3 ms·
The report mentions one of the effects of NSS is lower caloric intake. What people may not realize is your body is quite "efficient" at running at various calo
by bombcar 4y ago
The report mentions one of the effects of NSS is lower caloric intake.
What people may not realize is your body is quite "efficient" at running at various caloric amounts, and ±569 kJ/day (135 calories) may not do much.
Especially if there are other side effects of consuming "sweetener" like wanting to eat a tiny bit more (the opposite of using mouthwash, for example, which makes you want to eat nothing more).
- qeternity 4y ago> What people may not realize is your body is quite "efficient" at running at various caloric amounts, and ±569 kJ/day (135 calories) may not do much. Source? I'm very much in the camp that diet has a huge impact on one's ability to control their eating, but I've never seen anything that suggests that calories in calories out doesn't apply (outside of extremes, like genuine starvation).
- bombcar 4y agoCalories in = calories out, but 135 calories is not much (that's what, a 30 minute slow walk for an average American)? So if you drop your intake by 135 calories you may just not walk as much and not even really notice it. Or your body may slow down metabolism a tiny bit, etc.
- lm28469 4y agoYeah but then again the average american walks ~3000 step a day, which is about 30min.
- nmarinov 4y agoTo add on to what bombcar said: I don't think the implication is CICO doesn't apply. In my experience (and also studies) change in calorie intake is correlated with change in activity i.e.: when you eat more you naturally move more. Not just exercising and walking but also jittering and cleaning that little bit harder and moving that little bit faster. Or the opposite, saving a little bit of energy. Instead of moving your whole head to look at something - just a glance and so on. CICO is still valid but the body adjusts beyond what we can _easily_ measure. It's a lot more complicated but the above is one simple example how it adjusts.
- bombcar 4y agoExactly. You have to combine a caloric drop with an intentional increase in activity and even then it can take awhile for the changes to start to add up to be noticeable.
- unmole 4y agoCalories in calories out always applies. But calories out is a moving target and is influenced by calories in.
- deeviant 4y agoSo you are saying dieting does not work? Reducing calories is not the path to weight loss?
- bombcar 4y agoI am saying that the data in the report measures such a small amount (apparently) that it is hard to draw useful conclusions. I.e., as with many metareports, it's kinda worthless, it seems.
- irthomasthomas 4y agoCalories not important. Type of calories important. Fibre contains calories, but they are locked up in a hard chemical shell that your body cannot crack, and therefore is unaffected by it. So, 200 calories of regular carbs are far more fattening than 200 calories of fibre carbs. Edit: When I said that the body is unaffected by it, I was referring to the fact that fibre does no trigger the same cascading chemical reaction that other carbs do. No amount of fibre will cause an insulin spike and increased fat storage. The types of foods (and NNSs) we consume, and the chemical affects they have, are more important than the amount we consume.
- EForEndeavour 4y agoThe reduced availability of food energy from fibre is already accounted for in at least Canada's food labeling rules: https://inspection.canada.ca/food-labels/labelling/industry/nutrition-labelling/elements-within-the-nutrition-facts-table/eng/1613599715710/1613599936553#s4c1 https://inspection.canada.ca/food-labels/labelling/industry/... Energy value of dietary fibre A value of 2 Cal (8 kJ) per gram should be used for the dietary fibre portion of the fibre source. A value of less than 2 Cal (8 kJ) per gram may be used for the dietary fibre content if a specific value is available for the fibre source. Energy value of bran The energy value of the fibre portion of wheat bran is 0.6 Cal (2.5 kJ) / g and the wheat bran itself has an energy value of 2.4 Cal (10 kJ) / g.
- irthomasthomas 4y ago
- unshavedyak 4y ago> the opposite of using mouthwash, for example, which makes you want to eat nothing more .. sorry to be stupid for a second. Is this due to the taste? Or is there a known side effect of some types of mouthwash that inhibit hunger? I've never noticed anything, hence the question. I'd eat right after with no issue basically, but i don't because it's bad for your teeth to my understanding.
- bombcar 4y agoI don't know if it happens to everyone, or if it is just suggestion from normally being done before bed, etc, but the "post mouthwash mouth" makes me not want to eat again, maybe just because I'd have to brush/wash again. Or it could be that it "cleans" the palate so you're not "tasting" any sugars/food anymore so you go out of "it is eat time" mode.
- Freebytes 4y agoI am the opposite. For some reason, I want to eat immediately after using mouthwash, but maybe that is because I always want what I cannot have.
- raverbashing 4y agoPeople who drink sodas drink way more than 135kcal per day of sugary ones. One can is more than that The report is "technically correct" and also completely idiotic from a "putting the diet into practice" perspective.