4 ms·
Yes, absolutely. And what's changed is that we now have a massive number of people (on both sides) who no longer agree that these things are important, or at l
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
Yes, absolutely. And what's changed is that we now have a massive number of people (on both sides) who no longer agree that these things are important, or at least who think that other things are more important - so much more important that "these things" (constitutional protections) can be circumvented when they get in the way of the "more important things".
Constitutional protections are largely running on institutional inertia at the moment. That's good - the institutions were supposed to do that - but it won't last forever.
- colpabar 4y ago[flagged]
- CyberDildonics 4y agoDo you evaluate everything based on how you can label the people who made it or just this?
- nebulousthree 4y agoI agree that the expression is tired but it is not wrong. The context has changed.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoThe argument goes: Premise 1) Person came up with Idea. Premise 2) I do not like Person. Conclusion) I do not like Idea. It's not actually a good argument against Idea, it's just a preference.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoYou are absolutely right, even though you were downvoted at least three times in under a minute for some reason.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoProbably, assuming you upvoted. The comment was at -1 when I read this.
- millzlane 4y agoI've pondered this before. If a thief tells you that a all men deserve a right to own their own possessions and be secure in their ownership. Would you say he was wrong? Sure, he's a hypocrite but is it not true what the thief said?
- JellyBeanThief 4y agoIt's not that the sides no longer agree that these things are important. They do. The problem is they don't believe they agree that they're important. They believe the other side has abandoned the constitution, and they know that puts their own side at a disadvantage if they stay with it. The two sides are so frightened of each other at this point that all assumptions of good faith are off the table. So, note for next version of the constitution: Make sure the first amendment establishes strict separation of speech and money.
- majormajor 4y agoMoney vs speech is a good example, I think, of people not agreeing that these things are important or not. And that the "Constitution" part is not the important part. How would you get a Constitution to separate money when there are so many well-funded pushes for exactly the opposite, resulting in the situation where the courts say money needs to be protected? Before you can do that you need to get everyone on board with the dangers of money in politics, and then if you can do that, you've solved the problem because now your judges won't interpret "protection of speech" as "protection of buying political influence." You gotta win the debate either way.
- JellyBeanThief 4y ago> How would you get a Constitution to separate money Not that I put a lot of effort into this formulation, but how about something like > A well-informed and reasonable public, being necessary to the security of a working democracy, the right of the people to free and quick access to public information must not be abridged, but protected. And then back that up with a multi-layer prescriptive dictionary to minimize judicial reinterpretation. The terms "right of the people", "free and quick access", "public information" would defined in layer N, while the terms "right", "people", "free", "quick", "access", "public", and "information" would be defined in some layers N - M. We've had some centuries now to get better at technical writing, language engineering, and lexicography, to say nothing of IT. We should use them.
- locopati 4y agoIt's pretty hard to have good faith to people who have bullied and been deceptive to attain their goal of undermining bodily autonomy.