11 ms·
Wizards of the Coast Raids YouTuber’s House to Take Back Magic Cards
- northernskys30 4y agoFeels like Inscryption (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inscryption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inscryption).
- scrollaway 4y agoSpoilers! But I vividly recommend this game to everyone. Do go in blind, though.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoCan confirm, this is a wonderful game that will do wonder if you avoid any kind of information before playing it. It has amazing creativity, novel and fun gameplay, a very strong personality and an opinionated design.
- joshu 3y agoYou weren’t kidding. And there is another game/story embedded in the obvious one. Holy crap.
- scrollaway 3y agoGlad the recommendation got to you :)
- joshu 3y agodid you watch the stuff about the hidden story? an arg that extends beyond the game: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dT6odjCnKqg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dT6odjCnKqg
- digdugdirk 4y agoHuh. I didn't realize the Pinkerton's were still a thing. Its interesting to see an example of how they operate nowadays when they aren't able to roll in armed and ready like the good ol' days. That being said, I suppose them threatening to call in the police does that for them.
- carlmr 4y agoThere was no evidence of wrongdoing on his part. Even if they had evidence that he stole something, a private militia shouldn't be called to enforce this, but a police investigation. Somebody at WotC should be held liable for this. Are there no laws in America against this?
- colpabar 4y ago[flagged]
- phpisthebest 4y agoYes, but it requires people to know their legal rights, and engage with them Had the police been called most likely the police would have said "this is a civil matter" not done nothing, at most taken a report for a detective to investigate the alleged theft. Also had the homeowner just said "leave my property", and then the police called, the private militia would then be trespassing and the police would remove them. Here however the homeowner basically consented to the actions, the search, and the seizure while under threat of additional legal action they still consented. Know your rights.
- mindslight 4y agoThat is a good description of what is, but not what ought to be. It's very easy to discuss this after the fact, detached from the situation with a calm head, and be confident that this victim would have been legally in the clear. But rational analysis is sorely absent when an armed gang shows up at your door demanding something and threatening more violence if you don't comply. The legal dynamic in the US has basically evolved to justify shakedown behavior, where it's technically possible to "stand up" for your rights if you know the exact song and dance at the right time, but practically most people don't and can't. Whereas what really needs to happen is for various aggressor parties to be legally restrained from using coercion to begin with. And that's not even touching the dynamic where various types of aggressors end up shooting first despite being in the wrong, cry "self defense", and then successfully avoid getting charged with second degree murder.
- Spooky23 4y agoI’d laugh in their faces as I slammed the door.
- rationalist 4y agoAs would I, but the average person does not have that kind of wherewithal. It is still something we should be concerned about it, as I do not want to live in a world where this is commonplace, and I imagine you wouldn't want to either.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoYeah, people need to start teaching kids about their rights. Otherwise, kids who don't know about the 4th amendment (that you can tell actual police to go away and that's doubly true for rent-a-cops) are going to grow up and keep voting in politicians who'll keep chipping away at our rights more and more
- delecti 4y agoNote that this was about a month ago. If you see the title and think "again?!", no, this is the same incident where they sent Pinkertons. Not that it's not worth discussing, just that I'm sure someone might otherwise wonder.
- George83728 4y agoSo, is this guy done with Magic, or will he keep buying and promoting their products? WoC have been known assholes for years now, I would think people would figure it out by now.
- rationalist 4y agoI used to play MTG 20-15 years ago. I do not play anymore because of the constantly evolving playset, mechanics, and rules that I could not keep up with. I'm even more put off lately by the seemingly-cash-grab of incorporating other games/words such as Dungeons and Dragons and I think Lord of the Rings.
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago> I do not play anymore because of the constantly evolving playset, mechanics, and rules that I could not keep up with. Yep. I took a couple of years off in the late 90s and there was no going back.
- ldoughty 4y agoSounds like the buyer should have ASKED for the sheriff.... Private police threatening fines and jail time? Let them say that with law enforcement around for any follow up lawsuit. A purchase was made and the wrong product arrived at his door.. the seller had legitimate reason to have the product, but broke a street date... The customer did not ask for unreleased product... Sounds like the dealer is at fault, but not "stolen property"... Do card dealers not own their inventory before a street date? (And, therefore, sold product that was not his?) (Vs. breach of contract)
- PointA2B 4y agoHe could've closed the door in their faces and there would be nothing they could do about it. The company relied on theatrics and false threats to get back a legitimately purchased product.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoCould've, but theatrics are used because it's effective. A surprise morning visit by professional intimidators arguing that you "do what we say or you might spend the next decade in jail" can override a lot of logical reasoning.
