3 ms·
I'm not going to put this and similar cases quite in the class of just applying a Photoshop filter or similar transformations. But I'm not sure it's that far of
by ghaff 4y ago
I'm not going to put this and similar cases quite in the class of just applying a Photoshop filter or similar transformations. But I'm not sure it's that far off either. Which seems to fall into an area where you can't just take someone's photo, apply a couple straightforward changes, and now it's yours.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoOne of the problems, was that Warhol stole from Lynn Goldsmith, who is about as big-time a celebrity shooter as you can get. She's in the same league as Annie Leibovitz. She was able to devote years and years, to get it all the way to the top. Personally, I think it went the way it should, but I'm biased. My company worked with her, and I think she had a serious network; not just a single artwork. She's very popular, and has friends in high places. Other photographers probably don't have the capabilities that she has. Many of them have probably licensed through outfits like Getty Images, who would probably go after folks that used their works, but if they didn't, I don't think the photographer would have a whole lot of recourse.
- kevinmchugh 4y agoLichtenstein picked poorer, more anonymous artists to rip off and that seems like the more winning strategy
- mold_aid 4y agoNot for Koons it wasn’t
- ghaff 4y agoAs a non-lawyer, I basically agree. This seems like a case of license the thing already. It's an edge case but, especially given existing case law, seems like a less-difficult one. The main complication here seems to be big name photographer on the one hand and big name pop artist on the other. So this wasn't Andy Warhol repurposing some random pedestrian photo. Arguably the difference shouldn't matter. But it does.
- sum1zideas 4y agoSo glad Lynn Goldsmith can grift forever on one black and white photo. Forever copyright is a joke.
- anon84873628 4y agoThe animated gif in the article sure does make it seem like a very simple filter. I guess the "Warhol aesthetic" was at one time novel and seems basic now, but just changing the colors of a photograph isn't particularly transformative.