3 ms·
Winning here doesn’t actually mean style across all art is safe just safe in that specific instance: The case was litigated rather than being thrown out becaus
by Retric 4y ago
Winning here doesn’t actually mean style across all art is safe just safe in that specific instance:
The case was litigated rather than being thrown out because style is legally recognized as falling under copyright. “In 1993 the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit shot down that appeal, though, on the same grounds—the original suit had been neither frivolous nor brought in bad faith.”
The Supreme Court didn’t disagree, they ruled on a different matter.
- williamcotton 4y agoOk, so then back at you: That Ms. Rowling and her publisher won doesn’t mean that style is covered by copyright either. It could just mean they had a more expensive legal team. One of the key elements of copyright is this doctrine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idea%E2%80%93expression_distinction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idea%E2%80%93expression_distin... An adventure novel provides an illustration of the concept. Copyright may subsist in the work as a whole, in the particular story or characters involved, or in any artwork contained in the book, but generally not in the idea or genre of the story. Also, let’s take a step back. What do you think is a fair outcome, that once John Fogerty sold the rights to one CCR song that he is no longer able to write music? Or that he needed to learn to write and play an entirely new genre? Does the first music publisher to buy a reggae song now own the rights to every single reggae song produced after? What are you arguing for?
- Retric 4y agoI am not arguing for anything, just describing the system as it exists. > Or that he needed to learn to write and play an entirely new genre? As the court case you mentioned shows genre isn’t specific enough to be problematic. I can’t draw a clear line in the sand and say this is safe because ultimately that’s up to the courts to determine in each instance. But, it is important to understand the general areas that are risky. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharrell_Williams_v._Bridgeport_Music https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharrell_Williams_v._Bridgepor... Appellate Court Judge Jacqueline Nguyen wrote a dissenting opinion: “that the judgement allows for protection over musical style” That doesn’t mean “style” is enough to lose a copyright case, but shows such things are potentially problematic.
- williamcotton 4y agoAll it shows is that rights-holders with a large legal war chest can win specific cases. There is not a single musician or songwriter that I have met who wasn’t appalled by the Robin Thicke ruling. Luckily history didn’t repeat itself with Ed Sheeran. Here's a concise explanation of why this was a terrible ruling: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1COYitP8hI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1COYitP8hI If the entire music industry operated in such a manner it would suffocate creativity. I think what you’re really trying to do is win an argument that supports your opinions on LLMs. Generally speaking, the Robin Thicke case was an aberration. If it was the norm then the music industry would look incredibly different. As in, there wouldn’t be a music industry. We can go back and forth cherry-picking court cases or we can discuss the doctrines that courts are encouraged to follow, like the idea-expression distinction. An overwhelming number of copyright cases have been decided based on this doctrine! It is disingenuous to suggest otherwise!
- Retric 4y agoI understand your perspective, but I think you’re still missing my point. Winning a court case isn’t safe, getting the court case thrown out before it needs to be litigated is. You really don’t want to be in a position where someone with deep pockets can make a reasonable argument for infringement. The question of LLM’s is really secondary. It’s likely they could win, but that in itself is very dangerous territory.
- williamcotton 4y agoSo to be safe a songwriter should just quit music, just as Ed Sheeran said he would do if he lost his case… gotcha.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s clearly not what I said. To be a safe songwriter, don’t imitate other works. The lines are actually pretty gentle in practice as long as you avoid actively copying from other works.