4 ms·
i almost didn't open this because it said 'e-paper' and i've sort of dismissed e-paper for this kind of thing this is much more interesting than an e-paper dev
by kragen 4y ago
i almost didn't open this because it said 'e-paper' and i've sort of dismissed e-paper for this kind of thing
this is much more interesting than an e-paper device; it's a memory-in-pixel lcd device, which means 100 times better refresh rate and 1000 times better power consumption than e-paper. the lcd in question (ls027b7dh01, i assume, though that information is missing from the web pages) is supposed to run on 175μW at 20fps, so you can get a full usable computer system in submilliwatt territory, so the 2.2 kilojoules in a cr2032 can power it for weeks
however, i think that, as a low-power device, this is probably fatally flawed. the rp2040 dooms it; the rp2040 lacks a reasonable deep-sleep mode; its lowest-power mode is nearly a milliwatt, so it will drain the battery flat when it's not being used
also it's unclear, in this design, how much the rp2040 can do without powering up the pi zero, which is a humongous power hog, using over 1000 milliwatts. so instead of weeks of active use from a cr2032 (and months of standby if you use a low-power micro instead of an rp2040) you get hours
what's the point of using a super expensive memory-in-pixel lcd to get the display power consumption down from e-paper's 10-100 milliwatts into submilliwatt territory if you're just going to burn a thousand milliwatts in a raspberry pi? just use a conventional lcd then, maybe one with nice 24-bit color. old nokia lcds will run on a milliwatt
maybe an esp32 would be a better middle ground if you aren't willing to go all the way to an ambiq apollo3 or something, which can (hypothetically) give you submilliwatt power consumption with workstation-class performance, as long as you don't need virtual memory; you probably want an esp32 or equivalent in there anyway for wi-fi
usb-c is a great way to be able to hook up a full-size external keyboard, but speaking usb-c to a keyboard is also probably beyond the capabilities of the rp2040, and so would also need to power up the giant power hog pi zero
- knodi123 4y ago> its lowest-power mode is nearly a milliwatt, so it will drain the battery flat when it's not being used Add a hardware power button?
- dheera 4y agoI'm not too sure of this trend of rebranding 1980's monochrome LCDs as the "new" e-paper. The refresh rates are nice but it's really not the same, and in direct sunlight on a hot California day you can see a world of difference between the contrast and glare of a high school graphing calculator and a Kindle.
- xpe 4y agoFrom what I understand, memory-in-pixel LCD technology is relatively new to the market. Does it rely on the same screen as “1980s” LCDs?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kragen 4y agothese aren't 1980s lcds, they have an order of magnitude better contrast (slightly better contrast than a swindle), reportedly an order of magnitude lower power (i haven't measured mine yet), and much lower latency. this memory-in-pixel stuff relies on fabricating an entire flip-flop in every pixel, made of a layer of silicon on the glass, and that capability seems to be only about 13 years old, and only sharp has it they do have glare but are quite readable in direct sunlight or outdoors in the shade or on a cloudy day also they cost almost three orders of magnitude more but they definitely aren't epaper. aside from the glare, speed, contrast, and power consumption differences, they fade in about 30 seconds when you unplug them, rather than staying stable for years, and they don't have grayscale
- AlanYx 4y ago>in direct sunlight on a hot California day you can see a world of difference between the contrast and glare of a high school graphing calculator and a Kindle. Sharp Memory LCDs are reflective, not transreflective. They're easier to read outdoors than indoors, much like eink. (Sharp markets these screens for devices like bike computers and gas pumps.) Some of the optical properties are in the same ballpark as eink as well.
- myself248 4y agoAye, the "diagram" shows nothing of the topology. Can the rp2040 run the show with the Zero not even attached? That would be interesting. Furthermore, there's no radio other than what's on the Zero? That whacks it right into useless territory for me. What's the point of a low-power device if all it has is high-power communication? My first/only care for this would be a LoRa backpack. Or even some Nordic thing, or BLE, I don't really care, just anything's better than wifi.
- kragen 4y agowell, i think an autonomous computer can be pretty useful. i mean, i used computers for 12 years before i got internet access; the closest i got to networking was dialing up bbses maybe if you had a speaker you could do ultrasonic communication with ble-like range; there are several megahertz of spectrum there that can propagate through air for a few meters, and milliwatts might be adequate. similarly with infrared; historically it's suffered a lot from highly directional interfaces that assume stupid, fragile encoding schemes, but we have enough compute now to do better but yeah a low-power radio would open up a world of possibilities
- deepspace 4y agoSpot on. I was so excited to see the form factor, and then my excitement was deflated as soon as I noticed the component details. Note to any hardware hackers out there: I would buy the crap out of a unit in this form factor with an ESP32, LiPo charging, and proper deep-sleep oriented circuit design (I have seen too many circuits with cheap voltage regulators leaking many tens of μA).
- sqfmi 4y agoYou may be interested in our other product Franky then :) https://sqfmi.com/franky/ https://sqfmi.com/franky/
- tired_star_nrg 4y agoDoesn’t look like it’s available to purchase though :(
- b1ue64 4y agoI can see the beepberry page but this gives a generic database error.
- rudyfink 4y agoI had the same result. This is the best photo/description I could find: https://www.hackster.io/news/sqfmi-s-franky-gets-a-blackberry-keyboard-upgrade-becomes-a-pocket-friendly-beeper-chat-gadget-372b812d6fb0 https://www.hackster.io/news/sqfmi-s-franky-gets-a-blackberr... .
- kragen 4y agothis is more promising but you forgot the keyboard can you plug in an external keyboard or are you supposed to program it via whisper.cpp speech recognition
- garfieldnate 3y agoThat page just has some pictures. Is there a GH repo for the design, or some other kind of documentation? I would love to learn how this is built.
