4 ms·
Didn't suburbia evolved organicaly from regular cities? Should we just accept it, because it's organical growth, so it's optimal? There's place for organical g
by ajuc 15y ago
Didn't suburbia evolved organicaly from regular cities? Should we just accept it, because it's organical growth, so it's optimal?
There's place for organical growth, and there's place for upfront design, both in programming and in urban development.
The best cities layout I've seen was consequences of organical deveopment within some rules - see most old european cities. Building rules specified how broad should streets be, how high the building can be in each region, which functions can't be performed in which part of the city, which way should new streets be built. There were reasons for these rules.
In my country after 50 years of communism (and hideus commie blocks, etc) we went throught 10 years of "free for all" development of cities.
Believe me - I hate totalitarism, but in these first 10 years of freedom cities got much worse - wallmarts in the city center, ugly cheap postmodern buildings near 500 year beutiful houses, commercials hiding half of the city besides them. Now, since +- 10 years there is some regulations coming back, and I'm happy with that.
- bane 15y agoIt's interesting that you bring up European cities. I was about to type a post offering the counter example, New York (specifically Manhattan) and to some extent Chicago. Both are products of a strong "framework" of transit and utilities, but the growth within this framework has been more or less organic...all buildings don't have to be the same height a la Paris. I've felt that organically grown cities, of which most major European cities are good examples, are very sub-optimal for because of the haphazard and random way the cities are laid out. It many such cities, the old, medieval core became so bogged down that cars aren't even allowed and it's basically a pedestrian heaven. Navigation is hard in these cities, traffic is usually a mess without modern development to route around the "organicness" of the city centers, as a result certain types of goods and services...namely anything to do with lots of manufacturing or bulk goods, ends up moving away from the city core. And while it means that the cores tends to become very pedestrian friendly, they really just sort of end up as extended outdoor shopping malls with some housing for the shop workers above. It's interesting in some of the older Asian cities which have very old histories, say Seoul, the the haphazard, medieval-style organic planning has given way to a large effort to put the major thoroughfares on a grid and as old areas are redeveloped, to do so with a heavily planned development policy in mind. The city was simply not able to handle the growth and population demands the organic system created. There's a reason Paris' business center is not in Paris' geographic center, and central London has restricted driving zones, and most of Barcelona's population enjoys the 19th century planned developed residential areas, while the older parts are being turned into tourist hotels, malls, restaurants and more shopping areas.
- ajuc 15y agoWell, for me most of the disadventages you listed are adventages :) Pedestrian streets in the center, industry forced out of the city, services concentrating in the center, cars not viable for in-city transport, well developed public transport. Also, I don't think medieval and older cities were not planed. They were just designed without cars and milions of people in mind. With cars I think it's actualy good - cars and cities don't mix well. BTW: I know whole city designed by one architect as "ideal town" in 1580, and built according to these plans. It's quite nice to live - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zamo%C5%9B%C4%87 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zamo%C5%9B%C4%87
- bane 15y agoYeah, it totally depends on perspective. I actually love my time as a pedestrian tourist in European cities, hate them with a passion as a driver or when trying to do business. It's interesting how many old cities were started as a heavily planned Roman garrison towns, straight boulevards, right angles everywhere, etc. Then those cores turned into the medieval rats nests we're familiar with today, then usually outside of that there was a building boom in the 19th century and a return to some kind of order. But the advantage of the unplanned medieval layout is that the streets are usually an attempt at a shortest path between two interesting points.