3 ms·
That might take 5 or 10 years to reach endgame, but it seems like a less direct, but still viable way to complete the war. This plan would have killed more peo
by CamperBob2 4y ago
That might take 5 or 10 years to reach endgame, but it seems like a less direct, but still viable way to complete the war.
This plan would have killed more people, and caused far more net suffering, than simply nuking a couple of cities.
As a similar example, it's true that letting MacArthur use nukes would have been a monstrous act of evil that would have put the US up there with the Nazis in the annals of infamy... but it's also true that more North Koreans would be alive and well today if we had. We could hardly have done more damage with our bombs than the Kim family did with ideology.
Of course that's a simplistic assessment that ignores the consequences of normalizing nuclear warfare at a time when its destructive capacity was ramping up at an exponential rate. But it is entirely fair to apply it to Japan at the end of WWII, when the lesson was relatively cheap to learn.