14 ms·
Asus Ally Emulates PS3, Nintendo Switch, Xbox 360 with Ease
- nerdjon 4y agoI really wish this thing had 4 back buttons instead of just 2. If it did it would likely be an easy upgrade for me from the Steam Deck. I already primarily use mine with Windows anyways.
- theodric 4y agoI have yet to find a game that makes use of the back buttons on the Steam Deck, so it wouldn't bother me. Windows would bother me plenty, tho :)
- ikornaselur 4y agoYou make use of them, to remap any functionality that makes sense to you. I usually just remap 1-2 buttons to the back buttons though, but have used all 4. It's quite nice when you set it up and tends to free your thumb from moving between the touchpad/joystick and buttons all the time.
- nerdjon 4y agoI do a lot of my gaming with the Xbox Elite Controller. So I tend to remap some buttons to the back triggers for easier access (particularly for FPS). So the back triggers for me on the steam deck is for consistency, so I can easily switch between gaming with my elite controller and the steam deck with minimal differences.
- fendy3002 4y agoThe select button is small and hard to reach from left analog, so I plan to remap Dmc V taunt to L4 or 5. Haven't tried it though. If the upcoming AC6 isn't being restricted with console joysticks, I guess the back buttons can be used as more inputs for weapons or extensions.
- jxi 4y agoIsn’t Switch emulation illegal?
- pengstrom 4y agoIn principle no, but you can't get to a functioning state without illegally obtaining the signing keys.
- lytedev 4y agoHow is key extraction illegal? I'm running code on a piece of hardware I purchased, no?
- avhon1 4y agoIn the Unites States, it's a violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.
- Natanael_L 3y agoSince you own the console you dump the keys from, nope
- Gigachad 4y agoDepends what country. Bypassing drm is not illegal everywhere.
- branon 4y agoNintendo would like you to think so. Depends on jurisdiction I suppose. Not in very many places. Emulating other machines isn't illegal, Switch is no different.
- rychco 4y agoEmulation in general is not illegal, piracy is the only aspect of it that is “illegal”.
- 4y ago
- aliasxneo 4y agoIt'll be interesting to see how it fairs against the Steam Deck. Given the option, I'd still take the Deck hands down because Linux + Valve customer support. I would dread the moment I have to try and contact Asus support.
- branon 4y agoIt's decent competition for sure. Significantly higher spec versus Deck on paper but they are pushing the envelope for powerful x86 machines in this form factor. Seems like you can melt the battery extremely quickly if you try, since the Ally is a 1080p device. Seen benches around the 50 minute mark. Really no different than running Deck for 90 minutes playing Elden Ring at 800p. Ally works with Asus' proprietary eGPU enclosure, theoretically can expand horsepower even more. Again though only so much you can do with the form factor. I get using a dock but dedicated accessories seem like they'd provide diminishing returns versus conventional PC hardware. Especially at the price point. Base model Deck blows this thing out of the water value-wise.
- ElectricalUnion 4y agoThe proprietary eGPU enclosure is a very big downside in my point of view - granted, AMD has bad support for thunderbolt, but it instead makes the gpd win choice of industry standard OCuLink port look like an awesome idea.
- wlesieutre 4y agoDO YOU WANT TO USE BING? HOW ABOUT NOW? OR MAYBE NOW? HAVE A NEW DESKTOP BING SEARCH BAR! Windows 11 on a small touchscreen sounds like an awful idea to me.
- nirav72 4y agoAny version of windows on a small screen is a bad idea. I had couple of windows mobile devices back in the day. (Early 2000s). Then a htc phone with windows mobile (2004) Really clunky. Microsoft should’ve realized then that windows should’ve stayed on the desktop.
- smcleod 4y ago> runs windows No thanks.
- smlavine 4y agoThe touchpads really are incredible on the Steam Deck. So much less awkward than twin stick, as someone who grew up playing on PC. That alone is reason to stick with the Deck.
- Moldoteck 4y agoPlaying age of empires 3 on deck is so good with touchpads...
- adamkittelson 4y agoThe ROG Ally seems like a really nice piece of hardware. Having said that, I cannot possibly stress enough how bad of a time you will have if it breaks and you have to deal with an RMA / ASUS customer support. You'd probably save yourself a lot of time and frustration by just throwing it in the trash and buying a new one or a Steam Deck if something goes wrong with it.
- tiahura 4y agoUse a cc with a generous warranty provision.
