6 ms·
You're not wrong, except in so far as that's parochial. A government-controlled… never mind artificial god, a government-controlled story teller can be devasta
by ben_w 4y ago
You're not wrong, except in so far as that's parochial.
A government-controlled… never mind artificial god, a government-controlled story teller can be devastating.
I don't buy Musk's claim ChatGPT is "woke" (or even that the term is coherent enough to be tested), but I can say that each government requiring AI to locally adhere to national mythology, will create self-reinforcing cognitive blind spots, because that already happens at the current smaller scale of manual creation and creators being told not to "talk the country down".
But, unless someone has a technique for structuring an AI such that it can't be evil even when you, for example, are literally specifically trying to train it to support the police no matter how authoritarian the laws are, then a fully open source AGI is almost immediately also a perfectly obedient sociopath of $insert_iq_claim_here.
I don't want to wake up to the news that some doomsday cult has used one to design/make a weapon, nor the news a large religious group target personalised propaganda against me and mine.
Fully open does that by default.
But, you're still right, if we don't grok the AI, the governments can each secretly manipulate the AI and bend it to government goals in opposition to the people.
- AlexandrB 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- junofan 4y agoIt refers to a pretty specific set of views on race and gender.
- f-securus 4y agoCare to elaborate? I’ve read about 5 different explanations for ‘woke’ the last couple of months.
- junofan 4y agoYep, here’s a good overview: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woke https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woke It’s been around a long time.
- jeremyjh 4y agoThere is more than one usage described in that article. This is the relevant one in this particular thread: > Among American conservatives, woke has come to be used primarily as an insult.[4][29][42] Members of the Republican Party have been increasingly using the term to criticize members of the Democratic Party,
- miles 4y agoCNN's YT channel has this clip of Bill Maher taking a stab at it: How Bill Maher defines 'woke' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzwC-10O0cw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzwC-10O0cw
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stuckkeys 4y agoBill has has flaws, but he is right.
- mindslight 4y agoIs this a definition that people who identify as "woke" would use? If not, then it seems like just another straw man and set up for talking past one another.
- air7 4y agoYou can derail any discussion by asking for definitions. Human languages is magical in the sense that we can't rigorously define anything (try "Love", "Excitement", "Emancipation" or anything else, really) yet we still seem to be able to have meaningful discussions. So just because we can't define it, doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smolder 4y agoNope. It refers to what ever people want it to refer to, because it's a label used by detractors, not a cohesive thing.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThis is one definition, OP has an other that many millions ascribe to. Numbers make right in the definition game.
- smolder 4y agoMillions or not, it's pretty contentious. That said, I'm probably wasting my time fighting the tide, as with complaining about misuse of the word "literally".
- behnamoh 4y agoI mean, I've never seen any liberal calling conservatives "woke".
- smolder 4y agoNo, of course not. It's a certain demographic who have latched onto the word "woke" as Elon used it: first as a label for ridiculous radical-left ideas, and then for anything they associate with the left that they don't like.
- jlawson 4y agoWoke is a specific ideology that it places every individual into a strict hierarchy of oppressor/oppressed according to group racial and sexual identity. It rose to prominence in American culture from around 2012, starting in universities. It revolves around a set of core concepts including privilege, marginalization, oppression, and equity. Now that we've defined what woke is, I hope we can move on from this 'you can't define woke' canard I keep seeing. Woke is no more difficult to define than any religion or ideology, except in that it deliberately pretends not to exist ("just basic decency", "just basic human rights") in order to be a more slippery target. -- *Side note to ward off the deliberate ignorance of people who are trying to find a way to misunderstand - I've attached some notes on how words work: 1- Often, things in the world we want to talk about have many characteristics and variants. 2- Words usually have fuzzy boundaries in what they refer to. 3- Despite the above, we can and do productively refer to such things using words. 4- We can define a thing by mentioning its most prominent feature(s). -- The above does NOT mean that the definition must encapsulate ALL features of the thing to be valid. -- The above does NOT mean that a thing with features outside the definition is not what the word refers to. 5- Attempting to shut down discussion by deliberately misunderstanding words or how they work is a sign of an inability to make productive valid points about reality.
- smolder 4y agoThis is a recently imagined, ret-conned definition of what it is, complete with bias, to serve the purposes of the right wing. The definition, if there is to be one, should include that it isn't consistent across time or across political/cultural boundaries. I recommend people don't use the term with any seriousness, and I often ignore people who do. Address the specific ideas you associate with it instead, if you want to have a meaningful discussion.
- smolder 4y ago> Attempting to shut down discussion by deliberately misunderstanding words or how they work is a sign of an inability to make productive valid points about reality. Lumping a bunch of things together under a vague term to make it easier to vaguely complain about them is a sign of an inability to make productive valid points about reality.
- robwwilliams 4y ago> I can say that each government requiring AI to locally adhere to national mythology, will create self-reinforcing cognitive blind spots, because that already happens at the current smaller scale of manual creation and creators being told not to "talk the country down". This is a key point. Every culture and agency and state will want (deserve) their own homespun AGI. But can we all learn how to accommodate to or accept a cultural multiverse when money and resources are zero-sum in many dimensions. Hanno Rajaniemi’s Quantum Thief trilogy gives you a foretaste of where we could end up.
- selimthegrim 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35872321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35872321
- ben_w 4y agoI'd forgotten that headline (and still haven't read the content), but yes, that's one example of how it can go wrong.