2 ms·
Don't spread blatantly false statements. Here's a list of encyclopedias written by experts. (In cases where it wasn't obvious, like "Encyclopedia of Horses & Po
by dalke 15y ago
Don't spread blatantly false statements. Here's a list of encyclopedias written by experts. (In cases where it wasn't obvious, like "Encyclopedia of Horses & Ponies", I checked that the book text described that the encyclopedia was written by an expert.)
Encyclopedia of Physics (3043 pages)
Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology (912 pages)
Encyclopedia of Magnetic Resonance (6490 pages)
Encyclopedia Of Philosophy (6200 pages)
The Gale Encyclopedia of Nursing and Allied Health (6200 pages)
The Merck Index: An Encyclopedia of Chemicals, Drugs, and Biologicals (2564 pages)
Encyclopedia of Biological Chemistry (3000 pages)
Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications (139 titles in that series, at about 500 pages per title = 70,000 pages).
The Film Encyclopedia (1520 pages)
Encyclopedia of Horses & Ponies (384 pages)
The Kentucky Encyclopedia (1080 pages)
The Encyclopedia of the Swedish Flora and Fauna (100 volumes planned, and about 5,000 pages published so far)
Encyclopedia of Modern Coral Reefs (812 pages)
Encyclopedia of Geomagnetism and Paleomagnetism (718 pages)
Encyclopedia of Geomorphology (1200 pages)
The HarperCollins Encyclopedia of Catholicism (1349 pages)
Wiley Encyclopedia of Electrical and Electronics Engineering (17,616 pages)
Encyclopedia of German Literature (1136 pages)
The Encyclopedia of Romantic Literature (1772 pages)
The Encyclopedia of Christian Civilization (2790 pages)
Encyclopedia of Aerospace Engineering (5810 pages)
Encyclopedia of Quantitative Finance (2194 pages)
Encyclopedia of Analytical Chemistry (16,504 pages)
That's enough. Go to http://eu.wiley.com/WileyCDA/Section/id-WILEYEUROPE2_SEARCH_RESULT.html?query=Encyclopedia http://eu.wiley.com/WileyCDA/Section/id-WILEYEUROPE2_SEARCH_... and see the list of 436 encyclopedias written by experts as published by a single company. Now add the CRC press (another 200+ titles), Oxford University Press (95 titles), and so on.
How did you ever come to the conclusion that "experts shouldn't want to write encyclopedias"? If you still believe that, then what are all the above experts doing wrong?
- tptacek 15y agoYou're fixated on an argument I'm not really making. So, you disagree with me; you think experts should want to write encyclopedias. Great. What does that have to do with the article we're commenting on? Wikipedia does not have a policy that experts shouldn't work on the encyclopedia.
- dalke 15y agoI'm fixated on the many incorrect statements you're making, not the dialog you want to have. You do not follow my argument. It's not that "experts should want to write encyclopedias", it's that experts do write encyclopedias. This is not a disagreement in our viewpoints, it's an observation that your statement does not fit observed facts. You believe "experts should do what experts do best, and Wikipedia should do what encyclopedias do best: to wit, experts should conduct research to generate new primary sources or write books to generate new secondary sources, and Wikipedia should continue finding secondary sources to summarize." This also shows that you believe the goals of Wikipedia are aligned with that of encyclopedias in general. I've listed two dozen titles of encyclopedias written by experts and links to several hundred more. Quite obviously one of the things that experts do is write encyclopedias! This means that your philosophical view regarding encyclopedias is very different than that used a large number of other encyclopedia projects. Granted, individually each of those projects is smaller than Wikipedia, but collectively they far surpass the amount of content in Wikipedia. I cannot have the dialog with you about the article we're commenting on until you acknowledge and understand the big difference between the Wikipedia model and that of most other encyclopedia projects. Once you do that, you'll understand autarch's original observation "that wikipedia attempts to substitute policy for expertise." With that understood, it's easy to consider how an encyclopedia maintained by domain experts would not have the same deference to secondary sources (and avoidance of primary sources and new research) as described by this article.