6 ms·
US Secret Service: “blockchain is an opportunity to track money”
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoAnd people didn't believe me when I was saying Bitcoin is a CIA/NSA/FED joint project, the goal was and is still pretty clear at this point
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> CIA/NSA/FED joint project These guys variously compete for turf and are irrelevant to each other.
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoYet they share a common goal An example: https://qz.com/1145669/googles-true-origin-partly-lies-in-cia-and-nsa-research-grants-for-mass-surveillance https://qz.com/1145669/googles-true-origin-partly-lies-in-ci... An other one: https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/how-the-nsa-spies-on-international-bank-transactions-a-922430.html https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/how-the-nsa-spies...
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoNeither mentions the Fed. (The Fed doesn’t really do AML/ATF. Its business is in aggregates.) I’m not discarding the NSA/CIA hypothesis. Just the monetary component. Fed officials don’t need clearance and can whistleblow in a way the IC cannot.
- paulpauper 4y agoSorta misleading. They can recover crypto only if they are somehow able to crack an encrypted file, coerce an exchange, or coerce the perp into giving up the keys.
- jjgreen 4y agoFive minutes with a claw-hammer should suffice for the latter.
- kingsloi 4y agorelevant-xkcd-comic.jpg https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- baq 4y agoThey’re pretty good at the second part I assume, the practice is as old as humanity itself
- anotheronebytes 4y ago> They’re pretty good at the second part I assume, the practice is as old as humanity itself wrong. it's as old as civilization itself, yes. But humanity is not exactly the same as civilization edit: so the numbers (of votes) say that I'm wrong, so humanity is the same as its civilization? wtf.
- TonyTrapp 4y agoOr maybe people just see the comment as needlessly pedantic, adding nothing of value to the conversation.
- CommitSyn 4y agoAre you a bot, or did we just happen to say almost exactly the same thing within seconds of each other?
- TonyTrapp 4y agoGiven that your comment ID is two higher than mine, you must be the bot, or I am a bot that can predict the future ;) But yes, I was also amused by the almost-identical phrasing.
- kmoser 4y ago> The agency claims it can recover stolen crypto and advises using cash for privacy. Just don't use too much cash, lest you run afoul of banking regulations or become a victim of civil asset forfeiture. Also interesting that a federal agency would be on board with anonymous monetary transactions.
- poidos 4y agoNotice they don’t mention anonymity, just “privacy”. I’m kind of tempted to read it as privacy from third parties but not privacy from the government.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoThat's not a direct quote from an FBI spokesperson and instead just part of the subtitle of this article. I personally wouldn't read that it's "private, and not necessarily anonymous" as it seems likely that the author didn't distinguish so strongly between these things. To the point of anonymous cash transactions, I strongly suspect there are ways to acquire cash in a way that the bills which are used in a given transaction aren't necessarily traceable to the individual who made the transaction. I've heard mention of such tactics but never tried to put them into practice because I don't care enough (in most cases) to make it more than theory.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> don't use too much cash, lest you run afoul of banking regulations or become a victim of civil asset forfeiture Don’t hold too much cash. That single-handedly neuters the latter. Unless you’re spending $10 to 100k a month, banking regulations won’t give you an issue. (Below, you’re innocuous. Above, you’re big enough to find a bank that gives a fuck.)
- mikece 4y agoThere's a TED talk out there where an FBI digital crimes investigator refers to the Bitcoin Blockchain as "prosecution futures" -- they might not know who is behind a specific BTC address today but they have identified the people behind most of the transactions they track over time.
- nohaydeprobleme 4y agoI couldn't find a TED talk from my quick search, but for reference, there is a transcript of a talk at Amherst College [1] that mentions the concept: Alex Tapscott (at the talk as an Amherst College alumnus, known for being the CEO of a cryptocurrency company and writing a popular book published in 2016 about cryptocurrency): "The FBI started calling Bitcoin prosecution futures, because whenever someone spends it, down the road with enough information they can actually trace it back to who the original spender was, and they were able to reclaim a whole bunch of lost coin." I searched a bit more to see if an FBI agent or attorney used the term on-the-record, but it looks like the closest source is a New York Times article that quoted lawyers without naming a name [2]: "Hence Bitcoin’s wry new nickname in legal circles: “Prosecution Futures.” [1] https://www.amherst.edu/alumni/learn/amherstreads/pastfeatures/2016-features/october-2016/interview/transcript https://www.amherst.edu/alumni/learn/amherstreads/pastfeatur... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/19/business/eagle-scout-idealist-drug-trafficker.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/19/business/eagle-scout-idea... ; The MIT Technology Review cited this article with their report that prosecutors have begun to use the term "prosecution futures": https://www.technologyreview.com/2014/02/18/173936/marginally-useful/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2014/02/18/173936/marginall...
