5 ms·
There are three issues here: primary sources, secondary sources, and original research. You said "An encyclopedia is a survey of existing secondary sources". It
by dalke 15y ago
There are three issues here: primary sources, secondary sources, and original research. You said "An encyclopedia is a survey of existing secondary sources". It is not. An encyclopedia also contains references to primary sources, and can also contain new research.
A reference to a primary source would be, for example, a reference to Newton's "Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica" or to Darwin's "On the Origin of Species". An article on the history of evolutionary thought would be remiss if it does not include Darwin's book and instead only referred to books discussing Darwin's work. Like the children's game "telephone", only relying on secondary (and then tertiary, then quaternary) sources can amplify noise.
You then asked about "examples of original research published in the Encyclopedia of Physics". There are two different types of research involved here. One is "original to the field of physics". Physics has a well-established mechanism for publishing and disseminating work, and that is not an encyclopedia.
The other is the research needed to reconcile and synthesize multiple viewpoints into a well-constructed whole. A non-fiction piece for the New Yorker likely entails new research (even an interview is new research), and that's the type of research which goes well with an encyclopedia. Take a look at Wikipedia's entry for "History of the Encyclopædia Britannica" with comments like "40,000-word hagiographic biography of George Washington" and "Dr. Thomas Thomson, who introduced the first usage of chemical symbols in the 1801 supplement". Thomas Young translated the Rosetta Stone and in his WP page is written "[s]ome of Young's conclusions appeared in the famous article "Egypt" he wrote for the 1818 edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica."
Or take Asimov's Biographical Encyclopedia of Science and Technology. The entire encyclopedia was written by Asimov, who commented "I alone have done every bit of the necessary research and writing; and without any assistance whatever, not even that of a typist." Right there in the text it says "research."
Do you think these examples of the research which goes into encyclopedia articles aren't actual research? If not, why not? Or are these simply not encyclopedias?
As to "if Britannica is paying"... do you think Harry Houdini, Albert Einstein, Marie Curie, Sigmund Freud, Henry Ford, Leon Trotsky, Arthur Eddington, Lord Kelvin, Humphry Davy, John Stuart Mill, Thomas Malthus, and yes, even Isaac Newton, were contributors to EB mostly because they were being paid for their work? Most certainly not! (How much would Ford's time cost?) From what I've read, other factors were because they wanted to contribute to a collection of knowledge, and because of the prestige.
- tptacek 15y agoI think you're providing a lot of examples of things that Wikipedia is also largely fine with. Meanwhile, the author of this article did original research, generating knowledge that was not only new to the field but that actually contradicted the field's best known sources. Wikipedia (justifiably, but not particularly gracefully) told him "go write a journal article and then come back and cite it". Which is what he did. This makes sense for a variety of reasons, some of them having to do with the charter of an encyclopedia, others simply as a matter of pragmatism: 9 times out of 10, when someone contributes original research to Wikipedia, their work is crazy.
- dalke 15y agoWikipedia must be fine with it because many of the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica articles (which had entered the public domain) were imported into Wikipedia pages. My point though was nothing to do with Wikipedia's policies. It was to your incorrect definition of what it means to be an encyclopedia. You've said: - "Wikipedia is an encyclopedia. It's a terrible place for original research." I showed several examples of original research done for encyclopedias. One was the first use of the element symbols now used in every chemistry book. - "everyone's understanding of what an encyclopedia (ANY encyclopedia) is" ... "is not a place of first publication for new research findings." In addition to the previous comment, this view falsely separates the scholarly research which goes into producing an encyclopedia from the scholarly research of any other field. - "Wikipedia should do what encyclopedias do best: to wit, experts should conduct research to generate new primary sources or write books to generate new secondary sources." I gave a long list of encyclopedia articles across several encyclopedias written by acknowledged experts on the specific topic. Traditional encyclopedias often ask experts to do this. Wikipedia is in the small minority. - "An encyclopedia is a survey of existing secondary sources". I gave many examples where encyclopedias references the primary sources, and pointed to encyclopedia articles which are not a survey of existing sources. - "[Experts] shouldn't address the public by writing encyclopedia articles". Excepting that experts do address the public by writing encyclopedia article, and have been for centuries. - "Encyclopedia articles are the worst way for them to address the public." Excepting as Wikipedia shows, encyclopedias are often one of the first places people turn to for information, so it's a very good way to address the public. - "Experts shouldn't want to write encyclopedias." Except that some encyclopedias are written by experts. Do you think the "Encyclopedia of Magnetic Resonance" was written by non-experts? (Hint: "The existence of this large number of articles, written by experts in various fields, is enabling the publication of a series of EMR Handbooks on specific areas of NMR and MRI.") Your statements are definitely contra-factual to how other encyclopedias work, as you make statements for which counter-examples are easily found. Your understanding of the goals and purpose of an encyclopedia seem based solely on your understanding of the goals, purpose, and operation of Wikipedia. Do you have any evidence to back your claims? Otherwise I must conclude that you don't know what you are talking about.