5 ms·
A degree from a university that has gotten rid of grades will not be worth much compared to one that hasn't. > If a student already knew the material before ta
by kazinator 4y ago
A degree from a university that has gotten rid of grades will not be worth much compared to one that hasn't.
> If a student already knew the material before taking the class and got that A, "they didn't learn anything," said Greene. And "if the student came in and struggled to get a C-plus, they may have learned a lot."
Sorry, Jody Greene, you're out to lunch here. The grade is assigned by the lecturer of a course, as a confirmation that the student knows a thing or two about certain fixed topics. If the student learned about those topics somewhere else before taking the course, they earned that A just as much as someone who learned it in the course.
It is extremely important to intellectual freedom that the time and place where some knowledge or skills were attained is considered immaterial. The idea of someone not getting accreditation in a course because they already knew the material beforehand and so didn't learn anything is completely wrongheaded and abhorrent. I dare say, an attack on Western civilization's intellectual legacy.
> And so if we were to shift our focus on to learning and away from grades, we would be able to tell whether we were graduating people with the skills that we say we're graduating them with."
To "tell whether you are graduating people with skills", you need a test of those skills. That's a grade.
A skill test could actually be a lot harder than earning grades in some disciplines.
For instance, if we expect that computer science graduates ought to be skilled software developers and start testing that, it will be a shitshow.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zamnos 4y agoDepends if that university is MIT or Harvard, or somewhere else. But also, you know what they call the dude who got C's at medical school? Doctor.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wanttocomment 4y agoI would guess 80% of the career value is captured by satisfying admissions and graduating. I think the actual grading isn't looked at except to rank similar peers for admission to other competitive programs.
- fallingknife 4y agoThis is exactly why companies should drop degree requirements. If 80% of the degree requirements are met when you graduate from HS (and I would say it's more than 80%), then why make them wait 4 years and take on a pile of debt?
- bumby 4y agoOP didn’t specifically saying graduating high school. I read the post as graduating college was part of that 80%
- Mezzie 4y ago> If a student already knew the material before taking the class and got that A, "they didn't learn anything," said Greene Also, the fuck they didn't. They learned patience (have to listen to/discuss other people's questions even if they're stupid to you) and the ability to do tasks that are boring/tedious/something you've already done before - 2 qualities that are excellent to have when working. If you're used to picking things up quickly, learning to handle boring and tedious environments is probably the best skill you could take out of your schooling. How many meetings have we all sat in where we just have to sit there until somebody important reaches the conclusion we reached in 10 minutes?
- mordae 4y agoNot working. Being employed. There is a difference.
- Mezzie 4y agoGood clarification, thanks!
- sieongioetnio 4y agoThat could be learned working the checkout line at a grocery store. I think universities can aim a little higher.
- Mezzie 4y agoThe average kid who is that bright or in that situation is not being asked to work a check-out line. We recognize that it isn't an efficient use of their talent. That kid is doing side projects or taking internships. They have to pick up some patience somewhere.
- fallingknife 4y agoWas already worthless when they dropped standardized test requirements for admission.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoIn western countries, the basis of understanding and discourse is transitioning from reason to feelings.
- dalbasal 4y ago>The grade is assigned by the lecturer of a course, as a confirmation that the student knows a thing or two about certain fixed topics. That's an idea of what grades are and what they're for. It's not the idea. I would call this an ideal, often fallen short of, and often misguided. In practice, grades are used in all sorts of ways for all sort of reasons. Many times, they are used for no good reason. The idea that tests are impartial accreditation is abstract. It rarely plays in reality. There's a place for GMEDs, bar exams, TOEFLS and whatnot... but it's limited. >It is extremely important to intellectual freedom that the time and place where some knowledge or skills were attained is considered immaterial. > The idea of someone not getting accreditation in a course because they already knew the material beforehand and so didn't learn anything is completely wrongheaded and abhorrent It's abhorrent only within the accreditation framework of ideals. This just isn't reality. That objectivity ideal for education is always betrayed because it doesn't work. People don't value exam results, in their own right, because they're not that valuable in their own right. A course's job irl is to educate, not accredit.
