13 ms·
CO2 Heat Pumps Found to Offer High Efficiency at Low Ambient Temperature
- deofoo 4y ago[flagged]
- jnsaff2 4y agoCO2 heat pumps are an interesting trade-off. I think Sanyo used to make them and they work well but never get the best SCOP values, tho I don't think they are far off. Their major benefit obviously is that the refrigerant has a GWP of 1. Instead of several thousand for the mainstream gases. So say an air-to-air home heat pump with about a kg of refrigerant could release couple of tons of CO2e in case of a leak or an unknowing/caring worker cutting the pipes without properly collecting the gases during the dismantling. This could easily negate the lifetime atmospheric CO2 savings of that heat pump. Whereas in case of a heat pump using CO2 it would be a non-issue.
- pstuart 4y agoNow to get the price down so it crowds the dangerous stuff out ;-)
- samtho 4y agoIt’s not really about price, you can get refrigerant grade CO2 for about $2/lb while other common refrigerants can range from $4-$14/lb. The problem is making sure equipment is certified to handle r744 because it does have a different thermo profile, expansion ratios, and critical point. As you can imagine, manufacturers of more expensive refrigerants are probably not super eager to push a cheaper, easy to capture or manufacture alternative that is effectively not patent-enforceable.
- jnsaff2 4y agoCO2 is acidic so could there be any engineering problems working with CO2?
- jabl 4y agoAFAIU the main challenges is that the thermophysical properties of CO2 are different than for the usual fluorocarbon refrigerants, so it needs a different design taking that into account (among others, needs to handle much higher pressures). The advantage of the fluorocarbon refrigerants is that the current automotive one, R1234yf, is mostly a drop-in replacement of the previous R134a, which in turn was mostly a drop-in replacement for the freon refrigerants (R12) that were banned due to destruction of the ozone layer. So going down this path manufacturers can basically slightly tweak their original designs, potentially originally dating back to the beginnings of the automotive AC era. So saves on R&D costs. The downside is of course that these fluorocarbon refrigerants are very expensive compared to CO2, and the ever tightening F-gas regulations around the world meaning there seems to be a never-ending rat race where a fluorocarbon refrigerant gets banned, necessitating the development of a replacement which is more expensive, and then in turn gets banned in a decade or so. Rinse and repeat.
- citrin_ru 4y agoSufficiently dry CO2 cannot be acidic, only with water we are getting an acid (as far as I remember school chemistry)
- throwawaymaths 4y agoIt's still generally a lewis acid (depends on the reaction ofc) but it's effectively unreactive.
- usrusr 4y agoThe price for the medium in the loop isn't much of a factor in the total cost of a heat pump system.
- samtho 4y agoThe manufacturer of the heat pump system is rarely the maker of the refrigerant but they maintain a close relationship with them. That relationship would be harder to maintain if they suddenly decided to use a very common substance rather than the Dow, Carrier, or Honeywell r410a. It’s likely these companies would be happy to sell r744, but the margins are not going to be as good.
- stephen_g 4y agoThat's not exactly how I understand it - my understanding is that they are generally very good in terms of COP but the trade-off is that they operate at much higher pressures than other refrigerants (including the ones we're phasing out), so material properties, servicing, etc. are more challenging. (of course, it's more complicated than that because COP changes depends on input and output temperature, both in absolute and relative terms, and different refrigerants can be better for colder inputs or hotter outputs etc., but I am talking in general).
- stephen_g 4y agoGood to see heat pump tech being pushed forward in all sorts of applications. I didn't even think about using CO₂ in car applications. I have a CO₂ heat pump hot water system (integrated by this Australian mob - https://reclaimenergy.com.au/ https://reclaimenergy.com.au/ - but I think the heat pump unit is an OEM Japanese one) and it uses a ridiculously small amount of energy compared to my old conventional electric system (somewhere between 1.2 and 2kWh typically vs 4 to over 6kWh per day - and the new system also has a tank 2.5 times bigger than the small one I had before, which is so much better, and I probably use some more hot water than I did previously since it’s available). I have solar and it’s timed so it basically always is entirely, or almost entirely powered from that, so it’s gone from using more power from the grid than the rest of my usage combined, to now using almost no power from the grid. Yes, it was a bit pricy but should only take a few years to pay back.
- hbarka 4y agoThis is from Sanden, the manufacturer of CO2 heat pump water heaters. They are known for the SANCO2. https://www.smallplanetsupply.com/sanc02 https://www.smallplanetsupply.com/sanc02
- stephen_g 4y agoAh, interesting, apparently it is manufactured by Sanden, yes. I thought they were different because you can also buy Sanden branded heat pumps here in Australia too, and I assumed that since Reclaim also sell commercial ones made by Mitsubishi Heavy Industries I though the domestic one might be Mitsubishi too.
- zeristor 4y agoYou’d think that if you highlighted 150°F iPad Safari could translate it to Celsius, or allow lookup to do the conversion.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y ago65 degrees Celsius. For context, 54 degrees for 30 seconds will cause full-thickness skin burn.
