2 ms·
> In the US, someone earning $155,000 USD (Equivalent to 125 GBP) will also be paying 6.2% in social security taxes, 1.45% in medicare taxes, and then another 6
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> In the US, someone earning $155,000 USD (Equivalent to 125 GBP) will also be paying 6.2% in social security taxes, 1.45% in medicare taxes, and then another 6.2% in social security taxes (employer’s portion), and 1.45% in medicare taxes (employer’s portion).
In the UK, there is also National Insurance tax on top of income tax, which works similarly (but is a bit more complicated.) The employer share is 13.8%, which is a hair below the combined employee + employer share US federal payroll tax.
And there is also a 20% VAT impacting the cost of pretty much anything you might use your after-tax income to buy.
> All-in-all, Americans pay ~26% of their GDP in taxes.
Close: 26.6% (2021, provisional), 25.8% (2020) [0]
> People in the UK pay… ~27% of their GDP in taxes.
Not so close: 33.5% (2021, provisional), 32.1% (2020) [0]
> ‘Americans pay less taxes’ is largely a meme with no basis in reality.
No, the UK has a much higher tax burden; the US is significantly below OECD average, the UK a bit above.
[0] https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-highlights-brochure.pdf https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-highl...
- vkou 4y agoThe overwhelming majority of a person's expenditures (Housing, education, medical, most of the food you buy at the grocery, many forms of transportation) are not covered by VAT. Many forms of energy (residential electricity, gas) are covered at a vastly reduced VAT. And, again, the giant bugbear that is health insurance rears its ugly head on the US side. See the overall 'Taxes as a % of GDP' comparisons. Edit: I stand corrected about taxes as % of GDP. You are right, that the UK is at 33.5%. [1] Unfortunately, again, that doesn't include the percentage of US spending on healthcare - which is 17.8% of its GDP, with much of it coming out of after-tax dollars, instead of pre-tax ones. (Medicaid and Medicare make up about a third of that - and are, obviously, financed by taxes.) [1] https://www.oecd.org/tax/revenue-statistics-united-kingdom.pdf https://www.oecd.org/tax/revenue-statistics-united-kingdom.p...
- dragonwriter 4y ago> And, again, the giant bugbear that is health insurance rears its ugly head on the US side Sure, yes, that's a bigger non-tax expense for individuals in the US. The US having by far the least efficient healthcare system in the world is a huge problem. > See the overall ‘Taxes as a % of GDP’ comparisons. Yes, I’ve updated my post to address your wildly inaccurate “Taxes as a % of GDP” comparison, using the most recently published OECD data which shows that you were close for the US, and way low for the UK.
- vkou 4y agoAnd I've updated my post to point out the mountain of US post-tax healthcare spending, that in the UK, largely comes out of pre-tax pounds. At the end of the day, Americans still pay, and pay more. 26% in taxes, and then another ~11% in non-government-covered (non-Medicare/Medicaid) healthcare spending.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> At the end of the day, Americans still pay, and pay more They pay less in taxes, by a wide margin. They also get less for them, by a wide margin, particularly (but not exclusively) in healthcare.
- vkou 4y agoI've been corrected (my initial data was wrong, I've updated my post), and I agree on both points. I do, however, posit that when it comes to determining whether an economy/society/??? is healthy (which is the conversation in this sub-thread), we need to look at all of these 'costs of life/business'. So, yes, the sticker price on the UK looks rough, but add it all up... And it comes out to be pretty similar. As it turns out, providing similar forms of services costs... About the same, across the developed world.
- armitron 4y agoReally? I have top of the line healthcare through my employer in the US, which also covers my wife and teenage daughters, which costs me essentially nothing. NHS in the UK is collapsing, but even if it didn't, qualitatively it's orders of magnitude worse than what one would receive in the US through one's employer: Months to years for an appointment, incompetent doctors and a bureaucracy that puts Kafka to shame. https://www.economist.com/britain/2022/04/30/the-nhs-is-in-seriously-poor-shape https://www.economist.com/britain/2022/04/30/the-nhs-is-in-s... https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/01/02/collapse-nhs-tragically-predictable/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/01/02/collapse-nhs-tra... Yes US healthcare has issues but it's nowhere near as bad as UK.
- dukeyukey 4y ago> And there is also a 20% VAT impacting the cost of pretty much anything you might use your after-tax income to Except stuff like food, rent, utilities, small stuff like that. I'll give you the rest though. The UK is a low-tax country by European standards, and even by developed-world standards, but is above the US quite significantly.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The UK is a low-tax country by European standards, and even by developed-world standards, The UK is a bit above average tax burden as share of GDP for the OECD. It is not particularly “low tax by developed world standards”.
- dukeyukey 4y agoThe OECD includes countries like Mexico, Turkey, and Colombia that are definitely less developed than the rest of the list. Hell, looking at the IMF figures, half the European countries on that list count as "developing" too, especially the less-taxing ones. Don't think I agree with them, but I'm not an economist so hey.
- jjav 4y ago> > ‘Americans pay less taxes’ is largely a meme with no basis in reality. > No, the UK has a much higher tax burden; the US is significantly below OECD average, the UK a bit above. > [0] https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-highl https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-highl... Rather than contradict the OP's statement, the above document reinforces it. The document only covers taxes identifies as "taxes", which makes the comparison with US apples to organges. The two huge elephants in the room in the US are health care and higher education both of which are very high cost in the US and both of which have to be paid separately in the US. Whereas in most other countries these are either fully or partially funded by taxes. For an apples-apples comparison of out of required pocket expenses in the US vs. other countries you need to include health care and education costs.
- pmontra 4y agoAdd pensions to that. Many countries have mandatory state run pension funds (for lack of a better translation, it's late at night here.) People can add their own private pension fund.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoIf we’re talking about the UK, college has got a lot more expensive there. Cost to run a university is getting more expensive everywhere, the Baumol effect doesn’t discriminate. Some countries subsidize more aggressively than others, but it’s getting harder.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoPretending that the employer is paying taxes for the employees is doublespeak popularized by large companies to justify why they want to stop paying it. It is not taxes. It's a contribution to a functioning society. Otherwise, employers would get access to employees with NHS without putting a penny in.
- vkou 4y agoIt is taxes. Taxes are a contribution to a functioning society, though! There's nothing wrong with them when they are used well! > Otherwise, employers would get access to employees with NHS without putting a penny in. It doesn't matter how you slice it, the penny still comes out of payroll. It makes zero difference to me if I get paid 50,000, and 10,000 of that goes to taxes, or if I get paid 40,000 and my employer pays 10,000 in taxes. But it sure causes a lot of spilled ink about whether or not its 'really a tax' and 'who pays'.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> It is not taxes. It's a contribution to a functioning society That’s what taxes in general are, so the second half does not support the first. > Otherwise, employers would get access to employees with NHS without putting a penny in. The idea that payroll taxes are a fee that employers pay the State for “access” to workers and that this is a defense rather than a criticism of the scheme is... interesting.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoNope. Words have a meaning. Contributions are dedicated to a specific thing. Nobody can take the money of the Build-Hospitals contribution and use it to Build-Death-Star. Taxes however can go anywhere. Once again, "payroll tax" is language invented by employers to make it feel like they're being unjustly taxed. Additionally, in the case of Europe, most of these contributions were set up after WW2 because employers were happy enough to collaborate with the occupiers and kept wanting cheap labour without participating in rebuilding nations. So, sorry, I won't cry about them having to pay their fair share.