- bumby 4y ago>A course's job irl is to educate, not accredit But a course is part of a larger system which is built on accreditation. Universities no longer have a monopoly on information/education so accreditation is really the main value they hold. Erode that and there’s not much vocational reason to go to college (we could argue about the role of higher education, but it’s been more vocationally focused than civically focused going back to the Morrill act in the mid 1800s)
- dalbasal 4y ago>Universities no longer have a monopoly on information/education so accreditation is really the main value they hold. Erode that and there’s not much vocational reason to go to college. Again, I think this is idealistic thinking... and doesn't have much to do with universities irl. Whether or not an MIT degree is an accreditation, it is not an objective, grades based accreditation. It never was. There has never been a world where your bar exam results matter, and no one cares about where you went to law school. An MIT degree does not mean "passed the MIT exams." Universities never really had monopoly over knowledge. Every university teaches the same accounting courses. They're also online. There is even a well respected 3rd party accreditation. People still care about where they, their employees or their accountants were educated. We can debate why this is the case. We can't ignore that it is the case. The university matters, almost always, to the people involved... Accreditation matters sometimes, but usually only as a minimum bar. Neither education nor accreditation guarantee ability.
- prepend 4y agoThis seems funny to me as well as the point of learning isn’t the actual learning, it’s the knowledge gained. That’s why we learn. Yes the journey is valuable but the purpose of classes isn’t to measure learningness as a process, but to measure the knowledge and skills gained. If someone already knew material and learned nothing and got an A, it means they have knowledge of that topic and now there’s a little more signal of that knowledge. It doesn’t matter that they went from 90% knowledge to 95%. If someone got a C+ and went from 0-78% knowledge they learned much but still can’t demonstrate much knowledge. If we wanted a course on learning processes specifically, then create one. But thinking that the point of grades is measuring how much was learned seems so backwards. It’s good to recognize effort, but the point of effort is to achieve an outcome, not the outcome itself. “Prepend is so great, ve works so hard. Totally sucks and is stupid but works so hard.” Is silly if used for ability to do a particular thing, but useful in measuring grit and discipline or whatever.
- sidewndr46 4y agoGreene's take on education is very odd. Should I be considered not to have a CS degree because I did not need to learn anything to pass the classes? I would often leave myself a gap of 1 hour between project deadlines and when I would start on them, because I knew I needed 30 minutes to 45 minutes to complete them. I'd spend the remaining 15 minutes before class correcting the errors in the assignment and submitting those to the instructor as proposed revisions. I had a high school professor that just gave us the university's Chemistry introduction series (200 level, if that matters) as our high school curriculum. I didn't learn much in those classes at university, mostly because I had already completed the work.
- sieongioetnio 4y ago> A degree from a university that has gotten rid of grades will not be worth much compared to one that hasn't. You may be surprised to learn that quite a few well-regarded universities adopted this sort of policy years ago. In particular, grading freshmen pass/fail is not uncommon. >The idea of someone not getting accreditation in a course because they already knew the material beforehand and so didn't learn anything is completely wrongheaded and abhorrent. Whoa, Nelly! No one is talking about refusing degrees to students who read too much. I don't know where you got that idea. It definitely wasn't from Jody Greene. Right now, attending university is both an education and a credential. These two goals are in tension, and both are compromised as a result. Students should be able to pursue an education without fear that trying something challenging will permanently affect their career. Employers looking for proof of knowledge shouldn't care where or how that knowledge was learned. >To "tell whether you are graduating people with skills", you need a test of those skills. Right. >That's a grade. Wrong. Traditional letter grades are one way of measuring mastery, but the interviewees in this article describe a few alternatives. Sadly they don't describe these alternatives in detail. I wish this article were a bit more nuts-and-bolts. It leaves more questions than it answers.