- samtho 4y agoFor those not familiar, r744 is a type of refrigerant, similar to r134a and r404a. In any refrigeration system (A/C units, refrigerators, freezers, heat pumps), a type of refrigerant is required to move heat out of the target location (but heat pumps can reverse direction to move it into a living space to provide heating). Note that this is a closed system and had nothing to do with sequestering CO2 or anything, it just uses the specific properties of the gas to move heat. If I recall correctly, this refrigerant has been used in the industrial space for many years already for related cooling applications but is now being marketed as a something that EVs can utilize for cooling battery systems because it’s thermo profile allows it to be used very efficiently in this particular use-case. The other thing I want to point out is that the linked article is coming from a website who’s domain is r744.com so they may have some vested interest in publishing this research. That is to say, I don’t believe this to be fluff or misleading specifically, just something to keep in mind.
- benj111 4y ago>Note that this is a closed system and had nothing to do with sequestering CO2 or anything Surely the fact it is a closed loop does mean it is sequestering co2. In fact I'd go further and suggest that the best way of sequestering co2 is in ways where the sequestration is purely incidental, because then there's an economic imperative to do it.
- Centigonal 4y agoEach CO2 heat pump has at most a few kg CO2 inside. US per capita annual CO2 emissions is ~14 metric tons.
- benj111 4y agoThat doesn't invalidate the principle. A heat pump locks away a few kg of co2. While (more importantly) lowering the other side of the equation. I'm not advocating it as a one stop solution to climate change, just that it does in fact sequester a few kg of co2.
- doctor_eval 4y agoWait - a highly efficient heat pump technology for EVs using the exact same gas EVs were created to avoid? And they say God doesn't have a sense of humour!
- jamiek88 4y agoYes, it’s using co2 not creating it.
- jabl 4y agoIn a personal car sized vehicle it's probably less than 1 kg, circulating in a closed system. The only time it will enter the atmosphere is in case of a leak, or when doing some service on the AC unit where the refrigerant parts need to be opened. I would guess that as opposed to the fluorocarbon refrigerants there is no need to capture the gas, as there's already plenty of CO2 in the atmosphere? Might need to ensure proper ventilation though, 1 kg of CO2 in an enclosed garage might increase the CO2 level uncomfortably high..
- jaggederest 4y agoThrough the magic of dimensional analysis we can see that 1kg of CO2 is approximately 22.7 moles. Coincidentally, 1 mole of gas at STP is 22.7 liters. So 515 liters of CO2, which is a fair volume - half a cubic meter. Not enough to raise the CO2 level of a garage dangerously (assuming a standard garage is 4m by 7m by 3m) but a substantial jump - 1% or so, so you'd notice it. The other nice thing is that it's rare to have people suffocate due to high CO2 levels - it quickly becomes uncomfortable and people move to fresh air, unlike e.g. pure nitrogen, because the body is adapted to detect and alleviate high CO2 levels as a proxy for low O2 levels.
- tehbeard 4y agoSo a leak overnight in the garage would be ok... what about when using the car with the leak entering the passenger area?
- irjustin 4y agoLooking at the tradeoffs of CO2, r744, I don't see it gaining adoption. Quick search shows 10x pressure vs r134a. That pressure difference is significant on size, weight, maintenance of parts. Also at non-low ambient temps it's apparently less efficient so the useful range is quite limited.
- benj111 4y ago>Also at non-low ambient temps it's apparently less efficient so the useful range is quite limited. Surely it depends on efficiency curves, and local climate. If it's marginally less efficient above 0c and much more efficient below then it would still be a win in many climates. Further, the very coldest days tend to be less windy, and also tend to be the days when you want most heat so if your generation backbone is based on wind, co2 would still be the best choice, if only to minimise demand at the worst possible points.
- irjustin 4y ago> Surely it depends on efficiency curves, and local climate. Yeah and i'm still trying to understand the enthalpy curve of the two systems but at the same given temp it's way further along the X-axis for 33'C[0][1]. 33'C is a pretty common for a huge chunk of the earth. If it was way cheaper to implement then of course cold locations would work really hard to adopt it. but with 10x pressures, there's no way, right? [0] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ese3.976 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ese3.976 [1] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/cms/asset/cf698e11-dfed-489c-b818-b3d1925132e4/ese3976-fig-0004-m.jpg https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/cms/asset/cf698e11-dfed-489c...
- dzhiurgis 4y agoDoes it take away cooling efficiency?
- nforgerit 4y ago[flagged]
- gigatexal 4y agoFor anyone who read the article completely lost like I was: https://clade-es.com/heat-pumps/about-co2-heat-pumps/ https://clade-es.com/heat-pumps/about-co2-heat-pumps/ “ A CO2 heat pump uses carbon dioxide as a refrigerant. Carbon dioxide is a naturally occurring gas, and it has a very low boiling point. This makes it ideal for use in a heat pump. When the carbon dioxide is compressed, it becomes a liquid. This liquid then evaporates, and as it does so, it absorbs heat from the surrounding air.”
- voisin 4y agoAnyone know how this compares to the Rheem Proterra heat pump water heaters?