I wish people would apply critical thinking to whether or not it is appropriate to permanently punish two and all of their progeny for an action they took prior

I wish people would apply critical thinking to whether or not it is appropriate to permanently punish two and all of their progeny for an action they took prior to having knowledge of good and evil. Or why an omniscient, omnipotent, and benevolent being would need to torture a distant descendant of theirs to death before considering forgiveness for that action.