7 ms·
I'm continuously mystified as to why people who are heavily involved with WP seem mystified as to why the trends in contributions are going into the toilet. It
by bane 15y ago
I'm continuously mystified as to why people who are heavily involved with WP seem mystified as to why the trends in contributions are going into the toilet.
It's really very simple:
1) It's the highly problematic notability guideline abuse
2) It's the deletionists who think it's their job to lobotomize WP and delete knowledge out of the public sphere
3) It's the super editors who enable the deletionists and there's no reasonable mechanism to police either them or the deletionists.
I agree that there's a lack of oversight. The self-licking ice cream cone of the WP community built bureaucracy is finally starting to come apart because there's no reasonable way to participate in the bureaucracy unless you are an established part of it.
In the end, WP will be an interesting curiosity, populated by people drunk on the power their carved out fiefdom in the tangled mess of WP processes gives them, typing furiously about how great their contribution was to the great edifice of WP while their deletionist minions slowly burn the castly down around them until all that's left is a slightly dog eared copy of the Encyclopedia Britannica.
edit reading through the rest of the comments, this idea is repeated over and over and over again. It's sad really, there are vast communities of smart people actually telling WP what the problem is, and every once in a while a clueless editor pops his head out of the vault and asks "why are edits going down?" when it appears the rest of the planet outside of WP...the potential editor pool...already know the answer, but WP won't accept it.
- DanBC 15y agoIt's also the huge number of juvenile editors using automatic revert tools (eg Twinkle) who think making many reverts and slapping warning banners on user pages is a useful way to clean Wikipedia. You get the feeling they're on some adolescent power trip. The whole "VANDAL PATROL" badge thing reeks. See also the antipathy towards IP editors, who provide many useful edits and who could be encouraged to return but who are often treated like dirt. See also the bizarre over-concern about usernames. WP has software limits on user-names, and extensive filters. Usernames need only gentle filtering, yet there have been more than one notice board for user name action. Most of Wikipedia is great, and it's possible to ignore a lot of the meta-stench, but sometimes quiet productive editors get caught up in drama-mongering idiocy.
- conradfr 15y agoI used to clean up and correct small mistakes or vandalism, I don't have an account. My corrections were usually reverted almost instantaneously and I had to insist to push them, even when just cleaning dirty words by bored teenagers. Does someone even read edits before reverting them ? Nowadays, I just correct nothing and don't bother.
- bane 15y ago"Does someone even read edits before reverting them ?" I don't think they do. I'm convinced that they won't even read them through the entire appeals process. In the world of WP, the reversion holds more weight than the actual content that was reverted.