- jjoonathan 4y agoThat's why it needs to be a crime to impersonate law enforcement. I thought it was already, but here we are.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIs there any indication or evidence anyone impersonated law enforcement?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- nullc 4y agoI get that the youtuber just wanted no trouble, but he may have really screwed himself by not insisting on a waver of liability, agreement that the existing videos can stay up (or, alternatively, compensation to replace the lost income from them), and compensation for his costs at a minimum. Handing WOTC's paid thugs the material probably didn't do anything to reduce his risk and took away the little leverage he had -- they could even try to spin his willingness to hand it over as an admission that his possession was unlawful.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThey could try, but all he has to do is mention the intimidation factor of Pinkertons at the door while under oath and I doubt a jury would find him liable for anything. Plus, at that point, he could probably afford a really good lawyer from crowdfunded donations. Wizards already has a PR issue from this happening in the first place. They'd be civilly negligent toward the Hasbro shareholders to push it any further.
- nullc 4y agoFrom the comments it sounds like their "threats" were threats of legal action-- that isn't likely to count as intimidation... and if he's gone far enough in court to end up in front of a jury he would probably already be financially ruined. Now, if he asked them to leave and they didn't that would be something else. Unfortunately when you're not very wealthy the question if you'd ultimately win or not isn't very important. That's why it's important to get bright line clarity such that if they brought any claims your odds of getting a summary dismissal would be very good. Your point about the threat being limited by the specter of damage to their brand is a good one except if that were the motivation they wouldn't have opened with an in personal physical confrontation against a party with a highly visible public platform. > he could probably afford a really good lawyer from crowdfunded donations I doubt it. Sometimes that happens, but often people just blame the victim because there is always a never ending list of nitpicks ("Why didn't he tell the pinkertons they were tresspassing, ask them to leave and send a letter", "why didn't he insist on a release from the company", "he had to know this would happen when he put the video up in the first place!"). And even when the lawyers paid for, nothing can compensate you for the time, disruption in your life, and stress of being targeted.
- mercutio2 4y agoPrivate security appearing at your door may be intimidating, but it’s not a raid. Threatening someone with fines or jail time, who took receipt of distributed but embargoed product, i.e. by no stretch of the imagination illegal to possess, is the sort of thing you might want to look into legal options for, though.
- klyrs 4y ago[flagged]
- ghostpepper 4y agoI'm surprised these private security goons don't get guns pointed at them more often. As I understand American law it would be legal to shoot them if they refused to leave your property in some states.
- JohnFen 4y agoWhen I was in my teens, I spent a few months doing door-to-door canvassing. I had guns pointed at me on three separate occasions, just for knocking on the front door.
- ars 4y agoTry not to get your news from social media. What you wrote isn't actually true.
- InitialLastName 4y agoNotoriety is in the eye of the beholder. It doesn't matter whether the police are _actually_ trigger-happy; as long as they have a reputation for excessive use of violence, a threat to involve them is a perceived threat of violence.
- klyrs 4y agoI get my news from quite a few sources. But you're here on a social media site devoted to sharing news, commenting on a news article. Are you not getting your news from social media right here, right now? What I wrote is entirely true, I didn't say that a threat to call the cops is %100 guarantee to shoot somebody. I said that there's a nonzero probability. SWATting, for example, has killed several people who did nothing wrong. Personal experience: I've had a gun pulled on me a couple times while un-armed and non-threatening. Most amusing one: got pulled over for expired tabs and had a boffer sword (not even remotely realistic looking, mostly red duct tape) in my back seat.
- OskarS 4y agoI always wonder about stories like this what the internal process that lead to this insane overreaction was. At some point, did someone really make the decision "lets send Pinkertons to this guy's house, risking an enormous publicity backlash"? It's easy to blame "the legal department" for stuff like this, but it seems extreme even for the most zealous attorney. My hunch is that they probably have some kind of security contract with the Pinkertons to safeguard secrets, and the Pinkertons acted on their own. Hasbro/WotC has done some sketchy stuff recently, but this seems extreme even for them.