- csdvrx 4y ago> the rp2040 dooms it; the rp2040 lacks a reasonable deep-sleep mode; its lowest-power mode is nearly a milliwatt, so it will drain the battery flat when it's not being used Low tech immediate solution: add a power switch cutting off the battery. Bad for the RTC, but it's nothing that NTP or even rdate can't fix (or just don't use the switch if you need the RTC) Better solution: replace the rp2040 in the next revision.
- kragen 4y agothat's not a solution, for three reasons the screen will fade after 30 seconds (unlike epaper) once or twice an hour you'll forget to turn off the switch when you stop to think and the battery will drain anyway and you'll corrupt the flash
- csdvrx 4y ago> the screen will fade after 30 seconds (unlike epaper) So what? I see that as a positive! > you'll forget to turn off the switch Uh, if I don't see the screen fading in 30 seconds, I'll conclude I forgot. > once or twice an hour I intend to only turn on the device when I need it. > and you'll corrupt the flash I don't think so, I use industrial SDs + journaling filesystems, and I do `sync` before turning off my devices.
- kragen 4y agolet's contrast the sensibly designed device with the design i think you are describing on the sensibly designed device, say i'm answering an email. i look at the screen, ponder for 30 seconds, scroll down, ponder for 30 seconds, and hit reply. redrawing the screen took, perhaps, a million clock cycles each time, so it required powering up a 240 megahertz esp32 for 2 milliseconds. so i've consumed 6 milliseconds of cpu, 0.6 millijoules at 100 milliwatts, plus the 50 microwatts of the screen for 60 seconds, which is 3 millijoules then i spend 10 minutes typing out a 300-word reply at 60 words per minute with a duty cycle of about 50%. each time i press a key, the cpu powers up, processes for an average of 65536 clock cycles (0.3 ms), updates the screen, and powers back down. in total my 1500 keystrokes result in 450 ms of cpu time and 45 millijoules. keeping the screen active has cost another 30 millijoules. finally i power up the 1.5 watt wifi radio hardware for 100 milliseconds and send the mail, consuming another 150 millijoules total power consumption to read and answer the email: a bit under 250 millijoules. i'll get over 9000 emails out of a cr2032 coin cell, about six months of use [i'm being very generous with these numbers to be sure to estimate conservatively. my best estimate is that this screen will hold 12 lines of 40 characters of text readably, and proportional-font layout with word wrap takes about 40 clock cycles per character, including blitting from a font bitmap, so redrawing the screen should take about 19200 cycles, not a million; and handling a text editing keystroke should average 7500 cycles, not 65536; and sending an email over wifi should require it to be powered up for 1 ms, not 100.] with what i think is your proposed design, i have to leave the pi zero running at 1 watt for the whole 11 minutes, so i use 660 joules, 2640 times as much. the cr2032 coin cell will last me for 3.3 emails 2640 times more energy consumption means 1/2640 the battery life. with the battery they propose to use i think it's 33 emails vs. 90000 instead of 3.3 vs. 9000 [corrected obvious dumb math error above, sorry] evidently the second device is not an adequate replacement for the first even if it does support sixel --- as for corrupting the flash, a flash block that was partially written before the chip lost power looks exactly like a correctly written block some percentage of the time, maybe a high percentage like 99%. but sometimes you will read back corrupted data, maybe depending on temperature, emi, or state of charge. so cutting power to your industrial sds when you're not sure if the flash is writing or not is going to bite you sooner or later better hope it's not on orbit when it happens it was for me
- erohead 4y agoFirst off - this thing was designed to be a fun hacker toy, not a real product. Buyer beware! Plan for power management is pretty simple - trim as much fat from OS startup sequence as possible to get boot-times down to ~5s, eg https://github.com/IronOxidizer/instant-pi https://github.com/IronOxidizer/instant-pi. Then turn the Pi off as much as possible. Write to screen, turn off Pi. Set timers on rp2040 to turn Pi on periodically. With the 2000mAh battery, if the plan works, it should run for a while.
- kragen 4y agodoes that mean that every time you hit a key (after the idle timeout) you have to wait 5 seconds for the pi to boot, wasting 5 more precious joules (a minute of active usage battery life at 100mW) or does the pi zero have a submilliwatt suspend to ram and i'm just the last to know i think that it could be a fun hacker toy if you put a low-power microcontroller on it with access to the screen and keyboard and control over the pi's power rails (and the rp2040's if you put that in too) as a bonus if the low-power micro was an esp32 you would have wifi and bluetooth then you only need to fire up the pi when its computational gronk is really needed, and the ui stays responsive the whole time 2 amp hours (why would you say 'two thousand milliamp hours', that's four extra syllables for no reason) is 27 kilojoules at 3.7 volts; that's ten months at one milliwatt, a weekend at an esp32-like 100 milliwatts, 7 hours at an optimistic one watt, or three hours at 2.5 watts, which i think is more realistic for the pi you won't even be able to use this thing all night with the pi running; you'll need an external battery to recharge it before the sun comes back up, like that old laptop that you used to take out of the house back when its battery lasted more than two hours also 2 amp hours is somewhere in the neighborhood of 20 grams of battery, while the rest of the device is i think around 15 grams. admittedly still pretty small and light compared to the fragile monsters that pass for android cellphones nowadays
- erohead 4y ago> does that mean that every time you hit a key (after the idle timeout) you have to wait 5 seconds for the pi to boot, wasting 5 more precious joules (a minute of active usage battery life at 100mW) Yes, that's exactly the plan. Pi zero does not have suspend to ram unfortunately, hence this elaborate work around. Remember, the use case is a weekend chat device. This power management scheme fits the use case perfectly.