3 ms·
I'm guessing a large part of the controversy is related to the fact that reading has many different aspects. Possibly the article is referring to the same kind
by tsimionescu 3y ago
I'm guessing a large part of the controversy is related to the fact that reading has many different aspects. Possibly the article is referring to the same kind of reading you're referring to - technical books on various real-world topics.
However, it's much harder to see the value in doing anything like the article is suggesting for literature. Is there really much to gain from writing a summary of Virginia Woolf's To The Lighthouse, or of a book of poetry? Is that even the right way to engage with the material?
- chubot 3y agoOh definitely, and I think part of the pushback is framing it as "writing summaries". That sounds like homework. :) But I would just call it engaging with the ideas after you read. So talking with a friend about a book is just as good, and even better. And writing a comment on a forum can be just as good, as it's an active thing too. I sometimes write comments and then link them from my wiki. I've had a GoodReads account in the past, but somehow it seems a bit shallow and artificial ... almost a bit like homework. It's better if the topics naturally come up, but if they don't, I still find writing notes to myself to enhance the reading experience. I mean you may spend 1 week or 8 weeks reading a book. I don't see why spending 5 to 30 minutes writing notes a few days after can be viewed as bad. I totally agree with the author in that those 5 or 30 minutes is way better spent writing about what you read, rather than 5 or 30 minutes reading something new that you may or may not retain. And again I'm focusing on reading non-fiction for retention, not literature. (For better or worse, I read WAY more non-fiction than literature)