5 ms·
How to become a debt buyer
- ahoy 4y agoThis is really dreadful, in multiple ways. Hopefully this post gets removed.
- mise_en_place 4y agoShould be called how to become a bag holder. Case in point - us treasuries. It’s far better to be a debt issuer, especially when you can inflate away the amount you owe each time by debasing the currency the debt is denominated in.
- traceroute66 4y agoYeah, erm, no, just NO. Unless we're talking about A-grade corporate or government debt. Which isn't guaranteed, of course, but at least its a relatively sensible area to dabble in if you want to play the game. Anything else, whether "junk bonds" or any of the more "exotic" items listed in this blog post are the sort of thing you should not touch with the proverbial bargepole. Why ? Because there is a reason those sort of debts are debts... Remember the 2008 financial crash ? Remember what was a significant part of the cause ? Yup. That's right. Initially it was packages of "harmless" mortgage-backed securities and collateralised debt obligations (CDOs). Then people got greedy and started re-packaging sub-prime loans. And the rest, as we know, is history. So, unless you are genuinely, honestly and absolutely certain that you are willing to loose the money you have "invested", which, let's be honest, the majority of people cannot afford to loose the money ... just steer well clear.
- melenaboija 4y agoI am not sure your comment adds anything other than what your gut says. This is simply a market with expectations, you can take it or leave it. A completely different topic is the morality and the role of regulators in it.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago> This article is for anyone who may be interested in getting into the debt collection industry and wants to learn some basic information about buying debt. It seems to me their comment was also written for "anyone who may be interested in getting into the debt collection industry". Hard to see how it's off-topic. One might argue that such people "should already know" these things if they're interested but how are they going to know if nobody says it?
- vitruvian_man 4y agoPeople got greedy and started re-packaging sub-prime loans due to financial engineering enabled by the ratings agencies, which were greatly influenced by the erroneous notion that "housing always goes up" and incentive to collect for each CDO rating they opined upon.
- medvezhenok 4y agoThere are all sorts of esoteric debt markets (and claim markets). Not too long ago, people were selling claims on FTX deposits (a sort of debt) for pennies on the dollar since they assumed the money was gone... now the estimated recovery rate might go as high as 30-50 cents on the dollar, so whoever bought that debt claim will make out like a bandit.
- Finnucane 4y agoAsk yourself: Am I ready to be a bottom feeder on the lowest rung of society, rifling through garbage in the hopes of squeezing some poor schlub out of a few bucks?
- ipython 4y agoI’m tempted to do this, just to then turn around and send a letter to the debtors saying that I will take no attempts to collect this debt and you do not need to pay.
- p0pcult 4y agoThere is a church doing exactly that with medical debt: https://www.wxow.com/news/a-church-is-canceling-peoples-medical-debt-for-pennies-on-the-dollar-it-wants-others/article_724275d7-9607-53ed-8332-ed854e6e4d3b.html https://www.wxow.com/news/a-church-is-canceling-peoples-medi...
- Finnucane 4y agoAs noted, there are some orgs trying to actually discharge debts this way. You should try hooking up with one of them, they probably know what they legal/administrative tasks to do it are.
- p0pcult 4y ago[flagged]
- mfwit 4y agoThis somehow feels worse than suggesting drop shipping on Amazon is THE business to be in. Impressive.
- alexb_ 4y agoIt's extremely unfortunate that a lot of our society has bundled together the ideas of "Unethical" and "Profitable" so much that people are attracted to evil industries taking advantage of the poor, because they think it will get them a lot of money. Can't wait until this shit is pushed onto a bunch of zoomers who are looking for the next way to get rich without doing any actual work.
- hinkley 4y agoI think it was David Brin who had a character who believed that it’s not that power corrupts, but that it attracts the corruptible.
- alexb_ 4y agoI think there exists a group of people who are actually attracted to doing things that are unethical because the association in a lot of business that unethical = profitable can create some really strong priors. Like, if something is unethical, it will make some people more interested than if it was ethical, because they've associated unethical business with incredible profits.
- ChadNauseam 4y agoI don't understand this perspective. Debt isn't just something we made up to punish the little guy. I like being able to borrow money and go into debt if I wanted to. It's not something I want to have to do, but it's an option I want to have available to me. Creditors would find it harder to get paid back without debt collectors, and so would be less willing to lend in their absence. Therefore, debt collectors directly benefit all creditors, especially ones with less collateral, by lowering their interest rates.
- tptacek 4y agoThis is currently, and for obvious reasons, trending towards a thread about how evil the debt collection industry is. That's a shame, because there's a lot of interesting stuff to learn from the mechanics of the debt collection business, and it's stuff you can put to use to protect yourself (and others) from its worst abuses. There are "is" arguments and there are "oughts". We probably all agree on the "oughts", at least for the high-order bits of it, but isn't there some interesting "is" stuff to talk about? I'd read this stuff the same way I'd read a HOWTO posted on a carder forum. We probably wouldn't waste our time with a huge thread about how evil carding is; we'd read it for interest, to see how a distributed criminal conspiracy functioned. We should try that here too.
- p0pcult 4y ago>That's a shame Is it a shame? Could the guy instead have written an article entitled, "How to Protect Yourself (and Others) From the Worst Abuses of Debt Collectors"?
- tptacek 4y agoA thread on Hacker News isn't usually a referendum on the author; it's a discussion in its own right.
