5 ms·
I think we'll have to see what the demand for living in big/dense cities looks like in light of at least somewhat reduced demand for living there because of emp
by ghaff 4y ago
I think we'll have to see what the demand for living in big/dense cities looks like in light of at least somewhat reduced demand for living there because of employment. Certainly, there's some demand--especially among younger people in the college-educated demographic.
But it's less obvious what tradeoffs people make in general to the degree that employment isn't part of the equation. I certainly never lived in a city when my company was located well outside.
- bilbo0s 4y agoJust, Devil’s Advocate. But the whole reason we’re even having the discussion is because of the evidence that more people are remote working. So I’m assuming we’re talking about people who might have to go to their office at max two or three days a week in the extreme cases? Not sure how that will create enough of a market drain to make NYC, Boston, or San Fran living affordable? I think the suggestion to reclaim business districts is the only rational way forward with any kind of chance of lowering prices. There just don’t seem to be enough people willing to live outside the city to bring down prices. If anything, everything price-wise points to market demand increasing.
- ghaff 4y ago2-3 days/week isn't daily but still qualifies as pretty frequent. From first-hand experience, I still don't want more than an hour commute. Of course, I don't need to live right in the city for that but, especially in the absence of a good commuter rail system (which those specific cities have to at least some degree), you can't move that far out.
- xapata 4y agoDepends what "in a city" means. Some people might say I live in the 'burbs, but my postal address still has the city's name in it.
- throwaway2037 4y agoWhat city? It is probably not very dense.
- bcrosby95 4y agoI don't know if it's the city he's talking about, but by landmass, about half of San Francisco is the burbs.
- valleyer 4y agoI'm sincerely curious, and not disagreeing with you: what definition of suburban are you using, and which parts of San Francisco?
- bcrosby95 4y agoAreas with lots of single family homes where you're more likely to drive to go somewhere than not. Much of sunset, much of richmond, twin peaks, bayview/hunters point, lots of the places around 280 between 101 and 1.
- jquery 4y agoNot the person you were asking, but to me, "suburban" is not defined by density, but by how walkable an area is. Even relatively low density neighborhoods can be urban under this definition as long as residential isn't zoned far away from commercial districts and everything is within a few minutes of walking or an easy bus ride. Suburban is when having a car provides an enormous QoL boost, but isn't strictly necessary. And rural is when a car is absolutely required to survive. These are fairly car centric definitions. But considering the car enabled the suburb in the first place, I don't think it's necessarily wrong to use it as the metric.
- chrismcb 4y agoWhen talking about "living in the city" one generally didn't talk about the postal address, but rather the density.
- emodendroket 4y agoOh. Well in that case the vast majority of Americans live in a metro area so I guess they do like the city.