3 ms·
China’s loans pushing world’s poorest countries to brink of collapse
- jqpabc123 4y agoSo basically, China is running a loan shark operation.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoMore like "rent to own" where they know you're going to fail and they're going to repo the infrastructure.
- innagadadavida 4y agoIt seems worse that that - they take video trim if the countries infra like ports to have a military build up.
- dirtyid 4y agoNo, western loan sharks are trying to get chinese loan sharks to forgive more debts via propaganda. There's many more poor countries on the brink of collapse with majority % western loans due to covid, a lot of multilateral negotiation on debt forgiveness right now where everyone needs to take haircuts. But west trying to pressure PRC to forgive more / higher burden, and PRC is going lol nope. Some useful idiots buy it, like they do debt trap narrative, meanwhile those in charge still flock to PRC loans where available for infra build up, because no one else, especially west, has capability to stepping up.
- r9295 4y agoJust ask Sri Lanka
- delfinom 4y agoCorrupt politicians are pushing world's poorest countries to collapse*** China did not force those countries to take loans. And the reason they take those loans are for very obvious self enrichment.
- 36933 4y agoLet’s imagine you like to eat humans. You ask a guy if you can eat him. He agrees. You eat him. Then you’re blaming the guy for getting eaten, because he wanted it? My man you just ate a man.
- aamirraihan 4y agoThis applies not just for china but for all big US banks
- yieldcrv 4y agoChina soft power campaign beating the IMF at their own game While IMF was busy denying the veracity of “Confessions of an Economic Hitman”, China was using it as an instruction manual Thats one thing I always liked about conspiracies, whether true or false, they are great rubrics for the next ambitious soul
- diversionfactor 4y agoReference for the uninitiated, a good read. Its veracity on the individual level may be questionable, but the techniques of subduing third world countries via heavy debt burdens is well documented. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confessions_of_an_Economic_Hit_Man https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confessions_of_an_Economic_H...
- boeingUH60 4y agoMy country (Nigeria) now spends 80% of its revenue servicing debt mostly owed to China (I blame stupid and corrupt government officials much more than China). Welp, time to go learn Mandarin... https://www.thecable.ng/zainab-ahmed-nigeria-to-spend-60-of-revenue-on-debt-servicing-in-2023 https://www.thecable.ng/zainab-ahmed-nigeria-to-spend-60-of-...
- CogitoCogito 4y agoDo you know what the implications would be in simply defaulting?
- boeingUH60 4y agoOur economy will sink further from the horrible state it's already in.
- notadev 4y agoChina gets to take over all of the projects they built, this giving them a foothold in the local government and economy.
- elzbardico 4y agoOh, so, now China is the new IMF? Are they also requiring governments to privatize and cut social spending in education, health and housing like the IMF does?
- NLPaep 4y agoEffectively, yes and more. Did you read the article?
- asdajksah2123 4y agoThe difference between the IMF and Chinese loans is that the IMF is a lender of last resort, whereas China's loans are for greenfield projects to country that are in perfectly fine financial situations. The Chinese loans are attractive to leaders of countries because it allows them to advertise huge development projects, which are in many cases unsustainable and fiscally destructive, while pocketing most of the money, and letting the actual negative impacts, which show up a few years later, be dealt with by a future administration and the citizens of the country. A closer analogy to the Chinese loans are World Bank loans, and while they have strict requirements, they've not really ever led to countries facing these massive debts, even though countries have been borrowing from the World Bank for far longer than from China.
- asdajksah2123 4y agoNo. China doesn't do that. That's why corrupt leaders love Chinese loans. Unlike the IMF, China simply doesn't care that the loans will not actually lead to any improvements for the citizens of the recipient country, and are happy for the leaders to simply pocket the money in return for the country and its citizens paying China high rates and then eventually giving away the project to the Chinese. The IMF/World Bank have been consistently maligned, but it's increasingly clear that their demands for prudence is beneficial to the actual citizens of the country. The negative consequences are not a result of the financial prudence they require, but rather, a result of the mess the country got themselves in so they needed to go to the IMF to get money in the first place.
- asdajksah2123 4y agoChina's BRI has been a great advertisement for the IMF. 1. The IMF gives loans at significantly lower rates than China does. That clearly points out that the donor countries in the IMF are far more generous than any other entity that will lend to the countries in question, which completely goes against the idea that the IMF is trying to extract money out of poorly situated countries. 2. The IMF has never, AFAIK, appropriated land and property for default, or if it has, it's been on a very small scale over many decades. China has already appropriated massive parts of sovereign territory during a very short period of time. That's another indication of how generous the IMF really is. 3. Most importantly, the major complaint about the IMF has always been their demands for "austerity". Admittedly (as in, the IMF has literally admitted this), the IMF regulations were too strict in this regard, and the IMF has consequently loosened a lot of these requirements. But what the BRI has shown is that the intention, and effect, of these requirements is indeed good for the citizens of the recipient country, because it reduces the chances that the leaders simply pocket the IMF money (some still do), and it reduces the chances that the country will be caught in a debt spiral (some still do). The BRI has shown an alternative where the donors do not require structural changes from the recipient countries. And almost predictably, the result isn't that it leads to the recipient country's administration running their country in a fiscally sustainable manner without the evil foreign oversight. The result is that the country continues to be run terribly, benefiting the leaders personally, and moving all the costs off to the next government and/or the citizens themselves, but a few years into the future. This is fairly obvious when you recognize that invariably it's teh leaders who brought the country to a position where they need to beg for money that are getting the donated money itself. Essentially, the Belt and Road Initiative has pretty much completely undermined the idea that the IMF/World Bank (I didn't mention the World Bank because it's broadly considered far less coercive than the IMF) are an evil tool of western imperialism (which was obvious in the first place, considering the WB/IMF are completely voluntary organizations, and if they weren't so evil in the first place countries wouldn't go to them), and are in fact providing loans to countries that would never get them at all otherwise, at rates that are lower than anyone else would offer, and look out for the actual citizens (including future citizens) of the country in a way no other lending entity does. The only reason countries are opting for BRI funds instead of the IMF at this point is because their corrupt leaders know that even though those funds are far more expensive, and will invariably lead to ceding sovereign control of territory/projects to China, China will not care about the leaders themselves pocketing the money, unlike the IMF.
- hulitu 4y agoThey learned from US via IMF.
- anakaine 4y agoThe US has undertaken economic imperialism outside the IMF for quite a long time. They have not been aggressive in the past couple of decades, however, yet the effe ts are still being felt today.
- from 4y agoOf course all the countries mentioned in the article are all the kind of country where 10-20% of the people on the government payroll don't even exist ("ghosts"), no bid contracts are routinely handed out to friends of the government (and sometimes even current employees of the government!), spend ridiculous proportions of the budget subsidizing gasoline to buy votes, etc. Why are these countries any more deserving of forgiveness than countries that act responsibly?