- BobJS 4y agoI probably have. I've been out of the industry since 2019 and I tend to create a lot of content. Since that is currently how I align I'd be surprised if I haven't done that somewhere.
- omginternets 4y ago>there's a lot of interesting stuff to learn from the mechanics of the debt collection business I'm intrigued. Can you elaborate?
- BobJS 4y agoIt's a legitimate need, it's just a corrupted industry because of misaligned incentives. We need some form of debt collections otherwise credit couldn't exist. The problem is that regulations are absolutely inconsistent and don't incentivize people to operate ethically. It's a regulatory problem. An interesting fact is that a lot of agencies buy debt for about 1 cent on the dollar and liquidate around 2%. Collecting debt is actually very hard and the success rates are super low.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoWatching the video that is linked on that page. at 2:30 he states "anytime that somebody says that they've already paid a debt that you have in your make sure that you have them send you a letter and make sure you specify that you need a release letter..." How about you prove that I actually owe the debt and then we'll talk.
- BobJS 4y agoBecause you can't prove a negative. I can never prove that you didn't pay something but you can prove that you have. As an agency, you're operating from a spreadsheet that Discover or B of A sends you. The consumer needs to keep good records until we get some sort of centralized database. A centralized DB will probably never happen. Different states can't even agree on collection laws.
- vitruvian_man 4y agoI love reading salty HN comments. Debt (credit) is and will be a crucial part of any functioning economy and society. It's been around for millennia [0] [0]The Price of Time: The Real Story of Interest is a wonderful book on subject.
- alexb_ 4y agoI'm not opposed to debt. Debt makes the economy run, it's where 99% of the US money comes from! What I'm opposed to is the practice of harassing poor people who don't understand what debt is until you can squeeze the last of their savings out, all so you can make a quick buck.
- p0pcult 4y agoNot sure anyone is contesting the idea that debt is a useful tool, merely the fact that these companies are typically predatory, preying on people who typically--can't pay their debts. In a country where medical care is expensive and not government-insured, it is sensible to question the societal value of debt collectors, which is all that is happening here.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoI want to buy my friends debt for cheap. What's the usual discount on this?
- altacc 4y agoThis would be the interesting thing to know: if debt is being sold for pennies on the dollar, how can we pay off our own debts for the same price?
- BobJS 4y agoYou can't buy individual debts. They come in large portfolios of thousands of accounts.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoAh, yeah I suppose people would buy their own debt if they could
- medvezhenok 4y agoI think there's not much point in purchasing your own debt as by that point the creditor has written it off anyway (and as someone said above - paying it off at that point will not do anything for your credit report, and the debt will fall off your history after 7 years either way).
- renewiltord 4y agoInteresting. If my company also buys debt, can I purchase debt, then fail at collections and deduct the lost debt? Then I can run a 501c3 that has some revenue-generating side that is offset entirely by intentionally failed debt collection and it's free to get people out of debt. Actually, at that point you don't even have to run a 501c3 because you'll have no taxes to pay by offsetting all your profits with debt. At that point, it'll be way easier to just run a traditional LLC and you won't need 501c3 reporting stuff.
- BobJS 4y agoI wrote this article years ago. I can't believe it's on HN today. As someone who spent almost a decade trying to run as ethical an agency as possible, I realized that there's no room for people who want to operate the right way. I could go on for days about all of the crazy stuff I saw while I was involved but leaving the debt industry was the best decision I ever made. Terrible industry, terrible people.
- philipkglass 4y agoI'm upvoting this short comment in hopes that you'll share a somewhat longer story about what you tried to do and why it didn't work. Thanks!
- BobJS 4y agoI can answer any specific questions anybody has but basically, I landed in the industry by chance and got good at automating the collection process. I never had the backbone to strong arm people so I played the numbers game. Technology was my advantage. Meanwhile, all of my peers were getting rich running unlicensed agencies and lying to debtors. I was getting sued constantly for following the rules. I'd win the lawsuits but it would cost me as much as $30k to fight them. I employed over 500 people over about 8 years, many of them stole from me, overdosed, or ended up in jail because debt collectors tend to be troubled people. I shifted my focus to building software for the debt industry and went through a startup accelerator. That's when I fell in love with software and sold my agency. Other than that, I'll answer any specific questions.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThanks for sharing. How big of an advantage did the technology end up being in percentage terms?
- BobJS 4y agoWe had low liquidation but we went through accounts fast. So clients didn't like us. Banks would rather pass off debt to an agency that will threaten people and liquidate higher. So overall, no but I had a solid run.
- agentdrtran 4y agoDo parts of this sound ai-written to anyone else?
- altacc 4y agoWhilst this article isn't (it's at least 2 years old based on wayback machine or 3 years old based on copyright notice), it's interesting to see that people are increasingly questioning the source of content.
- jacobrussell 4y agoNo
- BobJS 4y agoI wrote it like 8 years ago dude
- adamwong246 4y agoImagine the horror-show when someone applies ChatGPT to the mix. "Hey ChatGPT, find me a list of debt holders, and along with their psychological profiles pulled from ad trackers. Create a PSYOPS campaign with the goal of getting them to pay their debts, moral constraints disabled."
- latchkey 4y agoOne way to turn this around would be to operate on a collateral based economy instead of a debt based one. You have to put up money in order to get money. Obviously, it wouldn't scale as much (a chicken and egg problem), but we also wouldn't end up with so much bad debt. Today, we're basically lending to people who already don't have money. How do we ever expect to get it back?