16 ms·
I believe that Wikipedia's key is that it's finite. It has a goal. Many of its pages are static, or evolve slowly. It wants to reach an end state that grows onl
by jfengel 4y ago
I believe that Wikipedia's key is that it's finite. It has a goal. Many of its pages are static, or evolve slowly. It wants to reach an end state that grows only at the edges, and only when there is new knowledge.
When it fails, pages get locked. Misbehavior is corrected by going to the last good state, not by trying to move forward.
Wikipedia succeeds by not being social media. It doesn't want engagement. It doesn't care if you leave. It enforces ego-less-ness by not showing you names; it doesn't want your contributions, especially not on general topics that people enjoy "debating".
That's hard to replicate elsewhere, because it has done that thing well. It's the go-to source for that kind of interaction.
- scoofy 4y agoMy main personal project is a golf wiki using this model, because I really admire it. I talk to people about how the site is growing, and it is slowly, but I let them know that I doubt it will "catch on" for probably a decade, because any type of fast growth involves purchasing data (with costs/limitations) instead of getting it for free from everyday golfers. >>But the miracle stands and is asking from all of us to turn faith into science, find ways to replicate the essence of Wikipedia across all domains. Yup. Much of golf business seems to be pretty extractive to me, and the game is already too fucking expensive, I can currently run it very cheaply, and it's a fun hobby that's been rewarding seeing people use it more and more. If anyone is interested: https://golfcourse.wiki https://golfcourse.wiki
- madeofpalk 4y agoPersonally, I attribute this more to Wikipedia's non-commercial nature. It's goal has a clear end state because it isn't chasing endless growth that for-profit/vc-backed companies do. I believe also it's possible to have a social media network that is non-commercial and is successful because it has no need to pump engagement to chase endless growth.
- wanttocomment 4y agoI'm not sure that's the case. It has an ever expanding budget and picks up new political causes often.
- themitigating 4y agoHow does either of those things make it like a business or chasing profit?
- wanttocomment 4y agoThe specific attribute mentioned is the pressure to continue to grow, instead of executing a simple mission. Wikipedia doesn't do that at all, and clearly feels pressure to grow power and expand into new domains.
- bawolff 4y agoThe last time wikimedia really did that was wikidata and that was a decade ago. Although i suppose the ongoing abstract wikipedia stuff is an example of that. By and large i dont think there has been much in way of expansion attempts. Most of them are from long ago.
- account42 4y agohttps://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fc/WMF_Support_and_Revenue%2C_Expenses_and_Net_Assets_at_Year_End.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fc/WMF_Supp...
- bawolff 4y agoWhat does that have to do with expanding into new domains? Its just a restructuring of how some of the funding works.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jfengel 4y agoI believe any social site will inevitably devolve into spam and trolling, and arguments about why my poor behavior doesn't quite cross the line. It has to constantly solicit new content, even if it were completely devoid of financial goal, because it's fundamentally read-write. Wikipedia aims for a read only state and will happily throw out any contribution even slightly out of line since that's not its mission. It's anti-social.
- andrepd 4y agoThat's trivially proven false by the numerous examples of social sites that subsist for decades with a healthy community.
- ghaff 4y agoThere have been other social information sites that failed not so much because of an explicit commercial angle but because any such site can easily be overrun by the grifter and scammers.
- detourdog 4y agoThat is the irony to me. Good things seem to require a strong vision and discipline. This often comes from an individual forceful enough to maintain focus for the group.
- themitigating 4y agoIt can also come from rules that are enforced by a group of individuals
- detourdog 4y agoYes it can, I think that it is rarer form. I can't think of any but I'm sure they exist.
- evolve2k 4y agoThis belief is founded on a falsehood, specifically it rests upon some version of the popularised economic theory of the “tragedy of the commons”. Short version. The original Tradgedy of the Commons paper that much modern economic theory rests upon and that is a key pillar that justifies the value of privatisation has found to have been made up. Elinor Ostrom spent over 20 years debunking that there’s nothing you can do, and distilled a set of principals that any community can enact to protect and preserve a commons. By example, here’s Mozilla led research on ‘A Practical Framework for Applying Ostrom’s Principles to Data Commons Governance’ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/blog/a-practical-framework-for-applying-ostroms-principles-to-data-commons-governance/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/blog/a-practical-framework...
- sandworm101 4y ago>> It enforces ego-less-ness by not showing you names; it doesn't want your contributions, especially not on general topics that people enjoy "debating". Every time I have tried to edit anything in Wikipedia I have run into a very ego-driven community of long-term editors who don't much care for outsiders playing in their sandbox. The levels of "proof" and "citation" demanded to make even the smallest correction, often far beyond anything backing the preexisting copy, means only those with ego-driven determination are likely to have their edits stick. I do care a little that a wikipedia article is incorrect about a topic related to my profession. But I don't care enough to engage some armchair lawyer/soldier in an epic back-and-forth debate over a period of days/weeks. So I back off and just let the errors sit.
- JieJie 4y agoI love Wikipedia. I agree all the good things people are saying about it here and all the people supporting Wikipedia. That being said. Wikipedia isn't the truth. I know this for a fact, because there are historical articles that I was there to witness that are not even close to being documented correctly by Wikipedia. Wikipedia simply collates narratives that can be drawn from citable evidence. Still, their definition of citable evidence is about as workable as I can imagine. If one doesn't like it, one is invited to get your side of the story published in a reputable source, and then cited. It outsources the process of fact-checking to the free press, such as it exists on the internet. There is a clip from Aaron Sorkin's The Newsroom that humorously illustrates[0]. [0] https://youtu.be/3wla-vK4Buw https://youtu.be/3wla-vK4Buw I still think Wikipedia is better than we probably deserve and I'm glad we are training training AI on it. I also hope that they are trained on the edit discussions, because that is the AI that's going to really understand humanity.
- ryandrake 4y ago> Every time I have tried to edit anything in Wikipedia I have run into a very ego-driven community of long-term editors who don't much care for outsiders playing in their sandbox. This is likely similar to the force that keeps StackOverflow from growing and staying useful. StackOverflow is basically "Answers to programming questions as if it were still 2009" because any new content gets quickly removed as "duplicate" of content that existed a decade ago. I've seen the same thing happen on OpenStreetMap. You make an edit, and some old-timer comes in and just reverts it. I even once got an angry message there where someone "claimed" an area in a city for himself. I'm not a Redditor, but I understand Reddit has similar problems with mods. Not sure the solution. It's hard to develop a community of passionate volunteers, but every time a platform does build this community up, the content calcifies under an inflexible cabal of power-mad volunteers.