4 ms·
While I guess an uncensored language model could create something mildly illegal, an uncensored image model could probably generate highly illegal content. Ther
by cubefox 4y ago
While I guess an uncensored language model could create something mildly illegal, an uncensored image model could probably generate highly illegal content. There is a trade-off between being uncensored and the (degree of) illegality of the content.
- nottorp 4y ago[Post deleted because I can't be bothered].
- cubefox 4y agoIn many countries.
- 1827163 4y agoYes, like in the UK, where it's practically already a de-facto police state.
- veidr 4y agoProbably lots of places, but certainly the USA, for instance.
- drxzcl 4y agoCan you give an example of a piece of text that would be illegal to write (not transmit/communicate, just write) in the US?
- cubefox 4y agoCan you give an example of a piece of text that would be illegal to write (not transmit/communicate, just write) in China?
- veidr 4y agoTotally bro! Let me just post that to this public internet forum for you... UPDATE: No, that was a joke. I was referring to imagery, which fictional or not can definitely be illegal in the USA even if you draw it yourself in your private journal. I'm not sure if you can be prosecuted in the USA for anything you write down yourself and don't somehow disseminate. (Although "doing it with computer" might also change the equation... US laws get pretty weird.)
- MacsHeadroom 4y agoDespite the wording of certain bills, mere possession of purely artificial media is generally not something the government has or can demonstrate a legitimate interest in controlling.
- RecycledEle 4y agoText that is illegal to write in the USA: Calls for violence against corrupt and powerful people who abuse others on a daily basis. Classified or confidential information such as security plans for the previously mentioned powerful abusers. Also including educational and medical records. Ways to circumvent censorship (DMCA.) Releasing true fact against court orders. Publishing factually correct evidence of powerful people raping kids (CSAM.) Publishing decryption keys that allow government information to be accessed. Software without FBI backdoors installed. Information that encouraged disobedience to current law (e.g., sovereign citizens.) Trade secrets. Communicating anything over radio frequency without the correct FCC license.
- tristor 4y agoNone of that is illegal to write, some of it isn't even illegal to communicate. Most of the things there would only create a legal issue when communicated, but not when written, and in most cases are necessarily written by authorized persons. Trade Secrets are basically always written down, they are not illegal to communicate, but doing so may violate a contract which would be a civil matter not a criminal matter. In the cases that the contract is either determined not to be binding or expired or was otherwise nullified, communicating trade secrets is an expected outcome. In fact, what makes something a trade secret is that a business takes actions and expends efforts to prevent its communication, as opposed to publishing it openly as a patent and getting legal governmental protections.
- nottorp 4y ago[Post deleted because I can't be bothered]
- veidr 4y agoWell, I mean, def not a fan of putting people to death for blasphemy, but... how does that make thinking of the US laws a "mistake"?
- 1827163 4y agoWell this "highly illegal content" is yet another attempt by the state to police our creativity. It is a thought crime. It's the 21st Century, we should not be conducting moral witch hunts in this day and age. That rightfully belongs in the past. Maybe if we distribute the material it should be illegal then. But otherwise it's not the state's right to police what art we are creating in our own homes, period. Thankfully, because it's run locally and not on the cloud, there is little the government can do about it, so it's very hard to enforce.
- drxzcl 4y agoThere is very little that is illegal to write down (with or without AI help) in most jurisdictions. Even things like threats, the crime is in the communication, not in writing the text. I can write down "Person X, I'm going to kill you dead" in my notebook as much as I want, as long as I don't communicate to anyone (i.e. threaten anyone, as opposed to writing down a threat in my personal papers). I'm very curious what text a personally owned and operated network could generate that would be unambiguously illegal in a liberal democracy.
- zirgs 4y agoHolocaust denial in Germany.
- egeozcan 4y agoReally asking: If I deny it in my personal notes and they are discovered in an irrelevant search, would I be in trouble? That'd be horrible lawmaking.
- RedNifre 4y agoIANAL, but the German holocaust rules are about propaganda and I don't think that personal notes that were intended to not be read by anyone else can be considered propaganda.
- Bran_son 4y agoIn Ireland, perhaps soon: Irish Citizens Could Soon Be Jailed for ‘Possessing Material Likely to Incite Violence or Hatred’ - https://www.foxnews.com/media/irish-citizens-jailed-possessing-material-likely-incite-violence-hatred https://www.foxnews.com/media/irish-citizens-jailed-possessi... If you don't trust Fox enough, their article does link to the text of the bill, directly by the Irish government: https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/bills/bill/2022/105/ https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/bills/bill/2022/105/ I'd link to a more trustworthy source, like the New York Times, but they are curiously silent on this bill.
- mk67 4y ago
- josephcsible 4y agoShould pencils and paper be restricted too, since they can also be used to make illegal content?
- okdood64 4y agoCounterpoint: Should purchasing metal be banned because it could be used to make an illegal weapon? It's about the ease of acquiring it.