3 ms·
> By declining on procedural grounds This wasn’t decided on procedural grounds, but on substantive grounds. The fact that it was decided on a different substan
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> By declining on procedural grounds
This wasn’t decided on procedural grounds, but on substantive grounds. The fact that it was decided on a different substantive question than some people wanted it to be doesn’t make it procedural.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoThe procedural issue is which substantive question to tackle first. If they address the merits of the underlying liability and conclude that there was none, then they get to skip the question of Section 230 because it's irrelevant. Now suppose they want to avoid tackling the question of the underlying liability. Well, if the defendants would be immune under Section 230 anyway then that question would be irrelevant and they could avoid answering it. But that's not what they did.