things that can be laundered by some actually existing AI.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]