4 ms·
The true waste would be taking valuable research and synthesize and hiding it in an encyclopedia. It's not like it wouldn't be available elsewhere, right? It
by angersock 15y ago
The true waste would be taking valuable research and synthesize and hiding it in an encyclopedia.
It's not like it wouldn't be available elsewhere, right?
It goes research -> authorship of secondary source (journal article, book, magazine article, whatever) -> citation in encyclopedia.
Conventionally, sure, but Wikipedia would seem to offer an opportunity to fix the shortcomings with that system.
Why do you care so much about secondary sources? Because they're vetted. Why is that important? Because primary sources can be taken out of context, because people can't parse them out correctly, etc.
I would submit that both of those things are no longer safe assumptions.
Secondary sources can be fabricated whole-cloth and appear legitimate (entire industries, such as some branches of SEO, do exactly this) when they are not, and can even cite Wikipedia themselves. So, secondary sources aren't these bastions of truth that they seem to be.
The idea that primary sources aren't usable to the populace is also old. It's trivial these days for a user (who cares even the tiniest amount) to run a search and contextualize a source. If Crazy Eddie's Account of the Haymarket Riot is, after a fast search, the only one that has Xenu interfering then maybe it's not a credible account, yeah?
Moreover, having so many eyes seeing the same citations and clicking through them increases the likelihood that somebody who actually does have expertise in the matter can comment usefully.
If you can't trust the great unwashed masses to search out the truth of things given primary sources, why do you think giving them prechewed knowledge is any better?
- tptacek 15y agoThe one promise an encyclopedia makes is that it is an effective prose survey of the existing literature. You propose that an encyclopedia should, if it can, also set out to be a sprawling "book about everything"; a primary source when experts debate on its pages, a secondary source when an expert decides to write an encyclopedia article instead of a book, and a tertiary source the rest of the time. The two goals conflict. You can't be an effective prose survey of the existing literature when any given sentence in any given article could be original research. The whole point of an encyclopedia --- a prose survey of literature --- is that you don't have to check every sentence to see if it comes from a reliable source.
- angersock 15y agoSo, I think I see the root of our disagreement here. I'm not proposing that encyclopedias writ large could/should/would do this--I propose that Wikipedia specifically do this. I claim that Wikipedia is considered an encyclopedia as that is the closest idea in mainstream use of what it is--and that now it's time to evolve further to better human understanding. There's no ambition--to use phrenology's phrasing--in doing anything less.
- tptacek 15y agoAbout 10 years ago, a couple of guys (the best known of whom was a bit of a fuckup) set up a web site with a trivial bit of software and in effect declared, "by soliciting anonymous unpaid contributions from the Internet at large to this crappy web page, we are going to build a resource that rivals the two-and-a-half-centuries-old Encyclopedia Britannica". 10 years later their site was not a footnote or a parable about Internet hubris. No, it was a resource that is in some ways better than the Encyclopedia Britannica in scope, in depth, and in some cases even in quality. It is a breathtaking achievement. Our daily reaction to it (and pretty much everything else on the Internet) is a crystal clear metric of how jaded we are. How extraordinarily lucky we are to be living in a time where someone like Jimbo Wales can (by the standards of history) more or less pull something like Wikipedia out of his butt at random on a whim. I think people need to get over what else Wikipedia could be. If you're right, there's an easy (and productive) way to prove your point: take the Wikipedia database, which is provided to you and to the public under extremely permissive licensing, and build the site you want Wikipedia to be. Based on your comments on this thread, I suggest the name of your site not include the string "pedia". Maybe you want to build "Wikijournal of XXX", or "The Wiki Transactions On XXX". Seriously. If that dude can make a Wikipedia simply because he got bored publishing web photos of boobs, anybody can do something similar. Get to work, and stop arguing with the encyclopedians.
- angersock 15y agoSo, yes, these are amazing times, Wikipedia is impressive, all glory to the hypnotoad, etc. Not arguing that. There is no reason to go to all the effort of forking Wikipedia just to prove a point, and asking me to do so is absurd. Let's ignore hosting. Let's ignore bandwidth. Let's ignore the amount of time it would take to duplicate that information. Let's ignore several "easy" (read: inconvenient to your argument that "you can just magically fork the datas!") issues I would encounter pursuing your suggested course of action. From a practical standpoint, Wikipedia has become the place where normal people get information. It is the cache of human knowledge that is first hit when somebody wants to learn something new. I'm not talking about where you turn, or where I turn--I'm talking about Joe Blow. It seems to consistently be in the top few results for any search on a topic. Ignore the encyclopedia bit. Ignore what it claims to be. Ignore even what it is. Pay attention to how it is used. The de facto use of Wikipedia goes something like: 1. Person wants to know about concept X. 2. Person searches for X, probably gets a Wikipedia article. 3. Person reads article on X on Wikipedia. So, it would seem that currently Wikipedia's use is to provide knowledge about X. The end user doesn't give two shits about the process that put that information there; or how reliable it is; or whether it is sourced primarily, secondarily, or made up entirely. The end user just wants knowledge. So, either one believes that Wikipedia has perfected the accomplishment of that mission (in which case I think you are obviously wrong), or one believes that Wikipedia has the capacity to be improved to meet that goal. Are you going to take a hard line that Wikipedia is perfect in its accomplishment of its de facto use case? Are you going to argue that good is good enough? EDIT: I'm not going to launch into how wasteful it would be to split up mindspace/SEOspace by creating another wiki. Suffice it to say that a mree policy change on Wikipedia could accomplish all this, while in the forking case you'd have all those "easy" problems to solve, plus promotion to get people (and lots of them!) involved, plus making sure people don't just default to Wikipedia anyways, etc.