- muhfuhkuh 4y agoA travel card that uses Visa Infinite is your best bet here. I have the Capital One Venture X and one of my prime use cases for it (aside from travel upgrades and points transfer) is electronics purchases.
- sfmike 4y agothere's a lot of drama currently with how their bios update is the only fix to burning cpu's and it void's warranty so you lose warranty to fix their mistake. Based on that I won't be getting a ally even though really wanted to.
- messe 4y ago> there's a lot of drama currently with how their bios update is the only fix to burning cpu's and it void's warranty so you lose warranty to fix their mistake How is that even legal? Makes me glad I’m in the EU to be honest.
- spuz 4y agoAsus states that despite their boilerplate warranty limitations for beta BIOS, they would honour the warranty in this particular case. https://www.asus.com/us/news/ihctikmgahafyrib/?tduid=969491bf92d2b4b64ea6c8e95d4e3dd9 https://www.asus.com/us/news/ihctikmgahafyrib/?tduid=969491b...
- steele 4y agoGPD Win Max 2r on the 7840u is a alternative option if you want a physical keyboard and hall effect thumbsticks. Might be good to 3d print grips to compensate for the laptop form factor vs handheld. So far, I haven't seen anyone divine noticeable benefits for the z1 extreme over the 7840u, at the TDP the OPs cited emulators require for stable frame rates.
- LegitShady 4y agoHaving trouble understanding how this low value content puff piece made it up so high on HN.
- diffeomorphism 4y agoBecause the topic is interesting even if the article is not.
- bhaney 4y agoThe Steam Deck also emulates those same consoles easily (anecdotally, my Deck runs Tears of the Kingdom just as well as or better than an actual Switch), so I'd be surprised if the superior-spec'd Ally didn't.
- mortenjorck 4y agoI’m out of the loop, but I had no idea the Switch was already at what, from the tenor of this comment, would appear to be a Dreamcast level of rootedness. Is that the case?
- privacyking 4y agoThe original switch revision had an unpatchable hardware vulnerability that let you run unsigned code from the bootrom. It's been broken since year one.
- wiz21c 4y agoIf you can find the video explaining how they did it (I guess it was presented at chaos computer club), it's a must see: very funny and enlightening ! (for a geek, that is)
- Lutzb 4y agoFor your viewing pleasure: https://media.ccc.de/v/34c3-8941-console_security_-_switch https://media.ccc.de/v/34c3-8941-console_security_-_switch https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ec4NgWRE8ik https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ec4NgWRE8ik
- bhaney 4y agoI'm not sure what you mean by rootedness in this context. The Switch can be rooted to run custom software on official hardware (though I think it's difficult on the latest hardware and firmware revisions), but I don't root mine personally and don't know much about it. The state of rooting is pretty much entirely separate from the state of emulation, which is doing very well. There are currently two major Switch emulators that I'm aware of and they can both play thousands of Switch games just fine, with various tradeoffs and support for game mods.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoThe Ally's single strongest selling point for me is its dramatically quieter fans. Small high pitched fans like get put into devices like laptops and the Deck are grating. While the increased resolution is nice, I could live without that. You don't need a ton of resolution at that screen size. On the other hand, its better colors and contrast as well as adaptive sync are nice. Adaptive sync especially is a no-brainer given how many games will have their framerates jumping around on a pogo stick due to power limits. I really hope that the Deck gets improvements in these areas before I make a decision on buying a handheld gaming PC, because the rest of the Deck is more compelling than what Asus is offering here.
- bhaney 4y agoThe Steam Deck is very user-repairable. You can buy a quieter fan, open up the Deck, and swap out the stock fan very easily. It's probably one of the simplest parts to replace.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoEh, most people don't want to start taking their console apart and look up fans to buy online. They want to start to playing games on it and be satisfied with what's out of the box. The repairability and hackability is an asset, but not the main selling point why so many buy it.
- pjmlp 4y agoThat isn't the target audience of game consoles.
- bhaney 4y agoI'm responding to an individual's personal complaint posted on a forum called "Hacker News," not defending a product's fit with its target audience in general.
- geraldwhen 4y ago
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoNot a fan of the design at all, it looks like a toy.. I'm still waiting for an upgraded https://gpd.hk/gpdwin4 https://gpd.hk/gpdwin4, the physical keyboard behind the screen is a must have..
- tirpen 4y agoIt probably looks like a toy because it is a toy. There is nothing wrong with being a toy, so why should they try to disguise it as something else?