- jldugger 4y ago> Hasbro/WotC has done some sketchy stuff recently, but this seems extreme even for them. I'm told their security executive used to be a pinkerton.
- jstarfish 4y agoIf true, that explains a lot. This sort of response appears deranged to outsiders, but would be completely logical if you rationalize it as calling in a favor from your former colleagues. For someone like that, it's not a vulgar display of force-- it's just another Tuesday. Optics are overlooked in favor of ease.
- JohnFen 4y ago> My hunch is that they probably have some kind of security contract with the Pinkertons to safeguard secrets, and the Pinkertons acted on their own This is almost certainly the case, but Pinkerton was acting as agents of WotC here, so WotC are the ones ultimately responsible.
- OskarS 4y agoFor sure. I didn't mean to imply otherwise. I was just saying I'm always curious about what the processes are in companies that lead to these disastrous results.
- lmkg 4y ago
- jmyeet 4y agoThe most interesting part of this (other than the completely unnecesary, tone-deaf corporate thuggery) is the involvement of the Pinkertons because many people don't know the history of the Pinkerton National Detective Agency, which was really prominent in the mid to late 19th century. At this time, the US had no real Federal law enforcement to speak of. That came later, modeled after the Pinkertons. Fun fact: the FBI evolved as a result of the Mann Act [1], which was aimed at stopped at white women being "trafficked" across state lines by black men so really it was misagenation. Anyway, the Pinkertons evolved as corporate muslce in the robber baron era. Strike-breaking, intimidation, sabotage, that sort of thing. At one point the Pinkertons were larger than the US Army. Thier downfall really began with with embarrassing incidents like the Homestead Strike [2]. Honestly two of the better depictions of the Pinkertons come from fiction: HBO's excellent Deadwood series and Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2. The most important lesson here is that law enforcement in the US historically, culturally and actually exists to protect the interests of the wealthy, first and foremost. as for WotC, they could've made good PR out of this by asking nicely for the cards back and giving the person something for their troubles since ultimately the mistake was WotC's. But no, let's choose violence. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mann_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mann_Act [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago"miscegenation" Interestingly enough, the Mann Act was used to prosecute a high-and-mighty in the KKK: https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/news/stories/2004/march/kkk031104 https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/news/stories/2004/march/kk...
- f0e4c2f7 4y agoWizards of the Coast seems to be on a rampage to do as much damage to their brand as possible. Weren't they pretty beloved by fans before some of these more recent actions? It's like they've turned into the Comcast of table top games. What do they really have beyond their brand? People can play other games.
- dgb23 4y agoIt's a shit show and plenty of people are not OK with it, including prominent content creators (for both DnD and MTG) that have a huge draw.
- permo-w 4y agothe DnD movie was very good. maybe they’re getting overconfident
- nickthegreek 4y agoApparently not good enough for a sequel though. Kinda sad how good something has to do to be considered successful these days.
- permo-w 4y agoI find it more sad that something being good necessitates sequels
- danjoredd 4y agoThey said before the movie released that it was not their intention to make a franchise out of the movie. They were open to making a franchise, but the movie was designed to stand alone. In the age of cinematic universes making a D&D cinematic universe makes a lot of sense, but thats not what the authors wanted. “It was never our intention when we came on board this film to make a franchise . . . I think that would cloud our ability to focus entirely on the film at hand. The cardinal mistake many studios make is to put the cart before the horse, where they start crafting a cinematic universe before they even make a good single film. So first and foremost for us was getting this right.” https://www.polygon.com/23665427/dungeons-and-dragons-honor-among-thieves-sequel-drizzt-dourden https://www.polygon.com/23665427/dungeons-and-dragons-honor-...
- rjbwork 4y agoLucky they didn't get shot. A private entity has no right to raid your house. That is some extremely ballsy behavior for a non-state actor in the US.
- last_responder 4y agoThere was no raid
- Throw73849 4y agoYou ask them to leave, they do not... Unless the "security" recorded and streamed everything into cloud, very difficult to prove.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stale2002 4y agoNo, actually. You cannot just shoot someone who is standing outside your doorway, And claim that they were trying to break in. You would go to jail.
- nickthegreek 4y ago>You would go to jail. You could go to jail. In some state's in the US, it is by no way guaranteed.
