3 ms·
The partisans were executed if captured. Turnabout is fair play.
by pfdietz 4y ago
The partisans were executed if captured. Turnabout is fair play.
- ceejayoz 4y agoI'm sympathetic to the practical concerns for partisans; these likely had basically no choice in the matter. They're operating out of their homes; there's nowhere to safely stash 50 Nazi prisoners. That said, "the Waffen-SS does it too" is perhaps too low a moral standard to set.
- masfuerte 4y agoThe SS weren't just executing partisans. They were responding to any resistance by killing innocent men, women and children.
- ceejayoz 4y agoI don't disagree. "They'd have done it to us" is a different argument, though. "We can't keep these people prisoner, and if we let them go they'll murder civilians" is a much better moral argument than "they'd execute us too if the battle went the other way".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- foxyv 4y agoIf the enemy calls no quarter there is no reason to offer it yourself unless you have that luxury. If you don't want to be executed, then don't invade someone else's home and hang innocent men, women, and children. If the partisans had gone into Germany and started hanging people I could understand claiming they were "Stooping to the level of the Nazis" but not this.
- ceejayoz 4y agoIf you can safely hold POWs, hold POWs. There’s value to being better than the other guy. If you can’t, I’m not gonna judge, and that’s almost certainly the position these folks were in.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe "turnabout" argument applies to regular troops as well. For example, Japanese would "surrender" so they could blow up GIs trying to capture them. The response was to stop accepting surrenders. At Guadalcanal, tanks were run over downed Japanese just to make sure they weren't faking death. The backs of the tanks were described as looking like meat grinders. There was a lot of machine gunning of Japanese navy personnel in the water after ships were sunk.