4 ms·
The best hires I've seen in my life have come through word of mouth referrals. No data, no recruiters, no leetcode, no HR screenings. Good people know other goo
by SoftTalker 4y ago
The best hires I've seen in my life have come through word of mouth referrals. No data, no recruiters, no leetcode, no HR screenings. Good people know other good people. They trust one another, they are motivated to discuss opportunities of mutual benefit.
Of course that doesn't scale when you're trying to fill in a large team quickly, but at that point you have to realize that "average" is about the best you can hope to get.
- artsytrashcan 4y agoSome of the worst hires come through word-of-mouth referrals, too. That's how you get unqualified nepotism hires. In fact, networking can be thought of as a form of nepotism or cronyism (depending on how touchy a given person is about "nepotism" being applied to the manner in which they got their position). I know I'm likely alone in viewing such hiring practices - feelings over process - as signal of an impending collapse. I think it's a sound heuristic, though, at least for previously-established companies. If you're not connected to eminently-qualified potential hires (and you're probably overestimating the quality of your network), "hire my friends" is a sure way to end up with an increasingly incompetent workforce.
- alfalfasprout 4y agoI've gone back and forth on this and now am firmly in the feelings > process camp if you have competent folks making the hiring decisions and you train everyone well in avoiding unconscious bias. The reality is that strong soft-skills are crucial to hiring the best talent and those skills cannot be "objectively" tested. Even software engineering to a large degree requires a lot of design-related traits that require subjectivity in assessment.
- mrkurt 4y agoYou can test soft skills. Evaluations don't need to be objective, they just need to be consistent.
- cwalv 4y agoDoesn't 'subjective' imply 'inconsistent' unless you have one subject doing all the evaluations?
- hughesjj 4y agoIn that case, wouldn't that select for generally likable people? Idk sounds like evolution to me. Of course, though, that's going to encode some existing biases in the data, but we could keep adding them to protected classes if society thinks they're worthy of inclusion. That last part is pretty flawed today and changes slowly, I admit, but overall this system sure as heck solves more problems than I could come up with. At least, I think it converges over time.
- blitzar 4y agoAn often overlooked job requirement is that you have to sit next to this person for 8 hours a day 5 days a week. There are no leetcode tests for that.
- mikrl 4y agoSpeaking of nepotism: on LinkedIn via my network, I saw a senior manager in a Bay Area company asking publicly for internships for his university age daughter. I shook my head in amazement, then felt absolutely mortified on behalf of that poor woman. At best, she is living in her father’s shadow. At worst, she is being denied valuable life lessons of the feeling of being allowed to fail and get back up.
- beckingz 4y agoThat's how networks work. Ask and you might receive.
- throw9away6 4y agoNah that’s what you do to get your kid in the door. It works and it helps.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoPersonally I’d be fine with someone doing this for me. It was hard and scary to land my first job out of school
- godelski 4y agoHonest question, how is this meaningfully different from a recruiter? Sounds like a recruiter with intimate knowledge of the candidate and a strong network. A biased recruiter, but aren't all? I mean a recruiter doesn't get paid unless they get someone a job (and they get more money for a hire paying).
- hef19898 4y agoI am a big fan of both, word-of-mouthbreferalls and sttict hirijg processes, read Amazon (without leetcode, I am no dev). If youbsomeone good, get them the first invite for the phone screening or even an on-site interview. But then recuse yourself from the hiring process, don't interview, don't participate in the decision making. That way, you are not the only one influencing the hiring, ypu just made it easier for someone to get the first foot in the door. Of course this isn't perfect, people might be biased to please higher ups or collegues by prefering those referral candidates. Or you might end up indirectly influencing thebhiring decision, intentionally or not. But still better than some AI based CV screening or pure nepotism.
- laratied 4y agoThe hiring process is basically a stochastic process with time wasting theatrical performances on both sides. I honestly believe at some stage there should just be a random number generator making the selection. Especially if the final selection is between a couple of highly qualified candidates.
- godelski 4y ago> The best hires I've seen in my life have come through word of mouth referrals. No data, no recruiters, no leetcode, no HR screenings. Nepotism. It gets a lot of bad rap but the reason this is effective is because you're essentially comparing hiring via a piece of paper vs via intimate knowledge of a candidate's actual knowledge and work habits. The latter clearly has more information than you could get from any screening process. Of course this doesn't mean you should just hire someone because they're a relative or friend because that's not actually using the information gain. But we should recognize why the process is successful. If we want to make a fair system that doesn't rely on nepotism then we have to also recognize why it works in the first place. I don't see these complicated hiring processes doing this. Of course, you can also just use a noisy process. But if you're going to use a noisy process maybe don't make it so expensive (for company and candidate; money and time). If this is the method, then the process should be about minimizing the complexity and costs of hiring.