3 ms·
> fingerprint, face scan, probably your retina scan, maybe your voice identification Technically, those are "things you are", not "things you have". A Yubikey
by JohnFen 4y ago
> fingerprint, face scan, probably your retina scan, maybe your voice identification
Technically, those are "things you are", not "things you have". A Yubikey would be an example of a "thing you have".
I think the ideal is that you're supposed to use a hardware key that uses a biometric like a fingerprint to unlock it. Then the passkey itself is the "thing you know", the hardware key is the "thing you have", and the fingerprint is the "thing you are".
But in practice, that's pretty onerous, so the passkey implementation being discussed eases up on those requirements a bit.
- lukeschlather 4y agoA passkey is never a "thing you know." It is a "thing you have access to, which mostly behaves like a 'thing you have' but also your OS provider probably has it if they want it."
- JohnFen 4y agoWell, we're deep into semantics now, but I think the passkey is "something you know". That you've chosen to offload your memory onto a device doesn't really change that. But, honestly, this is a point of little importance. Almost all of the "something you..." categories are only a rough guide, and most items can arguably fall into more than one of them.
- noman-land 4y agoAs soon as you write something down it becomes something you have.
- JohnFen 4y agoI can't argue with that at all.
- tunesmith 4y agoThat's not really deep into semantics if it's the whole point. Something you know is by definition not externalized, and thus has a different type of security.
- roundandround 4y agoIf a passkey is something you know then you are using a failed implementation. A fido/authn device is supposed to be able to attest to never having let the private key out, even with a relaxation to passkeys it should at least be sending it to another device that can attest.
- JohnFen 4y agoTrue, but I'm hoping that "failed implementation" is accepted, because the correct implementation is too burdensome for my taste.