- Throw73849 4y agoWhatever. Coming into someones house to make threats is very stupid idea. One day I came into my kitchen, there is my wife crying, and three big threating guys I do not know. I ask them to leave, instead of heading to door, they are aggressive and surround me. What do you thing is going to happen?
- rightbyte 4y ago
- shepardrtc 4y agoWhoever at WotC decided to send them should be fired. It's just a trading card game. Contact the guy through normal means and ask him to return them.
- prepend 4y agoThere’s a massive list of bonehead decisions made by WotC and none have resulted in firing. It’s an interesting hobby where fans have played no matter what the company does and the company knows that.
- nickthegreek 4y ago>It’s an interesting hobby where fans have played no matter what the company does and the company knows that. I don't think thats true. They walked back their license BS over fan outrage.
- prepend 4y agoThat was d&d, I’m talking about magic stuff. Just off the top of my head, they just seem generally incompetent and people keep buying. Here’s some stuff I remember: -underprinting (legends) and overprinting (fallen empires) -saying they wouldn’t reprint things (reserved list) then reprinting some, and monkeying around with it for 5 years -original magic online in early 00s was completely poorly built at the time of lots of other MOOCs and a super lively IRC open source client, Apprentice, that they could have just cloned -launching their new digital game, arena, as desktop only for its first three years -killing their tournament play -cutting out local stores with direct to consumer sales (and massive distribution through Amazon) -$100 “vip” booster packs -poor quality control that makes cards look like pringles -multiple versions of each card with different foiling techniques -firing artists over liking tweets -new product every two months instead of 3-4 times per year -freaking out over leaked spoilers -telling some people what cards would be reprinted beforehand to have them purchase or sell accordingly -not putting shandalar on steam/ never making sequels
- 4y ago
- api_or_ipa 4y agoHuh, if Pinkerton thugs showed up at my door, I would have demanded a warrant + actual law enforcement to even start the conversation. It's not like they have any more privileges than regular people. On the other hand, if they showed up with regular employees and pleaded their case to me I would probably help them out. Showing up with private heat is the best way ensure I'll think twice about being helpful.
- JohnFen 4y ago> Showing up with private heat is the best way ensure I'll think twice about being helpful. This. If you want me to be cooperative, set the tone by being cooperative yourself.
- nickthegreek 4y agoIdeally with fists full of cash.
- duxup 4y agoI wonder if they just offered this guy a few grand how it would have gone? Maybe really well?
- newsclues 4y agoHe could have been placated with the cards he ordered some extras or merch. Hiring security was the more expensive option, in short and long term.
- Verdex 4y agoYeah, this is sort of a case of tearing defeat out of the jaws of victory. Show up with some money, a bunch of magic swag + cards, and offer to create a card making them some sort of in game knight or king or something. Photograph everything and have them sign a non-disparage and suddenly you've got some PR that's worth it's weight in gold. And the next time a little card mishap goes down you'll get people volunteering to give them back in hopes of a tenth of what you gave out the first time. Or you could just do nothing because almost definitely nobody actually cares or will notice. Jumping to sending private security to someone else's private residence feels like an absolute last resort to a much more serious issue.
- Reubachi 4y agoThis really doesn't belong on HN. Old story, editorialized, and ultimatley a non-story with no impact beyond WOTC looking foolish, which is not newsworthy.
- Freedom2 4y agoWhat's more important than all those factors is if it generates "curious" discussion. Reading through the comments, I indeed say it does!
- rootsudo 4y ago1. No legal cause or case. 2. They were basically trespassing, if only the owner asked them to leave. 3. Person invited them in and let them take their property. Geez people really just create the drama they want. Easily should've told them to pound dirt and slam the door in their face. Instead the article goes on about one agent being apologetic, and the others not caring. People really are not aware of their rights. Remember, if someone has to ASK you or have you CONSENT you can say no. But it seems people don't know they can refuse anymore.
