4 ms·
Experts shouldn't want to write encyclopedias. That's presuming a great deal, don't you think? Besides, the format of Wikipedia isn't so much that an expert wo
by angersock 15y ago
Experts shouldn't want to write encyclopedias.
That's presuming a great deal, don't you think? Besides, the format of Wikipedia isn't so much that an expert would need to write an entire encyclopedia as it is that they can contribute their knowledge of a tiny slice of the domain to an article.
Don't get so bogged down in the definition of encyclopedia--hell, almost all of those are printed on paper or optical media, so I guess Wikipedia isn't an encyclopedia either, and so we shouldn't limit ourselves.
- tptacek 15y agoWho is this "we" you're talking about? How much of Wikipedia did "we" build? A bunch of people got together and used the Internet to replace Britannica. While doing it, they also said, "here's all of our work product, if you want to go do something else with it". Now here comes 'angersock, for whom that's not good enough. "No, it's not enough that I have the whole Internet to build a new site on, and the whole Wikipedia database to seed it with; no, I want the people working on Wikipedia to build the thing I want, and stop concerning themselves so much with that whole encyclopedia thing". I'm caricaturing, I know, but really, I don't get where you're coming from here.
- angersock 15y agoAnswered elsewhere--let's try to consolidate our discussion.