3 ms·
I wouldn't say it's just a cult of personality though. Game directors control exactly what makes it into a game, what is made for the game, and ultimately how i
by somenameforme 4y ago
I wouldn't say it's just a cult of personality though. Game directors control exactly what makes it into a game, what is made for the game, and ultimately how it turns out. No other individual has anywhere near that level of impact, nor responsibility. You can generally see this quite clearly when those big names leave studios, of which there are countless examples.
Kojima's final game at Konami was Metal Gear Solid V. After he left, Konami shrugged and made Metal Gear Survive. Suffice to say, the non-Kojima metal gear was a flop. Itagaki is another example. He's the creator of Ninja Gaiden, and also ended up leaving Team Ninja after a dispute. His final game was Ninja Gaiden 2, their first game was Ninja Gaiden 3. And again, the reception went from positive, to flop.
And to be clear it's not like these series waxed and waned. Every single Metal Gear game with Kojima received exceptional praise. Similarly for every single Ninja Gaiden game, to a lesser degree. Then they leave, and the series collapse. Obviously far more people work on these games than just the singular name, but if most of these people were replaced with somebody of a similar skillset, the final product would be largely unchanged.
---
Reception for Metal Gear Solid V: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_Gear_Solid_V:_The_Phantom_Pain#Reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_Gear_Solid_V:_The_Phanto...
Reception for Metal Gear Survive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_Gear_Survive#Reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_Gear_Survive#Reception
Ninja Gaiden 2 Reception: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninja_Gaiden_II#Reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninja_Gaiden_II#Reception
Ninja Gaiden 3 Reception: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninja_Gaiden_3#Reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninja_Gaiden_3#Reception
- nindalf 4y agoYou appear to be calculating something like Wins Above Replacement by saying the only thing that changed between these releases is the director being replaced. But you don't know that for sure. For example, Kojima would have known the most impactful, most critical staff at Konami. When he started his own thing he might have encouraged them to move. If this had happened Konami would have had to complete the new game with a gutted team, which would explain the poor quality. Of course you can say "well if this is true it only shows that Kojima can attract the best talent to work for him" and sure, that's probably true. But then we can't claim it's all completely Kojima doing the work.
- somenameforme 4y agoSure, I think that's a perfectly reasonable point. You'll find quite a lot of name overlap on Death Stranding (Kojima's first independent game) and Metal Gear Solid 5. But rather than appeal to Kojima attracting the best talent, I'd appeal to something else. Kojima has been creating Metal Gear games for nearly 40 years. And while there's naturally going to be some overlap between iterations, it's all liminal. Go back to the original 1987 Metal Gear on the NES and you'll find 0 overlap except for Kojima. Kojima was a new hire at the time and thrust onto a completely new team on a project already in development. He dramatically shifted the direction of what was being built, and what was born was Metal Gear. And, as would become a recurring pattern for every single title he's been involved in, it was met with phenomenal reception.
- nindalf 4y agoYeah, what you're saying is quite likely. I think the truth is somewhere in between. Kojima benefits from relying on a highly skilled team that deserves more credit than they get. At the same time he probably doesn't get enough credit for attracting that talent and creating an environment they can flourish in. If that were easy then anyone would do it.