3 ms·
Although MPs from England can't vote on the Scottish legislation per se, MPs from England make up most of the elected members of the present government, and tha
by tialaramex 4y ago
Although MPs from England can't vote on the Scottish legislation per se, MPs from England make up most of the elected members of the present government, and that government can and has used its power (misleadingly named "Royal Assent") to block legislation it doesn't like.
Basically they "advise" the Queen or King not to grant "assent" which is a formal part of the legislative process, so now the law is dead.
Now, it would likely prompt a straight up constitutional crisis and calls to declare independence unilaterally if they did this to some Scottish law about what is clearly a Scottish competence widely understood to be a matter for Scots, like rent reform, but they can do it anyway, they just haven't.
- arethuza 4y ago"but they can do it anyway, they just haven't" Isn't it fair to say that there are no restrictions on what the UK parliament could decide to do - they could do anything they just mostly haven't yet?
- tialaramex 4y agoYes, it's the nature of sovereignty that they don't acknowledge any restriction, including from themselves (Parliament can pass acts which say Parliament shan't do this or that, but such acts don't actually stop them doing what they said they shall not do) I just wanted to highlight that the observed asymmetry isn't as significant as it appears, but the consequence of trying this out, in both cases, might be a constitutional crisis. If you care to learn about this specific topic, look for the "West Lothian Question". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Lothian_question https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Lothian_question