4 ms·
Which is an odd state of affairs. Banks don't want that 2.5% mortgage on their books, so they should be offering incentives to get people off that mortgage.
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
Which is an odd state of affairs. Banks don't want that 2.5% mortgage on their books, so they should be offering incentives to get people off that mortgage. For example, offering a 4% rate to anybody holding a 2.5% mortgage would be a huge win-win for both sides.
- fallingknife 4y agoBanks hold almost no individual mortgage debt on their books. They are almost all packaged into agency securities backed by Fannie and Freddy
- bluGill 4y agoBanks don't care though, as they are not holding the mortgage, they are just servicing it. The mortgage itself is held by Freddy-Mac/Fanny-Mae, and sold on to bond holders. The bank is just charging a fee to service the loan, but the loan itself is on someone else's books. The above isn't 100% true, some banks do hold onto their own mortgages. However it is sill reasonable accurate.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThat should make it even easier. If it has been securitized, the value of that security is way below par value. For example, your $500,000 mortgage at 2.5% might only be worth $300,000 on the open market. Somebody could buy that mortgage backed bond for $300,000 and offer you a $500,000 mortgage at 4% in exchange, resell that mortgage for $400,000 and pocket the $100,000 difference. If I understand correctly, this is how the Danish mortgage system works.
- paul_f 4y agoGood idea, but mortgages are bundled together. You cannot split one off.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe owner of the bundle can.
- antisthenes 4y agoYes, well, the hiccup in your plan is someone voluntarily going from a 2.5% mortgage to a 4% mortgage. The incentive you would have to offer would erase most of that $100,000 difference you pulled out of a hat.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe incentive is the ability to move to a city with jobs without having to take on a 7% mortgage.
- afavour 4y agoI’m not sure it’s quite that simple. I got a mortgage at 3% some years ago for an apartment. Since then we’ve had two kids and paid off a chunk of the mortgage with our monthly payments. At this stage in my life I’d absolutely be looking to convert that into buying a larger home and would be happy to pay a higher rate for it to happen. But not literally double, which is where rates are today.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoWhy would you want to take this agreement? It’s equivalent to borrowing more against your house which isn’t inherently good. And we already have HELOC for people that want it
- toast0 4y agoThe proposed offer is to get a 4% loan on a different house in exchange for paying off the 2.5% loan on the existing home. It's good for the bank for obvious reasons, and it's good for the borrower (potentially) because it reduces the cost of moving.
- lesuorac 4y agoIIUC, the somebody spends 300k (for the 2.5% mortgage) and then an additional 500k (to you at 4%) to ultimately sell a mortgage for 400k which is a net 400k loss but they also now own the original house.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThey spend 300k for the original mortgage, and advance you another 500k at 4% for the new mortgage. At this point you owe them $1M. You then pay them 500k from the proceeds of selling the original house. They sell the new mortgage on for 400k, netting $100k. You also are ~$100K better off than if you had to pay $500K to get rid of the original mortgage and then had to borrow $500K at 7% for your new house.
- wanttocomment 4y ago[flagged]
- greenie_beans 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wanttocomment 4y ago[flagged]
- mizzao 4y agoThey already resold that 2.5% mortgage; some other party bears the risk now.
- xmcqdpt2 4y agoYou mean offering a 4% rate on a new home right? Otherwise it's only a win for the bank! It's complicated with mortgages because, in the US, mortgages are mostly securitized and resold. This covers 65% of mortgages in 2022 according to https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/staff_reports/sr1001.pdf https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/staff... So your mortgage isn't directly on your bank's book. The bank sold it, and then likely bought it back but as part of an MBS. In the US, there are a lot of small banks that rely on this to reduce their exposure to property prices in the local area they originate mortgages in.
- tclancy 4y agoThings don't work that way plus you're talking about having a loan for X at 2.5% and trying to offset it with a rate below the current market rate on what is likely a larger number than X and more years. Often substantially higher for both.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> For example, offering a 4% rate to anybody holding a 2.5% mortgage would be a huge win-win for both sides. Why would they do that when the US government is paying 4%+, and is much more creditworthy than an individual? That is why a 30 year fixed home mortgage is ~6%+. Individuals have to pay a premium since they do not have the power to print USD, and so more default risk has to be priced in. Plus the labor expenses of underwriting and issuing a new loan.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoYes, that is exactly why the mortgagee would want to get rid of the 2.5% mortgage. It's worth maybe half of its par value. So if the mortgager wants to get rid of the mortgage so they can move, and the mortgagee wants to get rid of the mortgage because it's worth only half of its par value, there should be a massive incentive for a fair deal to happen. Instead, the only option is for the mortgager to pay off the par value, which is a huge windfall for the mortgagee and a rip-off for the mortgager. So the mortgager decides not to move and everybody loses.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> So if the mortgager wants to get rid of the mortgage so they can move, The borrower wants to sell the house, so their main concern for the sale of their house is to earn enough from the sale to pay off the mortgage and be able to buy another house. In which case a higher new mortgage interest rate for the new house could be offset by lower house prices, but supply and demand have not recalibrated to that (yet). But of course, selling a house is not between the mortgage borrower and mortgage lender, it is between the homeowner and the potential new mortgage borrower, so there is an additional party involved whose needs need to be met. > and the mortgagee wants to get rid of the mortgage because it's worth only half of its par value, there should be a massive incentive for a fair deal to happen. The lender can sell the mortgage debt anytime it does not want it (and probably has anyway). The lender is currently deciding to lend to the government, at 4%, or an individual homeowner (or whatever others borrower). Of course, if the least risky entity is giving you 4%, then everyone else needs to give you more than 4%. Interest rates from previously issued mortgages are not relevant in making the decision for which interest rate to lend at now.
- refurb 4y agoBanks don’t hold mortgages on their books.
- mindvirus 4y agoMore straightforward in my mind would be letting people buy their mortgages. In a world of 7% mortgages, a 2.5% mortgage would only trade at ~68% of its value assuming they're both 10 years.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoYou may want https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortgage_industry_of_Denmark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortgage_industry_of_Denmark
- aidenn0 4y agoI don't know why I never thought until this moment about buying my mortgage. That seems super advantageous over just paying it off (or buying some other debt at par, since there is zero credit risk on a loan to myself).