4 ms·
Dev tools don't really have a place in managed environments IMO - they just need too low level of access to a system to be able to do their work. Now, say a ga
by zdw 15y ago
Dev tools don't really have a place in managed environments IMO - they just need too low level of access to a system to be able to do their work.
Now, say a game or web browser that runs potentially malicious content, sure, sandbox it. But other things like code interpreters, low level Unix tools, or inter process tools like AppleScript, they're still open to (mis)use by anyone.
I'm going to guess that most malware for OS X will soon become non-compiled scripts. Sure, the interpreter would be signed, but what it runs is totally arbitrary.
- gizzlon 15y agoGood point. Every interpreter - and program that loads anything - will have to be foolproof. There was a case some time ago where an Xbox (or was it ps3?) game did not correctly check the saved games before loading them. IIRC people where able to exploit this and get the game to run code on their behalf. In theory, all the games and apps have to sign/encrypt/check everything they load. But I can't believe they will all implement this correctly or that Apple will find all the subtle bugs when reviewing.
- roc 15y agoThe sandbox lessens the risk of said overflows. Instead of exploiting a flaw in an interpreter or file handling function and getting control of the entire machine, you'd only get control of the sandbox's context. The only way to parlay that into control of the system would be to break the sandbox. And then, because OS X default security is fairly sane, the only way to do real lasting damage is to use a further exploit to escalate your permissions.
- gizzlon 15y agoTrue, but that would be true without signed apps as well. Also, I guess it depends on what the app does and what you mean by "real lasting damage".
- gravitronic 15y agoxbox, ps3, wii, psp, gamecube.. this has been a consistent successful attack vector against signed application environments on consoles.
- Argorak 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Softmod#Softmods_for_Microsoft_Xbox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Softmod#Softmods_for_Microsoft_... Splinter Cell and MechAssault where famous for this. The bug is actually in the XBox Dashboard code itself, so the Host system was buggy.
- skymt 15y agoThat was the first way Wii owners got homebrew software running: the Wii version of Zelda: Twilight Princess didn't do a bounds check when reading the name of the player's horse from a save file. http://wiibrew.org/wiki/Twilight_Hack#Explanation http://wiibrew.org/wiki/Twilight_Hack#Explanation
- gcb 15y agothe real way we got homebrew in the wii in the first place was because of a awful RSA implementation done by outsourced devs in the USA. http://events.ccc.de/congress/2008/Fahrplan/events/2799.en.html http://events.ccc.de/congress/2008/Fahrplan/events/2799.en.h...
- theDaveB 15y agoThe original XBOX had a problem with a 007 game and with the right game save you could turn it into a FTP server. Once that was loaded, you where in. Dave
- Codhisattva 15y agoThat was my first thought too. MAS is mainly for the general public. While it's a nice long blog with lots of details, it's not a universally correct criticism of MAS.
- ramses 15y agoThere's another kind of applications, besides dev tools, that's going to be affected by this. I'm a user of one of Apple's "pro" applications, Logic Pro 9, a top music recording software (or DAW). I started using it long before it was put in the appstore, and was surprised when they moved it there, as it was a 5 DVD install. Anyways ... the tool interacts with plugins written in a Logic Pro independent standard, VST. It burns CDs. It manipulates midi through wifi, usb, and firewire. It reads third party provided sound samples and loops. It manipulates analog instrument interfaces through firewire ... Is Apple going to cripple Logic Studio? Or will they also have to take their "pro" software out of the appstore?
- Ryanmf 15y agoMainstage is in the Mac App Store as well, nothing about Rewire support is consistent with MAS guidelines. Unfortunately, it appears this may be a "do as I say, not as I do" situation.
- batista 15y agoUnfortunately, how? The whole point of sandboxing is to reduce the damage a badly written or mal-intended application can do to a system. Surely Apple TRUSTS their own apps.
- mburns 15y agoIn contrast to Google, whose malware auto-detection algorithms will still flag Google-owned domains.
- Ryanmf 15y agoAre you dense? It's unfortunate for users, rational beings who, having spent several hundred/thousand dollars on pro applications, can generally expect not to be served malware. I don't really need Apple's assistance to ensure that Ableton doesn't sell me a trojan. If they do, I have my lawyer's number in my phone, we know who to sue, we've got it covered. It's unfortunate that the way the rules are currently written, no pro media application will be able to take advantage of iCloud functionality…except of course the ones that Apple sells. I don't care who Apple trusts. And if the answer to "Who does Apple trust?" is "No one but Apple," that says more negative things about Apple than it does about the tens of thousands of software developers, large and small, who aren't Apple.