3 ms·
Not in any meaningful way—as evidenced by where they spend their political, social, and institutional capital.
by rayiner 4y ago
Not in any meaningful way—as evidenced by where they spend their political, social, and institutional capital.
- tptacek 4y agoNo. The issue you're advocating for is coded in literally the opposite way as you suggest it is. The opponents of DEI are the principal opponents of inheritance taxation. Well-educated and/or top-quintile professionals are also drastically more likely to support inheritance taxation (as a consequence of 21st century educational polarization). I don't think there's any meaningful connection between institutional DEI and economic justice, but you can't just make things up to drag DEI into unrelated arguments.
- rayiner 4y ago> don't think there's any meaningful connection between institutional DEI and economic justice DEI is how the upper quantile has co-opted economic justice rhetoric while entrenching itself in economic sectors (finance, tech) and behind policies (immigration) that deepen economic divides. It’s Wall Street’s brilliant makeover (in response to 2008), which has created a national conversation wherein being a racist plumber in Michigan is somehow worse than working in private equity. It’s immaterial what educated professionals purport to believe in. Politics isn’t just about supporting this policy or that policy. It’s about how you spend political capital to construct a majority coalition that can manifest policies. Upper quantile professionals have spent their political capital to create a majority capable of enacting their preferred social policies. When they wage trench warfare to make sure kids learn about race in history class, that’s political capital they didn’t spend making sure kids learn about the history of the labor movement. These are choices. And as a result of those choices, upper quantile professionals have created a Democratic Party that includes Wall Street, but excludes much of the working class (and excludes most of the white working class). As a result, that coalition is wholly incapable of addressing economic inequality.
- tptacek 4y agoAgain: DEI's most vocal opponents are the ones legislatively blocking any reform to inheritance taxes; in fact, they're attempting to repeal the Estate Tax altogether, as they have been since the 1990s, when the effort was a plot point on The West Wing. There is no reasonable connection to draw between DEI and a resistance to taxing generational wealth.
- hitekker 4y agoThis is a cogent analysis. To go further: I've noticed that rich, white tech professionals gravitate to social causes that pay lip service to economic equality, but only demand action on race. The mis-priorization and pretense you speak serves as a useful self-deception. Disclaim their own race, because they're already on top, and protect the wealth they've accumulated and now identify with.