6 ms·
The oldest known blueprints depict Stone Age ‘megastructures’
- rektide 4y agoExtending terrain to create a sizable animal pen. ~9000 years ago, around Jordan/Saudi Arabia.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoWhenever it's Homo Sapiens remember that's just ordinary modern man, no different than us now. Pre-Historic or not. So naturally every generation or at least every hundred years or so there's always been an Einstein, Tesla, or DaVinci come along.
- singularity2001 4y agoif you account for population density, and maybe surrounding of education, one would expect these geniuses to spread out exponentially though
- qwytw 4y agoI guess the problem nowadays is that most things got so complex and specialized that the impact a single person can make is rather limited. So we're simply not seeing these geniuses because incremental 'discoveries' ordinary people can't understand don't really make for good headlines.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 4y agoStrange convergance: I always think of a Paul Graham essay on this[0]. He mentions Florence generating several geniuses, even though nearby Milan was the same size and same almost everything. [0] http://www.paulgraham.com/cities.html http://www.paulgraham.com/cities.html
- labster 4y agoThat should depend on population size. I can’t think of any geniuses 100 years after Imhotep. Galen is roughly a century after Heron. And in the 20th century, we had Einstein, Heisenberg, Curie, Lorenz, Planck, Schrödinger, and Feynman in physics alone.
- detourdog 4y agoThe question should be in 4,000 year what names do we still have from the last 100 years.
- BirAdam 4y agoThe answer is: “those whose name was everywhere” which unfortunately will mean Louis Vuitton, Donald Trump, George Washington, and maybe Queen Elizabeth II? 4000 years is a long time, and our civilization will likely be gone, nothing but ruins.
- Retric 4y ago100 years isn’t that long we still remember Henry Ford etc. But even 1,000 years is going to erase everyone on that list outside of serious history nerds. Quick who was the first kind of England, and who started or ran the east India trading company?
- BirAdam 4y agoMy thought is more just the ubiquity of the names. If even a few objects are well preserved with those names on them, then the names will be remembered. What the people did may not be remembered, but the name may be. The ubiquity of Louis Vuitton and knock off products, Trump putting his name on… everything, etc.
- Retric 4y agoIf you just mean the actual names, I think most of our names will be recorded somewhere in 4,000 years. Genealogy doesn’t take up much space and people have been keeping widespread records for hundreds of years in many areas. The extreme is the Lurie Family which can “trace” part of it’s lineage back 3,000 years and that was with paper records. (700 years of that is well documented, prior to that is less certain.)
- imiric 4y agoSharing of accumulated knowledge is crucial to our advancement, though. Geniuses may have lived thousands of years ago, but their potential was mostly lost without access to knowledge of their ancestors, or other tribes. Which also happens today in places with poor education. We only hear about the Newtons and Einsteins because they were born at the right place and time.
- BirAdam 4y agoPeople used to memorize stuff. They’d memorize a lot of stuff. The geniuses of the Stone Age did little things, like finding better ways to make fire, flint knap, leather processing, weaving and looms, tent making, taming animals, inventing the wheel, food preservation, which plants were good for what ailments. You know, all the stuff you need without question.
- intelVISA 4y agoWho is our century's Tesla? Fabrice? Solomon Hykes? In terms of impact both are huge, Fabrice's works are a marvel and Hyke's repackaging of ELF with YAML is considered business genius - he could sell anything I'm sure.
- thewildginger 4y agoStephen Hawking.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- h2odragon 4y ago> Who is our century's Tesla? Some dude named "Bob" who lives in a trailer in the woods and never talks to anyone.
- kwere 4y agoI hope Bob doesnt want to publicize its own finding trough planting bombs
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoI'd say Jo Zayner's the closest to Tesla due to the showpersonship and self-experimentation in public.
- tgv 4y agoUnder a whole bunch of assumptions.
- somenameforme 4y agoYou're not considering a lot of factors here. One of the most noncontroversial would be population size. Past human population sizes are little more than guesses, but the one thing that's for sure is that they were far lower, and probably in the low millions at some point. So modern humans would expect to have on the order of something like 8000x as many geniuses than ancient humans, based on population alone. Another noncontroversial one would be nutrition. Malnutrition results in impaired intellectual ability, and malnutrition was much more common in the past. You definitely would expect to see a proportional number of outliers on a time scale.
- BurningFrog 4y agoWithout a modern society around them, providing universities, technology, communication etc, these geniuses would just end up being the best farmer or handyman in the village. Also, human population was very small in the old days: https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth#world-population-from-10-000-bce-to-today https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth#world-pop...
- wongarsu 4y agoAbout 7% of all humans who have ever lived are currently alive. Which would mean that also about 7% of all geniuses ever are currently alive, and thanks to modern agriculture most of them are not stuck farming.
