4 ms·
Looking at the Talk page itself (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Haymarket_affair&diff=prev&oldid=265741836 http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?t
by scott_s 15y ago
Looking at the Talk page itself (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Haymarket_affair&diff=prev&oldid=265741836 http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Haymarket_aff..., at the bottom, thanks zqfm), it was not clear to me reading his Chronicle article that he did not cite the primary sources in Wikipedia. Rather, in Wikipedia, he cites his own blog post, and in that blog post, he cites primary sources.
As ZeroGravitas points out, consider the case of a crank who links to his own blog as a source, and that blog post cites primary evidence. The Wikipedia editors now have a job that is identical to academic peer-review. I don't think that should be their job.
- angersock 15y agoThe Wikipedia editors now have a job that is identical to academic peer-review. I don't think that should be their job. Then why have editors? God forbid that, if you take on the mantle of vetting articles, you actually exert some intellectual effort.
- scott_s 15y agoBecause now Wikipedia editors are required to have the same expertise in each subject as academics who spend their careers in those subjects. I submit that model is clearly not sustainable, and quite different from not expecting them to expend intellectual effort. Wikipedia is not a place for original research for exactly this reason. Once something has gone through peer review, and is published somewhere, then it can be used in Wikipedia. I think that's reasonable. Wikipedia editors are then relying on a particular subject's community of experts instead of having to be those experts themselves. I think it's also important to note that this model is the same as any other encyclopedia.
- angersock 15y agoWikipedia would seem like a great place for original research, right? It's trivial to get people to check over claims, and you have a place to discuss issues (Talk pages), and the person doing the research can cite their references right there and get called out on it if they don't.
- tptacek 15y agoTo manage the process of accepting contributions at random from anonymous Internet users. Note that Wikipedia doesn't have "editors" in the sense of a newspaper or magazine; every user is an editor.
- angersock 15y agoIt's not a strictly flat hierarchy, though, is it? And so not every user has equal power, right? I'm not completely versed in the Byzantine system of Wikipedia, but the whole thing is based (somehow) on seniority, right? It would seem, then, that the system would self-select for people who spend more time on Wikipedia than doing useful research, right?
- DanBC 15y agoIn theory every editor (even those without an account) have equal weight. It doesn't matter if you know what the subject is or not. It doesn't matter how long you've been working on WP. What does matter is if you can source everything you write to a 'reliable' source; and if you can write clearly. Obviously, in practice this is not the case. Anon editors are often treated like dirt; people making 15,000 twinkle edits feel as if they should have some extra power or consideration. And there's a bunch of meta stuff which is, frankly, toxic and probably doing a lot of harm.
- tptacek 15y agoAdmins can lock articles and ban users, but they cannot use their powers to trump non-admins and get their text into articles. The WP admin community is a shark tank. Admins could try to use their status to thump people around article talk pages, but --- and this isn't an exaggeration --- there are at least 2 other admins watching commit-by-commit what any given admin does, looking for some policy slip-up they can use to incite drama. In practice, in the vast majority of articles, there is no seniority. At best, a person with a demonstrated history of building and grooming an article over a year or so might expect some deference when newcomer attempts a dramatic change. That deference is a good thing, and has nothing to do with adminship.
- andrewla 15y agoThis is really a key point that renders 90% of the discussion of this moot (bringing in a primary source to resolve it, too!). From reading that, it appears that there was just a misunderstanding -- all the author had to do was link in the wikipedia article to the reliable sources. Instead, he linked on his blog to the reliable sources. To me, this simple misunderstanding pretty much makes the Chronicle article lose all credence -- if I'm reading a wikipedia article and I find a factual assertion dubious (or just wonder where it came from) I don't want a link to some blog (especially since it appears that I can't even read the link -- I get some sort of login page). Instead, I want the link (or reference) to the original sources. For factual disagreements, any sort of primary or reliable secondary source is more than sufficient to have resolved this.