- rowanG077 4y agoHonestly these new consoles are too big for me. I'm not a small guy but the steam deck is simply way too large imo. the GPD win 4 looks MUCH better in that department, but I haven't seen it in real life. A Z1 extreme or 7840U in a newly released GPD win 5 or 4 Pro Max or something would be amazing.
- fendy3002 4y agoJust see it and it's an amazing design, with how there's something similar with trackpad and back buttons. However I'm afraid that sliding monitor can easily break/ lower the lifespan of the machine.
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoI had a Blackberry Priv for few years and it never failed me, and that's a phone, so I was constantly sliding the screen For the Win4 you won't need to slide the screen as often, so I don't expect it to break anytime soon
- Bancakes 4y agoPS3 emulation still requires a very beefy PC. Something like a ryzen 5600x as a minimum. I don’t see this thing running many games.
- Wolfenstein98k 4y agoFantastic to see. This generation of games is very underrated, and mostly lost due to difficulty emulating.
- PostOnce 4y agoXenia is the only 360 emulator and "18%" of games are "playable"; that means 82% aren't. On RPCS3, 30% of games aren't rated "playable" because they crash or barely run at all. So you might say instead "Asus Ally Crappily Emulates a Small Fraction of PS3 and 360 games... with ease!" Switch emulators are a different story. I felt I had to comment because it feels like a dishonest ad campaign.
- Xelbair 4y agoNo one cares about emulator performance/compatibility - as that's a metric inherent to emulators themselves. The only metric that matters is how many of those games that are 'playable' can be played on that device, as that shows capabilities of hardware.
- DuckyC 4y agoI would argue that the end consumer of the device and emulator cares... Which i guess is the point of the previous comment.
- thih9 4y ago> Switch emulators are a different story. Can you elaborate? As in: would you say that switch can be evaluated with ease or is it even worse? Also: what about gameplay elements that require certain hardware, e.g. is gyro aiming just missing?
- peanuty1 4y agoMost Switch games can be emulated very well on the Steam Deck.
- joenot443 4y agoGlad someone familiar with the scene is commenting. What's the longterm roadmap for Xenia, do people expect it'll reach Dolphin levels of playability? I remember using Dolphin in the 2010s and it still blew my mind; now it's one of the finest emulators ever made. Is there similar hope for Xenia?
- dur-randir 4y agoAsus is your choice if you want an abysmal software support. While it's hardware might be good, I'd stay away from it.
- bouvin 4y agoI'm all for emulation of older platforms for the valid wish to preserve history, but emulation of current hardware and games that can run on current console hardware smacks of piracy.
- Teledhil 4y agoHow can it be piracy if I own the game I'm emulating?
- bouvin 4y agoDo you expect me to believe that all the people, who, say, downloaded the leaked copy of Tears of the Kingdom, dutifully purchased a copy upon release date? Pull the other one, it has got bells on it.
- Teledhil 4y agoSo I guess we can agree that emulation of current hardware and games that can run on current console hardware is not piracy by itself.
- bouvin 4y agoI wrote 'smacks of piracy’ for a reason. But I do not doubt for a moment that the main motivation behind current generation emulation is piracy, and that finding a person with a one to one game library real and emulated is a remarkable feat indeed. These systems and their associated games are neither hard to find, nor difficult to run, unlike older consoles, so there is no excuse if you wish to experience the games as they were intended.
- deafpolygon 4y agoIt's still piracy because it's not a direct copy from your legally owned game.
- deafpolygon 4y ago
- unwind 4y agoI was wondering whether there was an FPGA onboard for emulation, but I couldn't find any mention in the tech specs [1]. I do think there's a typo since there seem to be two models but they are labelled exactly the same as far as I can see. Weird. Also weird/wonderful that this is a handheld device featuring (at the high end, and let me guess it's thermally throttled) a GPU capable of 8.6 TFLOPS while the system consumes no more than 30 W. That is more than the 2001 US supercomputer "ASCI White" [2] did, which at most reached 7.2 TFLOPS. It was housed in 200 cabinets weighing a total of 106 tons, and consuming 3 MW. [1]: https://rog.asus.com/gaming-handhelds/rog-ally/rog-ally-2023/spec/ https://rog.asus.com/gaming-handhelds/rog-ally/rog-ally-2023... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASCI_White https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASCI_White
- datpiff 4y agoNone of the headline consoles have FPGA implementations (at least publicly available).
- dizhn 4y agoI recommend the fantastic Eta Prime YouTube channel for all things related to game emulation. He has a lot of videos on this device too. One video has a good variety of emulators and games with usable power settings for battery saving.