- BurningFrog 4y agoThis also means that, empirically, only 93% of all humans have died so far.
- wongarsu 4y agoWhich puts our confidence that everyone will die at less than 3-sigma. It could just be a coincidence so far
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoThis is actually one of my favorite examples of cherry-picking statistics to support a false statement. "There's about a 7% chance I won't die because, of all humans who have ever lived, only about 93% have died." Of course, this ignores the entire concept of "life expectancy" but such is the nature of cherry-picking statistics to support a false statement.
- jameshart 4y agoAnd inventing ‘scratching a plan into something so people understand it’ is not an Einstein level invention. It’s immediately graspable by small children so it seems likely that it’s something humans have been doing for a veeeery long time. These ‘blueprints’ are preserved because they were carved in rock. All the thousands of years of prior art of scratching lines in the dirt are lost to time.
- acyou 4y ago1. I thought Vice declared bankruptcy? 2. This appears to be a wall. Why do we think this is an animal pen? Usually, you would build walls to keep out other people. I suspect the Neolithic people were more than capable of hunting and catching game without these structures.
- heavyset_go 4y agoThey filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and will be/were sold to creditors. Looks like it's going to exist in some form and not be liquidated.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoIt's not thought to be an animal pen, it's a killing funnel for wild game. They certainly would have been capable of hunting without these and even done so regularly. These were for large scale killings of herds when the conditions were right. Similar structures called buffalo jumps and buffalo pounds are known from the Great Plains. As for how we know they're not walls, that's easy: they're not tall enough. As someone who's excavated enough stone walls, it takes a much bigger pile than that to build human-scale walls, and far more if you want them to have any sort of defensive capability.
- singularity2001 4y agoWhile correct, it is an interesting thought of whether pens might have arisen through (earlier) kites by omitting or postponing the kill step in these traps.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoKites are much more sophisticated than pens and they're not relying on the same principles to work. A pen is just a physical obstacle to prevent animals from getting out. These rely on the animal's herd-following and avoidance instincts, as well as how poor eyesight, panic and misdirection. They wouldn't work very well at containing leisurely grazing animals, but they're also much cheaper to build. Also worth noting that you don't actually need to pen animals to domesticate them. It has a lot of advantages (e.g. separating them from predators), but it's not required and may even be disadvantageous if you're a (semi-)nomadic pastoralist.
- fritzo 4y agoFigure 9 of the original paper shows some side-by-side comparisons of kite representations vs satellite imagery https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0277927 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- shen 4y agoThe accuracy kind of blows my mind…
- singularity2001 4y agoNote that "up" is consistently in the north west. I have a suspicion that the four 45 degrees rotated poles are reflected in the hieroglyph 𓊖 for the four city quarters (urbis & orbis). since they are not anchored on the pole star, they might just represent idealized points of sunrise / sunset yet being aware of the pole star or at least the symmetry.
- balfebs 4y agoI believe that 9,000 years ago there wasn’t as distinct a pole star due to axial procession. Celestial north would probably have been somewhere between Vega and Tau Hercluis with a fairly wide separation.
- cryptonector 4y agoThere would have been circumpolar stars though, and those would have been very noticeable.
- layer8 4y agoDirect link to figure: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0277927.g009 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0277927.g009
- canadianfella 4y ago[dead]
- dclowd9901 4y agoThese are incredibly clever. They chased an animal into a space with some areas that look like escapes but are actually pitfalls. That requires such high level thinking. They’re really putting themselves in the mind of the scared animal in designing something like this. I’m fully aware that people of this era did not have the mentality of toddlers, but there’s still something to be said for the level of social development and communication that must be present to convince a large group of folks to build out one of these things.
- singularity2001 4y agoThese features might have arisen through "natural evolution" of traps but I doubt not that people of that era where capable of comprehending the architecture once it was there.
- qrybam 4y agoI understand that this comment probably wasn’t meant in this way but it comes off as condescending of people from only a few thousand years ago and it feels like my friends were being spoken about (personally!) We have to remember that it’s humans we're talking about here, and that this wasn’t exactly that long ago. They would have had the same cognitive potential as us, if not more simply because we’re lazy ungrateful creatures living in a level of comfort that royalty of old could not even imagine. The cost of a mistake in their “real world” was often death, and they _had_ to get it right so that their family didn’t die. People can spontaneously self organise and achieve all sorts of things “on the spot”, kids in the playground do this daily- making up fun games without any parental input. I don’t believe you need a whole level of social development beyond “I won’t kill you, let’s be friends” to achieve great things. This becomes complicated as groups grow of course, but I would imagine most of us have experienced this on some level. Necessity is the mother of innovation. Doing something the hard/impossible way a few times will force you to be creative, especially when you need to feed your family/group.