- jbverschoor 4y agoNo kidding
- Random_BSD_Geek 4y agoMy pet theory is that Bitcoin was created by a Five Eyes intelligence service.
- datan3rd 4y agoAgreed, seems like a very elegant method to create your own black budget.
- wudangmonk 4y agoand this is exactly why its not. I think we can all agree that the hollywood idea of competent people behind the scenes in positions of power has been proven wrong again and again. Any 4d chess move is the accidental consequence of a move so dumb that it becomes unimaginable to us.
- alfalfasprout 4y agowe certainly do not agree on this.
- lithos 4y agoThere have been similar schemes, like those privacy phones that were directly ran by the government.
- Razengan 4y agoExactly what a competent person behind the scenes would say.
- tehjoker 4y agoDef seems like it's involved in whatever is the next evolution of BCCI. Can read more about it in this book. I'm not sure where to find the definitive account. https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/american-exception-empire-and-the-deep-state_aaron-good/28967741/?resultid=9f7cf941-084e-4aea-ba7a-447da3563855#edition=60114948&idiq=47343621 https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/american-exception-empire-and-...
- ridgered4 4y agoMaybe I'm missing something but since bitcoin is a public ledger and exchanges all have KYC features it seems worse than buying visa gift cards with cash from a privacy perspective. I don't know that much about the crypto space honestly, but it didn't seem to make sense to me it was the go-to currency for criminal transactions.
- bombcar 4y agoBitcoin's advantage is worked online for people who are banned from normal online payment mechanisms. There are other privacy oriented coins that may do better than bitcoin for avoiding tracing (monero?) but the main reason criminals used it is it worked and nobody really cared about drugs, etc.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoYou can use mixers and the like to obfuscate the address that hits the exchanges from the address that is used for crime. When properly executed the strategy is foolproof unless the mixer you use is a honeypot. The issue is that there's a goodchance all the mixers are honeypots and properly executing the strategy requires an amount of vigilance that is beyond most organized crime groups.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> can use mixers This is automatic acceleration of probable cause. If you’re a state-level actor, mixers are fine. (You have a state behind you.) If you’re just having fun, go for it—it’s neat conceptually. For anyone less, take a lesson from the cartels.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoThere's no way to prove you were the one to use the mixer vs just buying the coins from someone else who did.
- hgsgm 4y agoLink to the actual AMA?
- 0x445442 4y ago"Blockchain is an opportunity to track money" Cool, let's start by putting all government transactions on an open blockchain.
- r3trohack3r 4y agoI’m super not interested in “doing crime” on a permanent public ledger - no matter how good the math is today. It’s a gamble. A gamble that the zero knowledge proof, implementation, etc. will outlive the statute of limitations for whatever crime I commit. If it’s broken before that, my only hope is that I’m a small fish in a big pond of crime. I understand that past a certain threshold of crime, the risks of moving large volumes of other assets exceed the risk of a blockchain. But I’m not here to make large scale organized crime more resilient. I’ll pay cash thank you. (As a side note, I’m surprised at how many folks use Venmo for this stuff. The social feed is hilarious. Like it’s cool I can see that some dude I haven’t talked to since grade school sent some other dude $45 for weed. Not sure I needed that feature though.)
- TacticalCoder 4y ago> A gamble that the zero knowledge proof, implementation, etc. will outlive the statute of limitations for whatever crime I commit. And that is only for the blockchains which do actually use ZK-proofs. Like, say, David Chaum's upcoming "XX network" chain (FWIW David Chaum is the author of Digicash, predating Bitcoin, and one of the seven papers cited in Bitcoin's whitepaper). Most blockchains by very far are using a public ledger and zero ZK crypto.
- vitehozonage 4y agoMonero uses them too of course, the one people actually use, so it's the better example rather than something obscure you're obviously trying to promote
- tromp 4y agoEvery elliptic curve signature, used in nearly all cryptocurrencies to transfer funds, is a ZK proof of knowledge of a private key, so most blockchains do use some ZK cryptography.
- hnbear 4y agohttp://www.vicemo.com/ http://www.vicemo.com/ Sadly looks like it stopped updating.
- BigCryo 4y agoI love how our benevolent government creates so many different rules and regulations and laws. It's really wonderful
- flandish 4y agoI can’t, for the life of me, understand how anyone thought “public ledger” meant “hide transactions.” It’s the same concept as tor, in a way: once you get it out, that’s the nucleation point for tracking.
- juancn 4y agoThere's no erasure or loss of information in the ledger, as in with cash transactions. It's just obfuscation, so yeah, it can be a treasure trove of forensic information.