2 ms·
> Why should I have to cover the cost of someone else’s poor decision to buy an ultra expensive to repair vehicle? You don't. You have to cover the cost of th
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Why should I have to cover the cost of someone else’s poor decision to buy an ultra expensive to repair vehicle?
You don't.
You have to cover the cost of the damage you caused unlawfully, not the cost of their decision to buy an expensive to repair vehicle. Routine repairs that aren’t due to torts for which other people are liable are the reaponsibility of the owner, and those are the only ones that are natural consequences of the purchase decision. Consequences of tort are...consequences of tort. Victims don’t owe tortfeasors a duty of care to minimize likely damages in the event of tort.
As to why you are liable for harms you caused even though they might have been cheaper were the victim
differently situated, well, that’s basically the well-established “eggshell skull” rule of tort liability.
- sieongioetnio 4y agoHowever you want to justify it, the result is the same: luxury toys are subsidized by people who don't buy them. Every expensive car sold makes everyone's insurance premiums go up. This is a transfer of wealth from the poor and the prudent to the rich and the vain. Any legal principle that supports that is wrong.
- firstlink 4y agoIt sounds like you are advocating for the deeply fascistic concept of "personal responsibility". Not a good look.