4 ms·
"“I don't believe that we'll be able to remove stinknet just by pulling it. We're going to need some chemical methods as well.” —Samuel Shaw, editorial intern"
by dylan604 4y ago
"“I don't believe that we'll be able to remove stinknet just by pulling it. We're going to need some chemical methods as well.” —Samuel Shaw, editorial intern"
i'm confused by this credit to the comment. "Samuel Shaw is an editorial intern for High Country News based in the Colorado Front Range." is this really a job title where someone can just add their own opinions? the strong advice of needing chemicals is not advice i feel comfortable on following from an intern. this comment really took the whole article down in credibility in my opinion (since they seem so open to expressing opinions).
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- totoglazer 4y agoIt’s not the best written or typeset. However I think that’s a quote from Armstrong? > Armstrong, however, said that Maricopa County will need to resort to herbicides, which may pose their own risks. “I don't believe that we'll be able to remove stinknet just by pulling it. We're going to need some chemical methods as well.”
- teruakohatu 4y agoIt is an unusual comment when there are other methods for removing invasive pests other than pulling them out. When they work Biological pest control methods can be extremely effective and work quickly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_pest_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_pest_control While some forms of bio control require extensive research programs to prove safety, others can be as simple as planting native species that complete with the weed. Here in New Zealand, gorse is a horrible, also yellow, woody shrub weed that is near impossible to remove with chemicals or by pulling it out (it just grows back). A solution was found simply to plant native trees under the gorse. The gorse ends up sheltering the native tree and once the native grows up it shades the gorse and the gorse dies off. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gorse_in_New_Zealand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gorse_in_New_Zealand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_control_of_gorse_in_New_Zealand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_control_of_gorse_in... A lot of bio control research is done in New Zealand to help pacific islands deal with invasive species. The tropical climates mean that when invasive weeds arrive, they spread like crazy disrupting the fragile ecosystems.
- rgmerk 4y agoBiological control is important but not a panacea. Not all invasive species have predators/diseases that are effective, specific, and maintain a viable population without human intervention. Biological control can go horribly wrong. One of the most notorious examples is the cane toad, which is in plague proportions across northern Australia.
- teruakohatu 4y agoIn fairness to me I never said it was a panacea, just that mechanical removal and chemicals are not the only option. Biological control practised today is vastly different to the old days of "let's just see how it goes" and introduce a large mammals, reptiles or amphibians (see the famous Simpsons episode). Today it is a long scientific process to ensure the control measure is hyper targeted. Sometimes it works great other times it just doesn't work at all and the agent dies off, but gone of the days of a failure being an ecological disaster.
- pfdietz 4y agoAn example of successful biological control of an invasive plant in North America is Purple Loosestrife. This otherwise attractive plant created large monotonous colonies in wetlands. Insects such as Galerucella calmariensis and Hylobius transversovittatus, which feed on the plant and keep it under control back in Eurasia, were found, evaluated, and introduced to the North America, to great effect. One sees the plant now but it's kept from running wild.
- pfdietz 4y agoAn even more remarkable story of biological control is the spongy moth (previously called the gypsy moth). https://biocontrol.entomology.cornell.edu/success.php https://biocontrol.entomology.cornell.edu/success.php "The tale of the gypsy moth is intriguing on several levels, including its mysterious control by a fungus (Hajek 2007). Originally brought to the US to breed with the native silkworms, the gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar L., escaped through a broken window in Medford, MA in 1868-9 and began defoliating deciduous forests and shade trees in many regions of North America. High populations of this pest are uncommon in areas where it has long been established (Europe, northern Africa and temperate Asia), but outbreaks have occurred where gypsy moth has invaded without its natural enemies. Fungal infected gypsy moths were found in Japan and brought back and released in the Boston area in 1910-11, but apparently didn’t take. By 1997, dozens of other natural enemies were also released but none provided effective control. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, scientists noticed gypsy moth cadavers hanging from trees in the northeastern forests and identified the cause as a fungal infection. This discovery renewed interest in using fungi for control. Molecular studies indicated that the infection was caused by the same species of fungus, Entomophaga maimaiga, as the one collected in Japan in the early 1900’s, but that it was not identical to that fungus or to the same species collected and released in 1985-86. When and where did it come from and how was it spread? The answer seems that it was an accidental introduction from Japan and probably occurred after 1971. Perhaps even more interesting is that fact that it has spread across the contiguous distribution of the gypsy moth in the Northeastern US. This spread is due to aerial dispersal of spores from gypsy moth larvae and perhaps to human activity, as gypsy moths are prone to move long distances on the undersides of vehicles. There is interest in using infected gypsy moth, or the fungus itself, to inoculate the leading edges of newly infested areas and prevent outbreaks of this devastating pest. However, details of the introduction and establishment of US populations of E. maimaiga remain a mystery."
- cypherpunks01 4y agoIt looks like that is a signoff for the end of the article, not the author quoting himself. I think it's just continuation of quoting from the person who was quoted above. Slightly sloppy by not attributing the quote, but in context it seems fine. Combined with confusing signoff for the article.
- emodendroket 4y agoHey, why not, any schmuck can walk into Home Depot and come out with herbicides they can spray with abandon.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoWhy are you misquoting the article to look like it's the journalist saying that, and not the person they're interviewing?
- dylan604 4y agoI didn't misquote anything. I literally copy&pasted the text from the article as listed. Why are you being a troll?
- Gordonjcp 4y agoYou copied and pasted part of the sentence, missing out the important part where it mentions who is saying that quote. If pointing out that you're either mistaken or deliberately disingenuous is "trolling", then you need to take a bit of a look at yourself.