2 ms·
Electric is significantly more efficient than diesel-electric only when the diesel-electric has to do a lot of braking. (Electrics have regenerative braking, s
by anamax 18y ago
Electric is significantly more efficient than diesel-electric only when the diesel-electric has to do a lot of braking. (Electrics have regenerative braking, so stopping one train can be used to power another.) That means either lots of stops or hills; a train going down can power a train going up.
While trains spend a lot of money on fuel, it isn't a big fraction of their costs, so even free fuel can't make a huge difference in total train costs.
Moreover, electrification is very expensive. It's so expensive that electrification plan for the CalTrain corridor (San Jose to San Francisco), which is pretty much a best-case for electrification due to the frequent stops, doesn't mention cost-savings as a reason. They'll probably never recover the capital costs.
Electrification might pay for itself over the Rockies, but it's a loss throughout much of the US.
Since fuel-savings is pure profit, the freight-train companies are very motivated and constantly look at these things.