2 ms·
It's not a strictly flat hierarchy, though, is it? And so not every user has equal power, right? I'm not completely versed in the Byzantine system of Wikipedia
by angersock 15y ago
It's not a strictly flat hierarchy, though, is it? And so not every user has equal power, right?
I'm not completely versed in the Byzantine system of Wikipedia, but the whole thing is based (somehow) on seniority, right? It would seem, then, that the system would self-select for people who spend more time on Wikipedia than doing useful research, right?
- DanBC 15y agoIn theory every editor (even those without an account) have equal weight. It doesn't matter if you know what the subject is or not. It doesn't matter how long you've been working on WP. What does matter is if you can source everything you write to a 'reliable' source; and if you can write clearly. Obviously, in practice this is not the case. Anon editors are often treated like dirt; people making 15,000 twinkle edits feel as if they should have some extra power or consideration. And there's a bunch of meta stuff which is, frankly, toxic and probably doing a lot of harm.
- tptacek 15y agoAdmins can lock articles and ban users, but they cannot use their powers to trump non-admins and get their text into articles. The WP admin community is a shark tank. Admins could try to use their status to thump people around article talk pages, but --- and this isn't an exaggeration --- there are at least 2 other admins watching commit-by-commit what any given admin does, looking for some policy slip-up they can use to incite drama. In practice, in the vast majority of articles, there is no seniority. At best, a person with a demonstrated history of building and grooming an article over a year or so might expect some deference when newcomer attempts a dramatic change. That deference is a good thing, and has nothing to do with adminship.
- SteveJS 15y agoWikipedia's accidental mission to ensure the stability and propagation of "popular misconceptions" is not very compelling. I understand it is the current tradeoff for something as great as wikipedia. But that doesn't mean the criticism is invalid.
- tptacek 15y agoI don't understand the criticism. Wikipedia is a terrible venue to correct "popular misconceptions". If a misconception about the evidence against the Haymarket Anarchists is indeed embedded into the best known books about the event, the correction of that misconception merits more than a sentence or two in an encyclopedia! And indeed the author here agrees, because he went on to write an authoritative text about the event, which will be cited by the encyclopedia.
- SteveJS 15y agoThe criticism is that writing an authoritative book or peer reviewed article is demonstrably insufficient in the face of a large body of incorrect secondary material and active editorial control. I think it uncontroversial to claim Wikipedia is a knowledge base with a bias toward stability of mature articles over correctness. It's a tradeoff. I believe your argument is that it is the right tradeoff. That may be true, but that opinion fails to be properly cited, and does not have a large body of secondary sources backing it up. :-)
- flomo 15y agoFrom my observations: The wording of many articles seems to be the result of a carefully applied 'truce' between long-standing edit warriors. Once applied, they tend to unite using terms like 'stable' or 'consensus'. These editors do effectively have "seniority" on that article and the ability to reject changes. Then a random newcomer bumbles in and unwittingly disturbs the balance, and everyone unites against him. This is what I suspect happened to the author of the piece more so than goofing his citations.