4 ms·
What would be the specific harm of TikTok? Is it because of China, or because of this style of social media apps? If it's because of China, then ban TikTok and
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
What would be the specific harm of TikTok? Is it because of China, or because of this style of social media apps?
If it's because of China, then ban TikTok and subsidize a competitor app - but be serious about it. Be ready to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on keeping the app free and servers up for years, sponsoring hundreds of content creators, dragging celebrities in to produce exclusive content, burning tons of money on all kinds of loss-generating marketing bullshit, like "publish a video from $concert, best 100 videos win a Nintendo Switch", for each concert in the state/country for the next few years.
Point being, if you can provide a TikTok alternative and make it extremely attractive, even if by literally giving away hundreds of dollars to each new user, then kids won't care about using TikTok anymore.
Now, if it's not about China but teenage use of social media?
Put an absurdly high tax on smartphones. Like 200%-1000%. That will make sure they become unavailable to a typical teenager.
Beyond that? I don't think you can do much about it directly, or in the immediate term.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIt's a hypothetical. Hypothetically suppose we all agree that TikTok usage should be reduced. You are a state legislator. What do you do?
- TeMPOraL 4y agoMake using it a criminal offense with minimum mandatory sentence of 5 years in prison.
- juliusgeo 4y agoI would like to make the modest proposal that a more effective way of reducing usage would be to make it punishable by summary execution.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoOh no. The US isn't some kind of totalitarian country to do summary executions for petty crimes. Why waste the free labor?
- badpun 4y agoLet's punish every act that we don't want to see with death (or, at a minimum, cutting off a hand), that will solve world's problems for sure.
- onionisafruit 4y agoIn that hypothetical I identify the federal policy I think would be effective and vote for the US rep, Senate and presidential candidates I think are most likely to enact that policy. As a state legislature I probably have some sway with my constituents, so I also publicly endorse that policy and candidates. What I’m getting at is this isn’t an issue for the state level.
- bardan 4y agoSometimes people say "you only hate TikTok because it's a foreign company doing it better than American social media". Maybe that's right, maybe TikTok is just doing it better than American social media platforms, but what have we been saying about American social media for the last decade? (generally not positive things) Maybe at some point this was all going to hit some kind of threshold where it is just no longer reasonable to call the effects of social media a net good. Maybe TikTok has passed that threshold. We can give them a trophy for that, but then plan some ways to finally restrict social media's addictive and anxiety-provoking qualities. So restrictions on infinite scroll, or require the user to actually press a button before the next video starts. I'm sure there are a lot of ideas, and people more qualified than me to suggest them, but I think these two alone would be reasonable restrictions. It disturbs me that TikTok being a Chinese company is being used right now as an excuse as to why these social media platforms shouldn't be made to change their deliberately addictive designs.
- kranke155 4y agoIn a free market a ban should be enough for competitors and replacements to arise
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThat assumes zero barriers to entry. Social media apps are pure network effect, making them the opposite of free market. You can't compete directly with TikTok without quickly matching its userbase and content volume.
- Spooky23 4y agoWell, in a free market there’s no ban. Is the reason for the ban “dur dur China?”, or performative political theater? Montanas politics are such that they you can’t find an OB to deliver a baby anymore, so any “free market” competitor needs to consider what random event will put them out of business.
- wildrhythms 4y agoIs it a free market if such a ban exists in the first place?
- kranke155 4y agoYep. Free markets don’t mean unlimited power to corporations.
- CapstanRoller 4y agoFree markets only exist in econ textbooks. It would be more productive to discuss actually-existing markets.
- Nanana909 4y ago> If it's because of China, then ban TikTok and subsidize a competitor app - but be serious about it. Be ready to spend hundreds of ..... Domestic competitors have already published their equivalents though, no subsidied required. It's not a very complicated app - they had clones up in months. Most popular Tik-Tokers already repost their content on these anyways. Why do we need to subsidize naything? This already exists.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> Why do we need to subsidize naything? This already exists. Because the problem presented here is: government bans TikTok, teenagers become experts at using VPN apps to work around the ban. Social media apps live on network effects - it's near-impossible to compete with a well-established giant directly. But this also means that, if you manage to pull a critical mass of users over from your direct competitor, most of the rest will quickly switch too. Therefore, the solution to teenagers overcoming the ban with VPN is to prop up a domestic competitor fast - pump money into it until it becomes more attractive to the kids than jumping through VPN hoops to get to TikTok. Once you get there, the problem solves itself. (This is ofc. only for the scenario where the problem is China, not TikTok-style social media.)
- DirkH 4y agoYour argument rests heavily on "teens WILL overwhelmingly become VPN experts" I don't understand why it can't instead be: banning will make domestic alternatives more attractive since now you don't even need a VPN to access it. Sure some teens will use a VPN and continue to use TikTok, but I'm not sure it'll be to such an extent that we'd be forced to concede that banning was the wrong call. Also you can do both: ban and subsidize.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> Your argument rests heavily on "teens WILL overwhelmingly become VPN experts" My argument rests on "social media is sticky due to network effects". Which is why "banning will make domestic alternatives more attractive since now you don't even need a VPN to access it" if and only if the domestic alternatives are so good in comparison to figuring out VPN, that a critical mass of domestic users switch over. Ban alone won't make it happen - TikTok is too sticky for that. Those are teenagers we're talking about. They're resourceful, motivated, have infinite free time - learning how to use a VPN app will be trivial for them, especially that "VPN" here doesn't mean Wireguard or ISO/OSI hokus pocus, but rather a turnkey app that requires about three clicks to make your US Internet connection look like it's coming out of Somalia. It's not hard for them - and will be even easier if a ban on TikTok makes VPN companies target the teenager market directly. > Also you can do both: ban and subsidize. That's exactly what I recommended.