- jstarfish 4y ago> Remember, if someone has to ASK you or have you CONSENT you can say no. But it seems people don't know they can refuse anymore. "Just say no" on police matters is not good universal advice. It can have undesirable consequences. Two immediate examples: If you're pulled over and the cop wants to search your car for drugs, you can play roadside lawyer if you'd like. Say no-- it's your right. They'll bring in a drug dog, it'll ring positive (coerced or not), then they proceed to disassemble your car to punish you for being obstinate-- we're talking ripping off door panels and liners to look behind and underneath. Reassembly is for you to deal with. If you have nothing to hide, you save yourself some trouble by just consenting before they call in the dog, which only ever increases the invasiveness of the search. Fail early. Same for DUI. You don't have to take a roadside sobriety test. Invoking your right to say no means you're getting detained anyway and will spend the next few hours in the hospital lab, which you will be billed for later. If you were drunk, you lose either way, but being stubborn is the costlier approach. Fail early. You have some rights on land you own. Fewer rights on land you rent. No rights on the road.
- rootsudo 4y ago100% Disagree. While dogs can ring positive for coerced, you want to make sure the search is as illegal as possible so that any evidence can be tossed, no evidence == no case. A dog can signal falsely for "drugs" but let's say they found $8000, that you have a receipt from the bank? While they will attempt civil forfeiture -- the dog was only for drugs - meaning no drugs found == better attempt to get that case thrown. Same for other medications, or any contraband. For your DUI example, many a lawyer I talked too and in my university days every law/pre-law professor stated if that ever happened, they would always refuse because it does not present evidence easily - a few hours in a hospital lab means any test result then will be delayed, and lets say you were drunk, (something I don't condone) - you now have more time to sober up and the further test results will be farther from when the stop was done. It is much easier to defeat a DUI Charge if there was no evidence at roadside that you were actually impaired. Even if your car is towed and you're billed high for the forced blood test and what not - it is still cheaper than a DUI charge which runs $15,000 nowadays, not including the future insurance waivers/SR-22/FR-44 probably required. You have rights, it is much easier to win a case/have your case dismissed if there is proof the police violated your rights. Lawyers glee and prosecutors will drop cases where there is overt police rights violation. I would say depending on the area, and on your race/skin color is more of a issue if you're being pulled over vs not consenting to a search because bias exists and LEO will try and try more - but with dashcams and such - that's changing, marginally. Though the video of the uber lawyer lately has been making the laps, to the point where that officer in question did get a promotion.
- tedunangst 4y agoHow many agents and how heavily armed? People are saying he was raided by a militia, but the available details don't seem to support that conclusion.
- dpedu 4y agoBy law, unsolicited merchandise received via mail is yours to keep. I wonder how this will play out in court, if the YouTuber chooses to go that route. I don't see any reason why WOTC wouldn't lose, and lose badly? https://about.usps.com/publications/pub300a/pub300a_v04_revision_072019_tech_021.htm https://about.usps.com/publications/pub300a/pub300a_v04_revi...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rdl 4y agoSo many problems are avoided by just never answering the door (and figuring out some way to receive packages). If it's a uniformed police officer, "COME BACK WITH A WARRANT" or "CONTACT MY ATTORNEY AT X".
- bastard_op 4y agoWow, so much for treating your biggest fans with any respect. Not like he stole them, it would have been interesting had he stood his ground to see what they did. Shame he didn't have video of the encounter like Afroman did when raided. If I were a fan, this would have sobered me out of it immediately. Now I wonder what happened to the guy selling Zelda Tears of the Kingdom two weeks early that "fell off the back of the truck". Nintendo probably read this and put these thugs on retainer for the next major release, if they don't already.
- gnicholas 4y agoI'd be curious to know what exactly these Pinkerton agents said, and if they flashed badges (as other commenters have suggested). My general rule is not to let anyone in who doesn't have a warrant, and I think that still works in light of this kind of tactic. But I hadn't considered the possibility that non-LEOs might fool me/my family into thinking they are LEOs, and that they might not be bound by the same rules regarding tricking someone into letting them enter their home.
- alexander-wilms 4y agofuck kotaku
- ilyt 4y agoWell if anyone else was still wondering whether WotC is scum on earth...
- magic_hamster 4y agoDo not let anyone in your house unless it's a police officer with a warrant, and even then, verify their identity and the documents. You can easily do this by calling your police department. We have rights.
- throw9away6 4y agoPinkertons are right there with nazis and kkk members for me. Nothing good comes from cooperating with them.
- WelcomeShorty 4y agoSo the guy's a YouTuber, the biggest thing ever in his live happens and there is no actual footage of the incident?