2 ms·
Re: analogies, having spent years answering questions on electronics.stackexchange I think the worst one is probably the electron. At this point you'll be half
by pjc50 4y ago
Re: analogies, having spent years answering questions on electronics.stackexchange I think the worst one is probably the electron.
At this point you'll be halfway through typing "but electrons are real, not an analogy" - but what do you think of when you think of an "electron"? If it's a ball, or even a point, then that itself is an analogy which will break down in all sorts of annoying ways. Electrons are slippery little non-localized bastards which can tunnel through solid objects. And don't get me started on holes. People like to think of electrons as "real" and holes as "not real", simply because they're defined by their absence, but in semiconductor physics they are both equally real and important.
If you use electrons, you have to face all sorts of basic problems like "why does electricity travel much faster than electrons move?" and "Why is the sign wrong on all of my calculations?" and "Which direction is current actually flowing?" These confuse people with an intermediate understanding.
It's much better to start with the field as primary. People understand gravitational fields and magnetic fields reasonably well. From these you can build an understanding in which it's the field carrying all the energy and the electrons are just along for the ride. Each carrying its own tiny electric field.
- namibj 4y agoThey're charge, in conductors neutralized by bulk charge from the substrate. Except plasma. That is a pure mix of majority and minority carriers.