4 ms·
Home schooling is one of those topics where there seems to be a huge difference between theory and practice. The theory is great: You're the parent. You are mot
by ryandrake 4y ago
Home schooling is one of those topics where there seems to be a huge difference between theory and practice. The theory is great: You're the parent. You are motivated by educational outcome. You believe your children can get a better education than at public schools. You have the time, patience, and resources to do a better job at home. The outcome is better-educated kids who get to skip the (admittedly terrible) abuses of the public school system. For some homeschooled kids, the above is actually what happened. You'll find all their glowing reviews of home schooling in the comment section below.
In practice, at least in the USA, it's different. By and large (with exceptions, obviously), you are motivated by religious separatism. You are not worried about the quality of the education, but the content. You see the public school system as uninvited ideology and home schooling as a loophole you can use to avoid it. The outcome is worse-educated kids who skipped entire subjects and are not even remotely prepared for higher education.
My wife's "moms groups" are always pushing homeschooling, and the sales pitch is never the quality of education. It's always that you can avoid those nasty topics like sex ed and evolution and that you can use the Bible in all your classes. More recently, during and after COVID, the pitches also included avoiding "political indoctrination". I know multiple actual families who pulled their kids out of public school for religious and ideological reasons, but nobody who did so with a legitimate intention of providing a higher quality factual education. Obviously they exist and a few are posting here, but I'd be shocked if those were even 10% of cases.
I'll never forget this clip[1] interviewing a homeschool family, where the poor kid looks mortified that she doesn't know even basic 2nd grade math, with her mom smugly laughing about it. These products of home schooling are not posting their success stories on HN.
1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QyNzSW7I4qw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QyNzSW7I4qw
- simonsarris 4y agoThe practice is great too. Almost all studies and surveys done to date suggest that homeschoolers do better across pretty much every measured metric, and that this gap is widening over time to favor homeschooling even more. If you've ever heard about Bloom's 2-sigma problem, this should be unsurprising. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom%27s_2_sigma_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom%27s_2_sigma_problem There are of course problems with survey data, but it's a huge mistake to think that homeschooling = the worst anecdotes you can find on TV. > By and large (with exceptions, obviously), you are motivated by religious separatism. This is not true. In the National Household Education Survey (2016), only 16% of homeschoolers said religious motivation was their primary reason, and only 5% moral education was their primary reason. Dissatisfaction with school academic quality and concern about environment at school were the two primary drivers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]