6 ms·
Replication can be hard. Failure to replicate shouldn't lead to immediate rejection. My understanding, though, is that this researcher has a very problematic t
by CamperBob2 4y ago
Replication can be hard. Failure to replicate shouldn't lead to immediate rejection.
My understanding, though, is that this researcher has a very problematic track record. It may not be appropriate to give him the benefit of the doubt here.
- chmod600 4y agoMaybe we should just ignore all findings until another team has independently reproduced the result. Even if what the original team concludes is true, a repro failure could indicate that it's under-documented. And if it's under-documented, then has science really moved forward?
- tensor 4y agoOr we could come back to reality and listen to the actual professionals about why the reproduction might not have worked, because of known issues in the reproduction. The only conclusion I can come to is that the comments here are exceptionally low value.
- olliej 4y agoAt the same time extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. The refusal to allow anyone to use their samples, or to apparently provide sufficient information to allow someone else to create the material they claim to be a room temperature superconductor, leans to it reasonably being an incorrect claim. Others point to past behavior as indicating this is fraudulent, but I'm just going to assume it's accidental error.