8 ms·
The maneuvering thruster system sounds similar to that of the Harrier VTOL. Which makes sense, because BAE Systems made the later Harriers. The Harrier used tha
by Animats 4y ago
The maneuvering thruster system sounds similar to that of the Harrier VTOL. Which makes sense, because BAE Systems made the later Harriers. The Harrier used that because it had to have some control at very low speeds, where the control surfaces are ineffective.
That system was very difficult for humans to fly. Pure-thrust vehicles are unstable.
Computers have far less trouble, as we see with quadrotor drones.
- inamberclad 4y agoInteresting, I wonder if this is more like a reaction control system with discrete jets, or if it's more focused on boundary layer control (or some combination thereof). By strategically causing flow separation on wing elements at specific times, a little bit of air could have a huge effect on the aerodynamic forces on the vehicle. The bare metal on the leading and trailing edge surfaces of the wing make me thing the latter is included in the design. Edit: yes, they're doing boundary layer control, just not in the way I thought. This article has a diagram: https://www.baesystems.com/en/article/magma-the-future-of-flight https://www.baesystems.com/en/article/magma-the-future-of-fl...
- mlyle 4y ago> The maneuvering thruster system sounds similar to that of the Harrier VTOL. It doesn't really, to me. The big idea here is using blown air to avoid having physical surfaces deflect-- neither the engine nozzle or any actual control surfaces on the plane. The Harrier uses fairly conventional bending nozzles to vector trust, and uses fairly conventional control surfaces at speed. > That system was very difficult for humans to fly. Anything helicopter-like is difficult to fly, and the Harrier is a pretty mediocre "helicopter" with relatively poor response times. In principle blown-air deflection of thrust could be more responsive for VTOL-type aircraft, but that's not even what this is aiming at. (The deflection attained of thrust is not sufficient for VTOL use at this point-- nor is deflecting thrust in one degree of freedom from one point sufficient for hovering flight.) > Pure-thrust vehicles are unstable. Blowing air to adjust airflow at the trailing edge doesn't necessarily produce anything too hard to control-- it's pretty similar to conventional control schemes. On the other hand, this aircraft will not be controllable at all without the active systems gating the airflow, while aircraft with control surfaces can often fallback completely to dumb control cables.
- Animats 4y ago> The Harrier uses fairly conventional bending nozzles to vector trust, and uses fairly conventional control surfaces at speed. On the Harrier, those are the big rotating lift nozzles. There are also small attitude control nozzles ("puffers") at the nose, tail, and wingtips. The puffers are used in hover and at very low speed. This new drone is pumping out supersonic air through control jets and bending the jets with a fluidic amplifier. That's new. May or may not be useful. [1] https://i.imgur.com/78bVjbC.png https://i.imgur.com/78bVjbC.png
- ianburrell 4y agoThese aren’t maneuvering thrusters where thrust moves the plane. These are changing the airflow on wing to act like control surfaces. Pilot should fly them the same way as now, with computers making them work and act like normal surfaces. This isn’t replacing aileron with thruster but replacing with inverse aileron. The next generation might use airflow control surfaces.
- Animats 4y agoRight. It's a fluidic amplifier. Steering a fluid jet with a smaller fluid jet is known, but not used much.
- carabiner 4y agoIt's useful for reducing radar cross section. Moving control surfaces are a headache for RCS management. The F-22 uses "cat eye" slits between its control surfaces to minimize these radar blooms, but it'd better to do away with them altogether. It could also remove the need for those huge aerodynamic fairings on the CS actuators on jetliners, but then add some complexity and remove fuel volume in the wings.
- ehnto 4y agoI am unsure of how the trailing edge tech works, are they blowing the air out of trailing edge for roll control, and is it blowing aft or directionally? Is the blown air itself the force moving the wing or is it just redirecting flow over the wing? I am thinking of diminishing control as speeds lower, which is already a characteristic of regular control surfaces. This is super interesting, I would love to build it in an RC plane.
- thunderbird120 4y agoNot really, thrust vectoring is separate from what they're doing here. Thrust vectoring allows you to literally use thrust from the engine to push the plane in different directions, this is a bit more subtle. Basically you can use little puffs of air to control the flow of air over the wings and other lifting surfaces and this can be used to increase or decrease lift in certain places. The actual force produced by these little air jets it totally negligible but by changing the way air travels over the lifting surfaces it can change the lift generated, allowing you to get rid of moving mechanical control surfaces. This requires very careful engineering and a very detailed computer modeling to get right which is why it's only really happening now.