- dalbasal 4y agoThey were probably very skilled at this kind of thinking, more than and I. You have to emphasize with an animal to track it, for example. Even non human hunters have such intuitions. A wildcat knows when a squirrel is likely to head for the nearest tree. By the time such structures were being built, coralling using simpler or natural terrain features was probably an important hunting method. Imo the notable part here is the scale and it's implications. Large groups. Long term projects. Long lived assets. A progressive mindset, where the "economy" and roles within it change. That's not, seemingly, the default.
- fsckboy 4y agoat a gut level, and I have no expertise, it seems more likely that these are representations created after the fact of what was built, rather than plans for what would be built. I base that mostly on the irregular arrangement of arcs along the circumference, which irregular arrangement could easily come about during construction with materials at hand, and then be drawn to scale, rather than being planned and then constructed. But again, what do I know.
- pixel_tracing 4y agoI would think some degree of carbon dating might answer this question?
- singularity2001 4y agonot if the drawing was done shortly after the creation, because carbon dating lacks such high precision
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoMy gut agrees and would add that the map diagram makes for a great training/planning tool on its own as a way to organize the multiple teams involved with corralling animals into their Kite. I think its an old school chalkboard and have just as much reason to believe it as I do any other explanation.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoWritten down before or after initial construction aren't substantially different. I don't have as much specific knowledge of kites in particular, but based on similar structures elsewhere they almost certainly weren't continuously used and maintained. They would likely be used for one or two seasons, then abandoned for potentially decades at a time as the migrations shifted. When herds eventually returned to the area, people would likely go out and do some restoration ahead of the herds. That would be things like re-excavating the pits, replacing any decayed brush/sticks in the terminal funnels, repairing pit walls, and so on. You can't skip parts or animals may escape and the structure may be covered in all manner of brush or sediment that makes identification difficult on the ground. It's not necessary to have a plan for the kite, but it would still be pretty useful, especially if it's one that's rarely used so most of the people present might have never seen it.
- newswasboring 4y agoDoes anyone else get minecraft vibes from this? I find it amusing that kids playing minecraft came up with similar structures (in spirit). Of course the specifics are different because the animals are different. Also I think the neolithic people who came up with this might be teenagers, right? Did minecraft wake up some kind of neolithic dormant program in our brains? I only half joke about this.
- lucas_membrane 4y agoHow were these structures dated? Did they have some wooden parts, or were there animal remains that could be carbon dated found with them? Something else?
- lucozade 4y ago> How were these structures dated? The study [0] mentions that they dated charcoal that they have reason to believe was contemporaneous. [0] https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0277927 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- stinos 4y agoHow earlier cultures built huge structures—including kites that can only be fully seen from the sky—has remained a mystery This can only be fully seen from the sky struck me as somewhat odd, almost downplaying that all in all mammals and even simpler species are really good in basic navigation. I mean going from A to B and back among various lines if we've never done so before or even if we've done before but suddenly there are obstacles in between, is no problem for us. Unlike for, say, some of my chickens or simple AI models. Doesn't really matter if we can see the whole picture from the sky or not. In fact doing so without seeing the whole picture is exactly part of the skill? Or is this perhaps a comment about drawing such route? Ok that's a bit more specialist, but the accuracy in historic maps shows it's a skill we've had for a long time. And this dicovery might just be the earliest proof of it.
- bordercontrol 4y agoThis Vice article is a pretty bad sum up, nearly all questions/opinios asked/raised here are commented in this good NZZ article: https://www.nzz.ch/wissenschaft/desert-kites-archaeologen-datieren-grosse-tierfallen-in-der-wueste-ld.1738080 https://www.nzz.ch/wissenschaft/desert-kites-archaeologen-da... It's German, but shouldn't matter much in th days of AI. ChatGPT anwsers to some questions brought up here based on the NZZ article: 1. The "Desert Kites" or stone structures were dated using two methods. The researchers used Carbon-14 (C14) dating on charcoal samples found near the structures. Carbon-14 dating can only be used on once-living material like wood or bone, hence its use on the charcoal. They also used a technique called Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL), which measures the last time sand grains were exposed to sunlight, based on the accumulation of electrons in their crystal structure. These two techniques revealed that the structures are between 7560 and 9000 years old. 2. Your instinct aligns with the interpretations of the researchers. The article suggests that the rock carvings depicting these structures may have been created after their construction rather than as blueprints. One reason for this is that the physical structures follow topography, incorporating or based on terrain features which are not reflected in the plans. The researchers propose that these drawings could have been used for hunting planning, demonstrating attributes of the structures that aren't noticeable from ground level. Also, they argue these drawings could serve as a demonstration of knowledge, the ability to depict spatial elements, and the act of transmitting this knowledge. The idea that these could be plans created before construction is less likely but not entirely dismissed.
- rixary 4y agoInsert unnecessary comment about using chatGPT to refute sources