4 ms·
> Enjoy responsibly. You are responsible for whatever you do with the output of these models, just like you are responsible for whatever you do with a knife, a
by mschuster91 4y ago
> Enjoy responsibly. You are responsible for whatever you do with the output of these models, just like you are responsible for whatever you do with a knife, a car, or a lighter.
The problem is: if I do something with a knife, say I threaten someone to stab them, I can and will get charged by the court for that crime. If I use AI to create content that incites violence (say, I create a video alleging a Quran burning), I would not be held liable for the consequences of my action.
The author's POV completely ignores the disparity in liability in the digital world and "digital ethics" in general.
- gattilorenz 4y ago> I would not be held liable for the consequences of my action. Incitement is a felony in multiple countries. Just because you did not write it but used an AI to write it, it doesn't mean you get a free pass. You spread it online, or made it possible to do so.
- mschuster91 4y agoMostly these laws are scoped to the country one is living in. The problem is, say I decide to post a meme inciting violence in a different country or limiting a country's decision to join NATO (the quran burning in Sweden for example caused Turkish president Erdogan to block Sweden's NATO bid)... I don't have to face any charges or responsibility, despite potentially affecting the lives of millions of people.
- Capricorn2481 4y agoYou are right, and this is a tech problem even before LLMs. Facebook has allowed very consequential calls for ethnic cleansing in Ethiopia and hasn't done anything about it. That is the issue with a global tech products. But there's nothing about LLMs that changes that from a country level prosecution/accountability perspective. You still have to be aware of where you're putting that text into the world. Right now, it's just between you and ChatGPT. People shouldn't fool themselves into thinking they can just plug this shit into their news network and be free of liability
- mschuster91 4y ago> You are right, and this is a tech problem even before LLMs. Indeed, which is why I find statements such as the one from the article's author that I pointed out in the first comment in the chain so disgusting. "Enjoy responsibly" is not an attitude to have with a weapon so powerful as AI or social media.
- Capricorn2481 4y agoI hold that opinion too. I think we're talking about two different things 1) AI helps people to make harmful context extremely easily, and that's why there are calls for regulation (which will probably favor OpenAI and stifle competition). We should question whether AI is a net negative 2) AI is being taken too seriously as an "oracle" of some kind that knows all, and people want to sue OpenAI for things it spits out when really people don't need help making up rumors. This is the part that seems unfair to me.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoIn the United States (for instance) you wouldn’t be liable for the consequences of your actions because they wouldn’t constitute a crime, not because you’ve laundered the actions through technology. Using technology as a means or medium doesn’t make the expression not yours. Whether I use my voice, a telephone, or an LLM I configured I am making the expression and I am accountable for it.
- Capricorn2481 4y agoLLMs are text generation, and I'm responsible for what text I put into the world. The law probably won't move fast enough to catch up with AI, but people should be liable for the AI content as much as they are manually written content. We should not be plugging our apps into a black box of text generation and crying if it says something harmful/illegal and there was no human in place to proofread it. Maybe prompt engineering and temperature settings can be enough to prevent this, but ChatGPT has only been out ~6 months and I find the attitude that the burden is on OpenAI to make sure it never says anything bad completely ass backwards. It's like a writer controlling his pen with puppet strings and going "wow, look what it's saying!" What if I ask it to make a threat against a public figure or ethnic group. Am I liable? What if I only hint at it, with a high temperature setting, hoping it generates it? The line is nowhere visible and it will be open to the interpretations of whatever person is judging you and all the biases that come with that. We need to stop acting like LLMs are anything they aren't. The only reason the Australian mayor is so pissed of about the "defamation" from ChatGPT is because it's being marketed as a knowledge database (including by many people on HN). It doesn't know anything, it just predicts the next word of what it says. And it will never reach a place where it's completely accurate, so why are we trying to litigate it as such?
- mschuster91 4y ago> Maybe prompt engineering and temperature settings can be enough to prevent this, but ChatGPT has only been out ~6 months and I find the attitude that the burden is on OpenAI to make sure it never says anything bad completely ass backwards. It's like a writer controlling his pen with puppet strings and going "wow, look what it's saying!" The problem ChatGPT - but especially image, audio and video AI systems - has is that these systems have drastically lowered the barrier to entry to create harmful content. Everyone can rig up an AI prompt to draw a convincing picture of a politician having sexual intercourse with a child in a matter of mere minutes - a work that would take even a dedicated visual artist many hours. For "voice cloning" AI, it's even worse, as it was practically impossible to emulate that unless you had access to a person talented enough to re-enact voices - and now anyone can pull off completely "legitimate" sounding prank voice calls. The general availability of such specialized AI completely erodes trust in anything not happening face-to-face - it was already bad enough with people denying actual genocides (Armenia, the Holocaust, Bosnia), but now? How can we even make sure historians can trust records from our time period?